Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
in the 50-150 circle |
|
May 07th 2012 | 1
|
RE: in the 50-150 circle |
|
May 08th 2012 | 2
|
that would be insulting, because Clinton has real Music instincts |
|
May 08th 2012 | 3
|
RE: that would be insulting, because Clinton has real Music instincts |
|
May 08th 2012 | 5
|
dr. dre has NOTHING in common with george clinton. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 25
|
PLEASE don't ever disrespect the GOD George like that again. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 4
|
no. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 26
|
RE: Where does George Clinton rank as a songwriter? |
|
May 08th 2012 | 6
|
RE: Where does George Clinton rank as a songwriter? |
|
May 08th 2012 | 7
|
among the greatest. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 8
|
Top fucking tier |
|
May 08th 2012 | 9
|
look i love Clinton and his musical contributions however |
|
May 08th 2012 | 10
|
he's right in line w/them. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 11
|
you don't know nothing about no songwriting |
|
May 08th 2012 | 12
|
i do. and i say Clinton is up there w/the greats. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 13
|
i am intimately familiar w/ all the songwriters you mentioned. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 23
|
Motown is wrong then ok? |
|
May 08th 2012 | 30
|
reply #44. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 45
|
Oddly enough got his writing chops from the same school as |
|
May 08th 2012 | 14
|
difference though those acts i mention have better songs |
|
May 08th 2012 | 16
|
George was "ahead of his time" and Barry shut him down |
|
May 08th 2012 | 17
|
Gordy was A Pimp and if you had true game he locked you up |
|
May 08th 2012 | 28
|
Fully agreed. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 19
|
I'm disappointed in you, denny. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 20
|
turkey please George will tell you he couldn't hold Sly Stone's |
|
May 08th 2012 | 29
|
devil's advocate..... |
|
May 09th 2012 | 33
|
RE: I'm disappointed in you, denny. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 34
|
The songs I posted could be played on MTV Unplugged |
|
May 09th 2012 | 35
|
Michael Jordan wasn't a 3-point specialist. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 36
|
This is where I was heading |
|
May 09th 2012 | 37
|
^^^ |
|
May 09th 2012 | 38
|
Agreed. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 39
|
Ridiculous |
|
May 09th 2012 | 40
|
and you don't know George Clinton. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 41
|
REAL TALK: Come to MUMU right now!! |
|
May 09th 2012 | 42
|
Denny i have been saying this for years in here |
|
May 09th 2012 | 76
|
right on Denny Pound Pound |
|
May 08th 2012 | 32
|
Norman Whitfield was a great producer, not songwriter. |
|
May 13th 2012 | 123
|
not good looks turkey because i wanna get next to you |
|
May 13th 2012 | 125
|
People still play "I Wanna Get next to You", but the lyrics are |
|
May 13th 2012 | 129
|
dude i didn't name call |
|
May 14th 2012 | 131
|
In the ''His songs works performed alone at a piano or with an acoustic ... |
|
May 08th 2012 | 15
|
^ all of this. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 24
|
i dont think georges songs were loose jams |
|
May 10th 2012 | 85
|
I have some issues with the standard definition of songwriting... |
|
May 10th 2012 | 86
|
RE: I have some issues with the standard definition of songwriting... |
|
May 10th 2012 | 87
|
Ask his songwriting collaborators n/m |
|
May 08th 2012 | 18
|
top tier. i mean, james brown isn't known for writing "songs" either. |
|
May 08th 2012 | 21
|
and btw, he could write "regular" songs too... check out The Parliaments... |
|
May 08th 2012 | 22
|
Clinton is in the same boat as James Brown, however not as |
|
May 08th 2012 | 31
|
Yep. |
|
May 11th 2012 | 121
|
James Brown is a More important Artist and Icon |
|
May 13th 2012 | 126
|
Agreed. |
|
May 14th 2012 | 132
|
true dat |
|
May 14th 2012 | 133
|
i almost widh u asked where g cLinton ranks as a personaLity |
|
May 08th 2012 | 27
|
greatest funk songwriter maybe; def 1 of the all time best lyricists |
|
May 09th 2012 | 43
|
if george clinton isn't top tier b/c the songwriting is non-linear... |
|
May 09th 2012 | 47
|
but they still stuck more to a verse-chorus format |
|
May 09th 2012 | 49
|
the original post didn't say POP songwriter. (edit) |
|
May 09th 2012 | 51
|
see #52 |
|
May 09th 2012 | 53
|
the rockist bias in this p-funk post is fucking surprising. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 44
|
but george wasnt really a songwriter in the pop sense |
|
May 09th 2012 | 46
|
you too... come to da mu |
|
May 09th 2012 | 48
|
says theres no space... |
|
May 09th 2012 | 55
|
after lunch |
|
May 09th 2012 | 60
|
neither was joni mitchell. or bob dylan. or jimi hendrix. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 50
|
im not sure theres a difference |
|
May 09th 2012 | 52
|
so how do great songs that aren't pop get made? |
|
May 09th 2012 | 54
|
it came from them sitting around doing drugs and humming to each other. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 56
|
^ incisive. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 61
|
lots of bands/artists dont 'write' |
|
May 09th 2012 | 63
|
so, lyrics just fall out the sky, huh? |
|
May 09th 2012 | 67
|
who said anything about lyrics? |
|
May 09th 2012 | 69
|
*raises hand* |
|
May 09th 2012 | 70
|
ummm |
|
May 09th 2012 | 74
|
*smh* |
|
May 09th 2012 | 75
|
|
but fuck Pop songwriting though. LOL |
|
May 09th 2012 | 62
|
great records vs great songs |
|
May 09th 2012 | 66
|
P-Funk made great records and great songs. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 68
|
now we're getting somewhere. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 65
|
we can't? says who? |
|
May 09th 2012 | 58
|
so great songwriting didn't happen until after the 50's... got it!! |
|
May 09th 2012 | 71
|
50s? |
|
May 09th 2012 | 72
|
wikipedia ref |
|
May 09th 2012 | 73
|
totally. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 57
|
Here's a perspective that might make the point. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 78
|
but it doesn't sound quite right unless george clinton is in charge. |
|
May 09th 2012 | 79
|
basically. |
|
May 10th 2012 | 91
|
id give up |
|
May 10th 2012 | 84
|
right. it's exactly like that. |
|
May 10th 2012 | 90
|
awesome. still, IMO, Clinton is 1 of the greatest songwriters of all ti... |
|
May 10th 2012 | 89
|
STFU!!! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D3PZuECIKlE |
|
May 10th 2012 | 93
|
This one is nice also: |
|
May 10th 2012 | 108
|
That's a great link..... |
|
May 14th 2012 | 136
|
TOP TEN |
|
May 09th 2012 | 64
|
i'd take RICK James over him as a Songwriter |
|
May 09th 2012 | 77
|
RE: i'd take RICK James over him as a Songwriter |
|
May 14th 2012 | 139
|
he's super underrated...also to me you can't disconnect |
|
May 10th 2012 | 80
|
yeah that tap dancing is all fine and good however |
|
May 10th 2012 | 82
|
and none of those people did anything as uniquely creative as GC |
|
May 10th 2012 | 92
|
WARREN SHUT EM DOWN |
|
May 10th 2012 | 94
|
Sly Stone by himself stands out |
|
May 10th 2012 | 96
|
pretend like Sly isn't the only one on the list |
|
May 10th 2012 | 97
|
Sly Stone changed the game turkey |
|
May 10th 2012 | 99
|
who did Sly go to in hopes of making a comeback in the early |
|
May 10th 2012 | 105
|
he went there and also to Earth,wind and fire, Jesse Johnson |
|
May 10th 2012 | 106
|
Sly recorded with P-funk...Funk gets stronger... |
|
May 10th 2012 | 111
|
bottom line Sly wasn't with it completely |
|
May 10th 2012 | 114
|
you talkin hood passes but listing Burt Bacharach...lol stop it maxx |
|
May 10th 2012 | 98
|
FYI on Burt Bacharach. |
|
May 10th 2012 | 101
|
Dionne w/ Bacharach was classic...but Black Radio wasn't checking |
|
May 10th 2012 | 104
|
Black radio did Check it because Bacarach influenced |
|
May 10th 2012 | 109
|
I'm specificlly stalking Dionne Warrick |
|
May 10th 2012 | 112
|
Dionne Warrick her songs did get alot of play Man |
|
May 10th 2012 | 115
|
But why are we requiring GC to do what Bacharach did? |
|
May 14th 2012 | 137
|
THIS BLACK ON BLACK CRIME MUST STOP! |
|
May 10th 2012 | 100
|
yo i named cats whose catelog as songwriters |
|
May 10th 2012 | 102
|
i've listened to the same albums that you have. |
|
May 10th 2012 | 103
|
one half good ear and the other filled with wax |
|
May 10th 2012 | 110
|
you are on that double crack and your hood pass is about to be |
|
May 10th 2012 | 95
|
EWF was a great band....but they couldn't fade the P |
|
May 10th 2012 | 107
|
yo Warren did you not read what I wrote? |
|
May 10th 2012 | 113
|
RE: he's super underrated...also to me you can't disconnect |
|
May 10th 2012 | 88
|
. |
|
May 10th 2012 | 81
|
on the verge of getting it on.. |
|
May 10th 2012 | 83
|
the songwriting team(s) Geroge had...... |
|
May 10th 2012 | 116
|
Holland, Dozier and Holland thinks your cap is on too tight |
|
May 10th 2012 | 119
|
RE: Where does George Clinton rank as a songwriter? |
|
May 10th 2012 | 117
|
q - who are the great funk song writers? |
|
May 10th 2012 | 118
|
Sly Stone, Charlie Wilson, Chris Jasper,(don't front on 3+3 era) |
|
May 10th 2012 | 120
|
This is a awsome thread. |
|
May 11th 2012 | 122
|
He's definitely in the 70th percentile or higher. |
|
May 13th 2012 | 124
|
Clinton started out as a Motown staff writer |
|
May 13th 2012 | 127
|
RE: Clinton started out as a Motown staff writer |
|
May 13th 2012 | 128
|
RE: Clinton started out as a Motown staff writer |
|
May 14th 2012 | 130
|
RE: Clinton started out as a Motown staff writer |
|
May 14th 2012 | 134
|
RE: Clinton started out as a Motown staff writer |
|
May 14th 2012 | 135
|
RE: Clinton started out as a Motown staff writer |
|
May 14th 2012 | 138
|