Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby The Lesson topic #2741682

Subject: "what i believe even more is that people aren't genres" Previous topic | Next topic
howisya
Member since Nov 09th 2002
39983 posts
Thu Sep-20-12 06:13 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
17. "what i believe even more is that people aren't genres"
In response to In response to 15


  

          

meaning if someone makes mostly or even exclusively to that point music that fits into a certain genre (which is just a fluid concept, as this thread well illustrates), that doesn't make them personally that genre or everything they will ever do that genre. so if suddenly a rock band makes a polka song, it's not rock just because their other music is (perceived as) rock. hypothetically, the lack of "purity" in the polka song isn't because it's bringing the rock genre into it but because those particular musicians are bringing themselves, their skills, and their musical interests into what is considered the (more rigidly defined) polka form. to that end, one mustn't get so hung up on the idea of a genre. i think artists perform the music they want to make and others to hear, not genre exercises despite how perfectly it might fit into a preconceived, widely established understanding of the genre. so i would rather listen to what is actually going on in the music than check off a list of what should be found according to the supposed genre.

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


"Indie" in 2012 = ? [View all] , good5, Tue Sep-18-12 03:09 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
RE: "Indie" in 2012 = ?
Sep 18th 2012
1
RE: "Indie" in 2012 = ?
Sep 18th 2012
2
Indie the ''genre'' never really meant independent whatever...
Sep 18th 2012
3
RE: Indie the ''genre'' never really meant independent whatever...
Sep 22nd 2012
33
i don't know, but
Sep 18th 2012
4
RE: "Indie" in 2012 = ?
Sep 18th 2012
5
welcome to the boards. Stay a while.
Sep 18th 2012
6
we need to change our lens
Sep 19th 2012
8
I don't agree with this:
Sep 19th 2012
9
RE: we need to change our lens
Sep 19th 2012
10
      good posts, and i join in welcoming you to the boards
Sep 19th 2012
14
           Do you really believe that?
Sep 19th 2012
15
               
                     RE: what i believe even more is that people aren't genres
Sep 20th 2012
20
                     Of course people aren't genres...
Sep 20th 2012
21
                          RE: Of course people aren't genres...
Sep 20th 2012
22
                               And you really think people do that?
Sep 20th 2012
24
                               RE: And you really think people do that?
Sep 20th 2012
26
                                    RE: And you really think people do that?
Sep 20th 2012
28
                                         RE: And you really think people do that?
Sep 20th 2012
29
                                              ...
Sep 20th 2012
30
                               genres are definitely real
Sep 20th 2012
25
                               RE: genres are definitely real
Sep 20th 2012
27
                               RE: Of course people aren't genres...
Sep 22nd 2012
34
                                    RE: Of course people aren't genres...
Sep 22nd 2012
35
when did jazz dominate the pop sound?
Sep 20th 2012
18
      RE: when did jazz dominate the pop sound?
Sep 20th 2012
19
      1920s-50s
Sep 20th 2012
23
           RE: 1920s-50s
Sep 22nd 2012
36
in terms of how average people use it, it feels like the new college roc...
Sep 18th 2012
7
I love you, Indie.
Sep 19th 2012
11
me and gb, bff.
Sep 19th 2012
12
Have you suffered a stroke?
Sep 19th 2012
13
      just a key stroke
Sep 22nd 2012
32
-HERE IN LIE SPOILERS-
Sep 19th 2012
16
Marketing Termenology
Sep 20th 2012
31

Lobby The Lesson topic #2741682 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com