| Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
 How did Dilla "change" Hip Hop though? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 1
|
 Is this a serious question? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 3
|
 are you seriously comparing Dilla to someone who literally changed |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 5
|
| You realize Yoda was always right? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 6
|
 Didn't I tell you we weren't gonna agree on this shit. You can compare |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 12
|
| Did I say anything about agreeing? Yoda is always RIGHT!!! |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 14
|
| this is true |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 16
|
| in case you're wondering about the "also" in the og subject line |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 18
|
| shit, i'ont agree with that post either, lol |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 21
|
| |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 19
|
| HA!! I been saying this forever... I even challenged ?uest on his |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 20
|
| That has very much been my opinion on Dilla overall. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 23
|
| *whispers* don't tell anybody |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 26
|
| RE: *whispers* don't tell anybody |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 28
|
| genres should always be in quotes |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 46
|
| understood |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 60
|
| Nosaj Thing and Exile were two examples recently raised round here |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 63
|
| eh... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 70
|
| growth at times requires a broadening of definition |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 73
|
| FIXED: growth requires progression |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 76
|
| If you don't hear progression in Nosaj Thing you don't want to. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 83
|
| lol...OR maybe what he is doing isn't really progressive! |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 89
|
| RE: lol...OR maybe what he is doing isn't really progressive! |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 97
|
| RE: lol...OR maybe what he is doing isn't really progressive! |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 98
|
| RE: eh... |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 189
|
| give me your best of influenced by Dilla producers I should check |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 30
|
| there are no 'true disciples of Dilla' nor are there of Hendrix |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 34
|
| To me Prince is heavily influenced by Jimi, who's Dilla's Prince? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 37
|
| At what point in Prince's career would you make this declaration? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 39
|
| To me it's his stage presence... Prince's sound especially on For You |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 43
|
| I don't hear more than peripheral influence on For You and Prince |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 48
|
| Prince DOESN'T measure up to Jimi in my world, but the influence is |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 50
|
| that's why i went to specifics on technique |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 51
|
| and THAT'S why I hear Jimi... you clearly hear Dilla, I haven't been |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 61
|
| OH SHIT!! We agree. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 64
|
| of course HA!! |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 66
|
| jimi is not one of p's main influences |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 190
|
| Can you answer post #28 please? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 42
|
| no response huh.... n/m |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 55
|
| uhhh post #46 |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 58
|
| my bad...I didn't see it. n/m |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 59
|
| eddie hazel would strongly disagree with you |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 99
|
| elsewhere i mentioned ernie n/m |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 113
|
| I agree. It isn't a knock to Dilla though. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 75
|
| But can you articulate how Hendrix 'revolutionized rock n roll'? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 78
|
| Axis: Bold As Love -- read up on how that was produced |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 82
|
| You're talking to me about Hendrix not his influence. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 84
|
| the first 3:35 can articulate it for him... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 87
|
| "and I went on afterwards and I just stood and strummed" |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 90
|
| THAT is the stand out quote, HA!! |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 93
|
| Listen to the music. Watch videos of him live. Music changed |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 116
|
| Pay attention to what I am asking... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 125
|
| LOL |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 141
|
| is that 'all there is to it'? LOL!! |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 144
|
| I'd rather educate you on more modern acts |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 147
|
| Hendrix had a specific rhythm technique |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 149
|
| animal collective are not all that innovative at all. |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 169
|
| someone hasn't heard feels, get the fuck outta here telling me that |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 176
|
| this exchange reminds me of k_orr's infamous rakim post |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 173
|
| Can you go a little deeper? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 22
|
| That's the yoda reply... there is no deeper. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 24
|
| hmmm...then this thread is bordering on Hip Hop revisionism |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 29
|
| RE: Can you go a little deeper? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 32
|
| So how would you compare Dilla to Madlib? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 35
|
| Somewhere above I admitted a lot of it is consequential... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 38
|
| hmmmm......... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 41
|
| ^^^any response to this? n/m |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 71
|
| RE: hmmmm......... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 74
|
| RE: hmmmm......... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 86
|
| RE: hmmmm......... |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 191
|
| EVERYBODY WHO QUESTIONS DILLA'S LEGACY SHD BE ASKED THIS |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 45
|
| I believed it has |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 158
|
| Nah. The Notorious BIG would be the closest. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 2
|
| Not enough output. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 4
|
| tupac |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 7
|
| just edited #4 on this one. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 11
|
| primo |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 8
|
| i accounted for him in #3 |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 13
|
| jay-z |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 9
|
| "ungh!" |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 15
|
| Jay Z and Hendrix |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 132
|
| peter rock n roll |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 10
|
| i'll illustrate something with this example |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 17
|
| until the electric goes out |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 25
|
| *beat boxes "lightworks" to this reply* |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 27
|
| Dude is not that iconic |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 31
|
| *throws on "JDilla Changed My Life" t-shirt* |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 33
|
| so he is moderately iconic? |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 193
|
| lol u know wat he means bitch |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 194
|
| dont tell me what i know |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 205
|
| tell u wat I know....keep fuckin round & u'll have a dectum in ur rectum |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 207
|
| dont tell me what you know either |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 209
|
| you do the same with these gay ass Dilla posts |
|
Jan 20th 2010 | 218
|
| fight me, b*tch |
|
May 04th 2011 | 222
|
| Rakim |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 36
|
| strong case could be made but post #17 also deals with him. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 40
|
| RE: Rakim |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 135
|
| Dj Shadow. where does he fit into this? The Janis Joplin? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 44
|
| LOL @ Janis Joplin!!! |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 47
|
| the cd shrinkwrap sticker on "endroducing" |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 202
|
| RE: James "Jay Dee / J Dilla" Yancey is also the Hendrix of our Generati... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 49
|
| no. no, he's not. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 52
|
| are you going to just say 'no' or are you prepared to give it weight? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 53
|
| he really isnt. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 56
|
| the thing about dilla is not many of his beats had that impact |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 54
|
| most valid counter point: no live chops |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 57
|
| i thought about this a bit more |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 62
|
| strong reply n/m |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 72
|
| for argument sake... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 80
|
| ive never seen that |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 94
|
| i thought about this.... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 65
|
| erm that would be kanye man |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 67
|
| yeah... kinda... you right |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 69
|
| dilla did bring some rythmic innovations |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 95
|
| SPACE RESERVED FOR POPWELL!!! |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 68
|
| don't fuck around, chum |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 120
|
| ^^^ official seal of approval ^^^ |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 124
|
| dilla is not even top 5 most influential of his own ERA much less of |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 77
|
| myopics are a bitch |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 79
|
| dude ur giving no specific examples tho. u realize ppl were playing |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 81
|
| your initial reply didn't warrant specific examples. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 85
|
| like it or not but T Pain has influenced hip hop more than Dilla |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 104
|
| show me in my original post where i limited this generation to hip-hop |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 109
|
| um u realize hip hop is a sub set of music right..... |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 174
|
| smh |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 195
|
| "do ya'll listen to music...or do you just skim through it?" |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 88
|
| ^^^an example of how dying young can elevate someone to mythical levels |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 96
|
| Dilla saved me from gaining 5 pounds... last night I saw the "Hot" |
|
Jan 17th 2010 |
|
| u cannot say that.... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 134
|
| yes I can because it is *my* opinion...nothing more and nothing less |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 138
|
| aight cool....it's just that personally...i'm yet to see... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 140
|
| RE: aight cool....it's just that personally...i'm yet to see... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 143
|
| how you gonna tell everyone else their opinion? |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 196
|
| Nigga |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 103
|
| but honestly..who are you to say how someone affected another's life... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 133
|
| u right |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 153
|
| you need to point out artists/djs/bands/tracks if you're making that sta... |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 165
|
| no disrespect to you but |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 172
|
| yeah i just went through this whole thread and found nothing |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 184
|
| welcome to the party |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 185
|
| RE: welcome to the party |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 186
|
| you're putting words into my mouth... |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 187
|
| RE: you're putting words into my mouth... |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 188
|
| go dig a hole. |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 192
|
| Dilla: hip hop:: Anvil: heavy metal |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 91
|
| RE: Dilla: hip hop:: Anvil: heavy metal:: Hendrix:Rock N Roll |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 92
|
| please. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 100
|
| Hendrix was at one point a huge mainstream success. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 105
|
| Good point. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 107
|
| But do we say he's great because of his mainstream success? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 110
|
| No. But he had mainstream success. Dilla didn't. |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 181
|
| RE: James "Jay Dee / J Dilla" Yancey is also the Hendrix of our Generati... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 101
|
| But who has already surpassed Dilla? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 102
|
| Without question - MADLIB |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 111
|
| I don't agree |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 154
|
| I'm one of them too |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 160
|
| Once and for all |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 177
|
| actually I am serious, cumchomper |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 183
|
| Honestly MS has so many BORING beats |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 197
|
| I don't build with faggots |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 201
|
| RE: I don't build with faggots |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 208
|
| i've heard all the madlib |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 212
|
| thats one album, HOMOHOUSER |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 213
|
| how is that undebatable? |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 204
|
| it's real simple... |
|
Jan 20th 2010 | 214
|
| orly? |
|
Jan 20th 2010 | 216
|
| *plays "The Healer" to this reply* |
|
Jan 20th 2010 | 217
|
| nice reply |
|
May 04th 2011 | 223
|
| Clearly you are an elitist and your posts come off |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 106
|
| clearly you don't know who the fuck i am |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 108
|
| RE: clearly you don't know who the fuck i am |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 118
|
| muhahahahahahhahahaaha |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 112
|
| Main difference: Everyone who listened to rock knew who Jimi was |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 114
|
| yeah, pretty luda comparison... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 115
|
| Sure, but we're talking influence not popularity. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 130
|
| Addendum to address specifics |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 137
|
| It has nothing to do with fame |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 155
|
| peep |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 164
|
| you could also say the same thing for Primo or Pete easily |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 166
|
| i've accounted for them above |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 171
|
| I'm sorry but this is some BULLSHIT |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 167
|
| it's not that serious and takes nothing from Hendrix |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 170
|
| fair enough but I respectfully disagree! n/m |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 175
|
| RE: Main difference: Everyone who listened to rock knew who Jimi was |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 136
|
| you do realize that jimmy not only changed rock, but funk & soul |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 117
|
| RE: you do realize that dilla not only changed hip-hop, but pop & soul |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 122
|
| *lol* you might wanna stick to hip-hop, dilla didn't touch soul |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 126
|
| "Hip-Hop, is bigger than the government... this one is for dilla hip-hop... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 129
|
| you're giving him WAAAAAAY too much credit |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 127
|
| keep your rocket in your pocket popp |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 128
|
| oh I ain't coming off on you |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 131
|
| Eh, point of information |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 255
|
| If we limit "our generation" to Detroit hip-hop, yes. |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 119
|
| it wont? |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 242
|
| / |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 121
|
| YOU CAME BACK!!! |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 123
|
| somebody has studied how to make a buildingblock post 101 |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 139
|
| ..lol..i came in here to post this initially, but got distracted n/m |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 142
|
| LOL!! imcvspl is the buildingblock of this lesson generation |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 145
|
| Ha....a classic OKP moment right chea..! |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 179
|
| i had to keep checkin' the name to make sure i ain't made this! |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 211
|
| I could see the validity in that but i dont agree |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 146
|
| can't be Jimi of the generation sampeling......sorry... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 148
|
| say more, where's the limitation in dilla or the format? |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 150
|
| the limitation is in the medium.... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 151
|
| hmmmmmm.... |
|
Jan 17th 2010 | 152
|
| Yes you can |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 163
|
| jay z and basketball are apples and oranges...music is music |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 178
|
| thats just your little box |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 206
|
| dilla was written/arranged original material same as hendrix |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 210
|
| wowsers, you've outdone yourself this time. |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 156
|
| the thread that keeps on giving |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 157
|
| RUN DMC |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 159
|
| It took a long time for Hendrix's |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 161
|
| most of the artists that have the most impact aren't appreciated |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 162
|
| RE: James "Jay Dee / J Dilla" Yancey is also the Hendrix of our Generati... |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 168
|
| more like 3 1/2 |
|
Jan 18th 2010 | 180
|
| RE: more like 3 1/2 |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 203
|
| Incorrect. |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 182
|
| Nah bub |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 198
|
| RE: James "Jay Dee / J Dilla" Yancey is also the Hendrix of our Generati... |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 199
|
| 2X http://i49.tinypic.com/2cyimgz.jpg |
|
Jan 19th 2010 | 200
|
| trying to decide if the reaction to this is better/worse than me'shell |
|
Jan 20th 2010 | 215
|
| i love this post |
|
Oct 14th 2010 | 220
|
| lol @ u hatin ass haters |
|
Jan 20th 2010 | 219
|
| up |
|
May 04th 2011 | 221
|
| no one said tupac?! |
|
May 04th 2011 | 224
|
| You're kidding |
|
May 04th 2011 | 225
|
| hell no. hendrix changed the way people conceptualized the guitar. |
|
May 05th 2011 | 226
|
| Ableton Live became what it is after Dilla died |
|
May 05th 2011 | 227
|
| dude, hendrix made feedback a good thing. |
|
May 05th 2011 | 228
|
| if you think hendrix invented feedback.... |
|
May 05th 2011 | 229
|
| fair enough. i don't know who those people are. |
|
May 05th 2011 | 235
|
| Nobody was programming drums like Jay Dee. |
|
May 05th 2011 | 231
|
| Hate to burst your idiot bubble, but deadmau5 changed Ableton Live |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 247
|
| dilla changed the way people conceptualized the chop |
|
May 06th 2011 | 240
|
| This post is over a year old and yall still can't shut it down |
|
May 05th 2011 | 230
|
| I won't be so bold. |
|
May 05th 2011 | 232
|
| that influence has been there... |
|
May 05th 2011 | 233
|
| I usually go to GD to get my laughs, but this was a good one... |
|
May 05th 2011 | 234
|
| Dilla... |
|
May 05th 2011 | 236
|
| you're going all overboard with your point |
|
May 06th 2011 | 237
|
| RE: you're going all overboard with your point |
|
May 06th 2011 | 238
|
| RE: you're going all overboard with your point |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 252
|
| I was gonna say this Dilla stannery has reached cult status... |
|
May 06th 2011 | 239
|
| it really has been cult status for quite some time. |
|
Dec 15th 2011 | 241
|
| Lol, this is one of the dumbest shock posts in the history of the lesson... |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 243
|
| Whatever. |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 244
|
| Nothing Dilla did with an MPC has opened doors for anyone. |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 245
|
| You clearly have no idea. |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 250
|
| Yes I do, I love both artists. |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 251
|
| What Hendrix accomplished with a guitar... |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 253
|
| Hendrix had freakishly big hands... |
|
Dec 17th 2011 | 259
|
| RE: Lol, this is one of the dumbest shock posts in the history of the le... |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 246
|
| TWO YEAR OLD POST |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 248
|
| I used to think you had some sense/knowledge of music. |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 249
|
| did _you_ really just say this? |
|
Dec 16th 2011 | 254
|
| I'm not bored when I'm writing shock posts tho |
|
Dec 17th 2011 | 256
|
| LMAO. |
|
Dec 17th 2011 | 257
|
| Who you be, baby? Jimi Hendrix can't work a beat thing! |
|
Dec 17th 2011 | 258
|
| sorry dude. but this is a fuckin ignorant statement. jay dee was the |
|
Dec 17th 2011 | 260
|
| cross-post |
|
Jun 27th 2012 | 261
|
| can we get some moderation in here today? |
|
Jul 25th 2012 | 262
|
Printer-friendly copy 
Email this topic to a friend
The Lesson
