Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby The Lesson topic #2533106

Subject: "RE: The Cure are possibly the most misleading singles band. . ." Previous topic | Next topic
Austin
Charter member
9418 posts
Sun Apr-03-11 12:54 AM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
52. "RE: The Cure are possibly the most misleading singles band. . ."
In response to In response to 1


  

          

. . . of all time.

Let's take a look. . .

Three Imaginary Boys: no singles, really
I guess the singles affiliated with this album are 'Boys Don't Cry' and 'Killing An Arab' I guess pretty representative of the proper album, but way more catchy than anything on the album (except maybe 'Fire in Cairo').

Seventeen Seconds: Jumping Someone Else's Train, A Forest
Ok, this is one case where the singles represented the album pretty well. Sparse, jangly minor chords and whatnot.

Faith: Primary, Charlotte Sometimes
If all someone knows of this era are these two songs, they are in for a very slow, very melancholy shock when they actually listen to the album.

Pornography: The Hanging Garden
Sure, it's dark and poundy, but it's actually very tuneful in comparison to the rest of the album. I've always thought 'A Strange Day' would've been a much better single.

in the interim: The Walk, The Lovecats, Let's Go to Bed
Bob goes pop. Representative of Japanese Whispers, sure, but that's a compilation anyway.

The Top: The Caterpillar
Nothing is representative of this album. Least of all, that song. If I had to pick a more representative single, I'd pick 'Birdmad Girl.'

The Head on the Door: Inbetween Days, Close to Me, A Night Like This
Funny that the most representative single from the album ('Night Like This') was also probably the least popular. Besides the two big songs, the rest of the album is a little more dark sure, in a mid-80's 'goth pop' big production sort of way, but still.

Kiss Me: Catch, Just Like Heaven, Hot Hot Hot, Why Can't I Be You?
The catchiest songs on the album, point blank. The title track started the album and that should be a good clue-in. Other fan favorites on this album that weren't singles: 'How Beautiful You Are', 'If Only Tonight We Could Sleep' and 'Lime Cockatoos' catchy stuff, sure, but not really radio hits.

Disintegration: Lovesong, Fascination Street, Lullaby, Pictures of You
In the case of three of the singles from this album, they were the shortest songs on the album. Literally besides 'Lovesong' 'Fascination' and 'Lullaby' everything else on the album was six minutes or longer. So, yeah.

Wish: Friday I'm in Love, High, A Letter to Elise
The album started off with 'Open' and went on to have other shoegaze/Madchester experiments like 'From the Edge of the Deep Green Sea', 'Cut' and 'End.' The singles were easily the most pop things on the album the rest is very dark. Except for the aborted fourth single 'Doing the Unstuck' (shame, that it should've been the lead single in my mind).

Wild Mood Swings: The 13th, Gone, Mint Car, Strange Attraction
Another album where no single would have been representative. In a perfect world, 'Jupiter Crash' would've been the single and, furthermore, it would have been a hit.

Bloodflowers: Maybe Someday
Another Disintegration case, where all of the songs are too long to really be singles. I will concede that this is actually a pretty representative song for the rest of the album.

The Cure: The End of the World, Taking Off (in Europe), alt.end (in America)
They actually were a little more honest to the Americans with this one, as 'alt.end' feels a little more representative of the darker, more 'tough guy' rock sound that this album attempted. But still, they fucked up again as 'Before Three' was clearly the best and most representative song on the album.

4.13 Dream: The Only One, Freakshow, Sleep When I'm Dead, The Perfect Boy
Ok, actually a pretty representative batch of songs for a mixed bag of an album.

So, yeah. There's my analysis.

~Austin

os·ti·na·to
/ˌästəˈnädō/
noun
a continually repeated musical phrase or rhythm

http://austinato.bandcamp.com

https://www.discogs.com/lists/Favorites-of-2017/332378

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


Who are your "greatest hits = good enough" artists? [View all] , dalecooper, Fri Apr-01-11 12:33 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
RE: Who are your "greatest hits = good enough" artists?
Apr 01st 2011
1
The Cure - I think I'm two albums off from the whole Cat
Apr 01st 2011
8
they BOTH make GREAT albums...
Apr 01st 2011
15
The Cure is a te4xtbook single4s-act to me4...
Apr 01st 2011
29
      RE: The Cure are possibly the most misleading singles band. . .
Apr 03rd 2011
54
Busta is definitely one of them
Apr 01st 2011
2
Snoop Dogg, Ludacris, T.I., Young Jeezy... shit, even 2Pac
Apr 01st 2011
3
Uh oh
Apr 01st 2011
4
      it is rare for music from 1992-1996 to be worthy of two discs
Apr 01st 2011
44
all classic Motown acts except Stevie and Marvin.
Apr 01st 2011
5
RE: Who are your "greatest hits = good enough" artists?
Apr 01st 2011
6
The Guess Who, and even there it's only the Best Of, not Greatest Of
Apr 01st 2011
7
Anita Baker....
Apr 01st 2011
9
listening to Rapture is like listening to a Greatest Hits album.
Apr 01st 2011
12
      you're absolutley right...we JUST talked about this,
Apr 01st 2011
16
the Who
Apr 01st 2011
10
RE: the Who
Apr 01st 2011
11
I *should* love Live at leeds...
Apr 01st 2011
25
Who's Next is a strong album front-to-back, I'm sure you consider
Apr 01st 2011
19
I hate that album with a passion...
Apr 01st 2011
26
      why on earth would you buy a record you hated three times?
Apr 01st 2011
35
           Because I bought it during different times in my life...
Apr 02nd 2011
45
Who's Next & Tommy are amazing
Apr 01st 2011
30
With you on the Tom Petty
Apr 01st 2011
13
Nah, Holmes... You DEFINITELY need Bob's whole shit...
Apr 01st 2011
17
      I barely even listen to Marley albums at this point, if I'm in a Marley
Apr 01st 2011
22
      I agree - my copy of "Legend" is gathering dust
Apr 01st 2011
24
      Songs of Freedom is a 4 disc set
Apr 01st 2011
36
a lot of the 90's Alt-Rock bands...
Apr 01st 2011
14
RE: a lot of the 90's Alt-Rock bands...
Apr 01st 2011
18
on: Oasis
Apr 01st 2011
20
      RE: on: Oasis
Apr 01st 2011
23
The only Soundgarden hits i like are the ones from Badmotorfinger...
Apr 01st 2011
27
Roger and/or Zapp
Apr 01st 2011
21
oh NO
Apr 01st 2011
41
RE: Of all the bands I've checked out over the years, only one.
Apr 01st 2011
28
RE: Of all the bands I've checked out over the years, only one.
Apr 01st 2011
33
      I will co-sign this one
Apr 01st 2011
42
      RE: I prefer the earlier Furs.
Apr 02nd 2011
46
      RE: Of all the bands I've checked out over the years, only one.
Feb 21st 2013
60
Pearl Jam, Peter Tosh, The Ramones, John Lennon, Inspiral Carpets
Apr 01st 2011
31
Inspiral Carpets?
Apr 01st 2011
32
I have a hard time with this.
Apr 01st 2011
34
nm
Apr 01st 2011
37
Chuck Berry
Apr 01st 2011
38
RE: Who are your "greatest hits = good enough" artists?
Apr 01st 2011
39
I will agree on Lenny Kravitz
Apr 01st 2011
43
      A Greatest Hits would be cool, but you need "Mama Said".
Apr 03rd 2011
59
RE: Who are your "greatest hits = good enough" artists?
Apr 01st 2011
40
Creedence n/m
Apr 02nd 2011
47
Hall & Oats...Harold Melvin & The Bluenotes
Apr 02nd 2011
48
I was about to say Hall & Oates.
Apr 03rd 2011
56
any good white people music*
Apr 02nd 2011
49
RE: This post makes me sad.
Apr 02nd 2011
50
      why?
Apr 02nd 2011
51
           RE: This.
Apr 03rd 2011
53
           i post about congolese music all the time and i never see you in
Apr 03rd 2011
55
           What exactly is 'white' about this?
Apr 03rd 2011
57
                Hunh?
Apr 03rd 2011
58
Prefer to take the good with the bad (or mediocre)
Feb 21st 2013
61

Lobby The Lesson topic #2533106 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com