Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby The Lesson topic #2657554

Subject: "Some key parts in your post" Previous topic | Next topic
OldPro
Member since Dec 10th 2002
34401 posts
Fri Feb-03-12 04:40 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
33. "Some key parts in your post"
In response to In response to 31


  

          

>she's a pop music Marilyn Monroe.

and why is MM the iconic symbol she is?

>Janet has had a nice respectable career but even in her prime
>she wasn't as big as Madonna

Wasn't as big with who? And why?

>If you want to see black artists who were at Madonna's level,
>two of them came out of the eighties alongside her: Michael
>and Prince.

Both men... somewhat androgynous non threatening men at that. But beyond that the sheer fact Madonna in ranked along side those two is telling in and of itself. We can play the "which one of these things is not like the other" game if you wish.

>It's been a while since a black woman had anything like
>Madonna status though. Mariah is probably closest.

Closest in shade too

>But to be
>fair, no white women have that status either. We can talk
>about Gaga if she's still doing it in two decades, but for now
>she's just aspiring. Madonna's the only female star in her
>weight class since she came on the scene - that really says it
>all.

Every era has had them... From Judy Garland to Barbra Streisand there has always been a dominate white female star. All you need to do is look back at how they were revered compared to their black female counterparts if you want to really compare. If Gladys Knight had gotten Streisand level love then maybe you could make an argument.

Really man a lot of the shit I said in the opening post was over the top... but to act like race isn't playing a role in how female pop stars are handled is pretty damn naive.

_________________________________
Reunion Radio Podcasts
Bringing Together Five Decades of R&B/Funk/Soul/Dance

http://reunionradio.blogspot.com/

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Proof of the industry's double standard: Janet vs Madonna [View all] , OldPro, Fri Feb-03-12 11:31 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
is this a Friday Fun post?
Feb 03rd 2012
1
Old man rant is more like it
Feb 03rd 2012
2
Dogg... I've nothing to add but I LMMFAO.
Feb 03rd 2012
3
not too mention there ain't no love lost between the two
Feb 03rd 2012
4
lol "Joyce Dewett" - hahahaha... yoooo
Feb 03rd 2012
6
I almost typed something off that, but I chilled...
Feb 03rd 2012
9
HA! Maxx went INNNNN! lmao
Feb 04th 2012
48
you're giving Madonna's acting too much credit...
Feb 05th 2012
51
hahahaha... *daps* seriously.
Feb 03rd 2012
5
yeah I thought the same thing....
Feb 03rd 2012
7
i guess Madonna being a Single Mother gets her a pass?
Feb 03rd 2012
21
Pretty much - I'm still surprised ppl didn't call Timberlake OUT!
Feb 03rd 2012
23
RE: Proof of the industry's double standard: Janet vs Madonna
Feb 03rd 2012
8
RE: Proof of the industry's double standard: Janet vs Madonna
Feb 03rd 2012
10
Madonna's Sex book was 20 years ago, though.
Feb 03rd 2012
11
Dude I told you I was on a rant
Feb 03rd 2012
12
      LOL
Feb 03rd 2012
13
           *rubs hands together*
Feb 03rd 2012
15
aka the Cave Bitch stay winnin'
Feb 03rd 2012
14
Fear Of A Black Titty reswipe for semi relevancy
Feb 03rd 2012
16
Desperately needing an editor, but I like it nonetheless
Feb 03rd 2012
17
if it's because of mispellings, that's my fault
Feb 03rd 2012
18
Some valid points here but..........
Feb 03rd 2012
19
      donna summers never gets her due and Millie Jackson is unsung..
Feb 03rd 2012
20
But Janet got the Super Bowl tap before Madonna?
Feb 03rd 2012
22
they asked Madonna for years for one thing
Feb 03rd 2012
24
      Justin Timberlake got off easy
Feb 03rd 2012
26
      Somehow I doubt that stunt was his idea...
Feb 03rd 2012
27
           Timberfake wasn't trying to be Nursed when he was pulling
Feb 03rd 2012
46
This post is really stupid.
Feb 03rd 2012
25
RE: This post is really stupid.
Feb 03rd 2012
28
shut up Cracker
Feb 03rd 2012
29
Is there any compelling reason to check for Janet in 2012?
Feb 03rd 2012
30
Its not about relevancy its about hypocrisy
Feb 03rd 2012
32
      Janet Jackson showed her boob on live TV
Feb 03rd 2012
34
           I love how the super bowl thing is where everyone is getting stuck
Feb 03rd 2012
36
           hey dumbass..pay attention
Feb 03rd 2012
37
It's not about white, it's about status and money
Feb 03rd 2012
31
RE: Some key parts in your post
Feb 03rd 2012
38
      Honestly this is one big circle
Feb 03rd 2012
41
           RE: Honestly this is one big circle
Feb 03rd 2012
43
           RE: Honestly this is one big circle
Feb 05th 2012
53
you forgot Britney Spears she is still a big deal
Feb 03rd 2012
45
yes.
Feb 04th 2012
49
i mean, yeah. n/m
Feb 03rd 2012
35
Talk bro talk
Feb 03rd 2012
39
I mean... no.
Feb 03rd 2012
40
but you realise
Feb 03rd 2012
42
yup. this too.
Feb 04th 2012
50
Madonna has managed her irrelevancy better than Janet
Feb 03rd 2012
44
I Hate To Say It But Janet's Last 2 Albums Wasn't Pop Enough
Feb 04th 2012
47
she got the gay white fanbase on lock. that's why.
Feb 05th 2012
52
nigga, janet pulled out her titty tryna be provactive....
Feb 05th 2012
54
Proof of the blah blah blah: Janet vs Madonna vs. M.I.A.?
Feb 05th 2012
55

Lobby The Lesson topic #2657554 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com