Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby The Lesson topic #2526669

Subject: "AFKAP sez: Folk music is boring, corny and childish" Previous topic | Next topic
lonesome_d
Charter member
30443 posts
Fri Mar-18-11 08:51 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"AFKAP sez: Folk music is boring, corny and childish"


          

I'll be back with commentary

*start swipe*

I'm still struggling to "get" folk music, to be honest.

My interest in folk has always been largely anthropological in nature but for a range of reasons, I've never been able to forge an emotional connection with it.

Like, I can dig the Dylan strain and the post-rock stuff, but I just can't grab on to the Engish and Irish ballads and some of the traditional American songs. Probably because in the era in which I grew up (of course, I know you grew up in the same era).

I remember reading a Frank Miller interview in which he said he never felt a connection to the radical politics of the 1960s because around the time he was in high school, all his teachers were hippies or ex-hippies, so their whole culture to him felt like the establishment that he rebelled against.

For me, those songs are the tunes that came pre-programmed in your Fisher-Price toy phonogram... or they evoke for me dorky, beardy camp counsellors strumming acoustic guitars around the bonfire. Or worse yet, their melodies recall nursery rhymes (obviously they come from the same sources as most popular nursery rhymes). So somehow, the shit just feels childish to me.

I struggle to conceive of a time that playing and listening to this kind of music was at one point considered the extremely hip thing to do. I understand it on an intellectual level but I don't get it!

-------
so I'm in a band now:
album ---> http://greenwoodburns.bandcamp.com/releases
Soundcloud ---> http://soundcloud.com/greenwood-burns

my own stuff -->http://soundcloud.com/lonesomedstringband

avy by buckshot_defunct

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


AFKAP sez: Folk music is boring, corny and childish [View all] , lonesome_d, Fri Mar-18-11 08:51 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
the scope of conversation
Mar 18th 2011
1
For me, as always, it's all about context.
Mar 18th 2011
21
      RE: For me, as always, it's all about context.
Mar 18th 2011
28
      RE: For me, as always, it's all about context.
Mar 19th 2011
54
           LOL
Mar 19th 2011
56
           that's not sidetracking at all - in fact I kind of wanted to
Mar 21st 2011
63
      more on this
Mar 21st 2011
65
suprised about this
Mar 18th 2011
2
RE: suprised about this
Mar 18th 2011
7
i AM behind the *notion*
Mar 18th 2011
24
      that is more in line with what i would have expected
Mar 18th 2011
29
RE: AFKAP sez: Folk music is boring, corny and childish
Mar 18th 2011
3
lol
Mar 18th 2011
4
RE: lol
Mar 18th 2011
6
RE: AFKAP sez: Folk music is boring, corny and childish
Mar 18th 2011
19
It is the latter that I am referring to.
Mar 18th 2011
25
I have a hard time defining modern folk music
Mar 18th 2011
5
it's many things to many people
Mar 18th 2011
8
      yea i agree more with your definition of folk
Mar 18th 2011
11
Trying to think of how to approach this
Mar 18th 2011
9
RE: Trying to think of how to approach this
Mar 18th 2011
12
yep
Mar 18th 2011
13
RE: Trying to think of how to approach this
Mar 18th 2011
14
      RE: Trying to think of how to approach this
Mar 18th 2011
15
      i'll post some links when i get back
Mar 18th 2011
18
      It depends on what kind of 'Yoruba stuff' you mean.
Mar 18th 2011
27
      You're right to an extent.
Mar 18th 2011
26
           *shrug* I fucks with these
Mar 18th 2011
36
                Actually, the Nigerian folk stuff I tend to like
Mar 18th 2011
41
further
Mar 18th 2011
10
ha! talk about incendiary subject lines!
Mar 18th 2011
16
only for a select audience
Mar 18th 2011
17
on: trad songs
Mar 18th 2011
20
My problem is mostly with the English and American trad songs
Mar 18th 2011
22
      Understood
Mar 18th 2011
30
           RE: Understood
Mar 18th 2011
32
Contemporary Folk music is meh... the classics are awesome.
Mar 18th 2011
23
I dislike people generically strumming guitars and lyric-based music...
Mar 18th 2011
31
not surprising
Mar 18th 2011
34
Bellman's most famous song:
Mar 18th 2011
50
RE: I dislike people generically strumming guitars and lyric-based music...
Mar 18th 2011
35
on: edge
Mar 18th 2011
37
      y'know, about this...
Mar 18th 2011
49
I got so much out of that response.
Mar 18th 2011
40
on: corniness and camp
Mar 18th 2011
33
LOL y'all checked this out yet?
Mar 18th 2011
38
won't play
Mar 18th 2011
39
plays for me...
Mar 18th 2011
42
      ok it plays for me too...
Mar 18th 2011
43
           'Friday' is a song that has become a viral sensation
Mar 18th 2011
44
                Yeah, it's bad.
Mar 18th 2011
45
                That's a question folks have been asking
Mar 18th 2011
46
                clearly I'd missed the viral sensation
Mar 18th 2011
47
                oops... yeah, wrong link
Mar 18th 2011
48
                i'm loving this song, man
Mar 18th 2011
51
                     I love it too.
Mar 18th 2011
52
                          PLEASE send me both
Mar 18th 2011
53
oh shit.
Mar 20th 2011
57
fire agrees profusely
Mar 19th 2011
55
great post...n/m
Mar 20th 2011
58
Would you consider Iron and Wine "folk" music?
Mar 20th 2011
59
folk rock, heavier on the rock side.
Mar 20th 2011
60
you know?
Mar 20th 2011
61
Actually, it is a bit like American Tropicalia
Mar 20th 2011
62
      whaaaaaaaat
Mar 24th 2011
71
I&W, Bon Iver, bright Eyes, Sufjan, Oldham etc. etc. occupy a niche
Mar 21st 2011
66
btw, I keep thinking about the 'sexiness' (or lack thereof)
Mar 21st 2011
64
btw, watched this last night & it was very relevant to this
Mar 23rd 2011
67
*shrug* i like folk music, everything is not for you to get
Mar 23rd 2011
68
that's hardly the point.
Mar 23rd 2011
69
and what's folk music to you?
Mar 23rd 2011
70

Lobby The Lesson topic #2526669 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com