Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
Wow - I really thought they'd lose that case |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 1
|
the case shouldn't have survived summary judgment, IMO. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 7
|
RE: the case shouldn't have survived summary judgment, IMO. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 51
|
Right?! |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 10
|
yes! |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 2
|
tried to tell these know it all niggas |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 65
|
oh wow |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 3
|
oh...it's a jury verdict. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 4
|
it does |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 9
|
but getting clearance is nothing new tho right? |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 11
|
clearance for what? |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 16
|
the beats of the songs are almost identical...to the point where |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 18
|
what do you mean 'beats'? |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 25
|
inspiration is NOT theft. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 64
|
thats why i put 'inspiration' in quotes buddy. and its ok if u |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 114
|
RE: thats why i put 'inspiration' in quotes buddy. and its ok if u |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 119
|
or so he thought. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 129
|
RE: or so he thought. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 |
|
RE: or so he thought. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 151
|
so youre saying only vocals are protected? |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 20
|
i'm saying only the actual notes that make up the music. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 26
|
if you're the defense how do you let it be a jury trial, or do they |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 14
|
the parties would have to agree to a bench trial. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 34
|
Good. Detest Theives. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 5
|
lol this dude robin thicke is having the worst sequence of events ever |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 6
|
He really is. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 157
|
He'll be alright. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 556
|
the songs are EXTREMELY similar...blatant rip off. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 8
|
yes but the parts of GTGIU that Williams and Thicke borrowed |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 12
|
which parts arent protected and why? |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 15
|
the sheet music is protected. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 22
|
right but ppl give credit for interpolations too...which to my understnd... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 28
|
yes, when parts of the sheet music are replayed |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 36
|
RE: which parts arent protected and why? |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 29
|
that's what i hear. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 42
|
RE: that's what i hear. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 44
|
i dunno. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 46
|
RE: i dunno. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 91
|
How many jurors read sheet music? C'mon. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 169
|
RE: How many jurors read sheet music? C'mon. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 217
|
RE: the songs are EXTREMELY similar...blatant rip off. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 112
|
Can't even imagine how many rights owners are drooling right now |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 13
|
This will be bad for music |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 17
|
for real: if you're cheering this you're 1. an idiot and... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 19
|
yep! |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 27
|
lots are cheering b/c they hate whitey. others b/c they hate Thicke. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 30
|
i mean, that seems to be it. logic has been put out to pasture. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 35
|
base |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 38
|
shit is reverse racial psychology |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 40
|
^^^this. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 43
|
not hate, its just that you can't jack an Iconic song period |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 263
|
. . . |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 291
|
too close for comfort |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 410
|
For real. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 31
|
don't disrupt them in their RaceWarz slumber. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 56
|
RE: for real: if you're cheering this you're 1. an idiot and... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 57
|
yep. and, furthermore, 3. i would like to kick your ass. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 66
|
Ur unhinged and would likely be the one getting ur ass beat |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 74
|
fuck off, fuckwit. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 155
|
reply 74 |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 241
|
you're an idiot, something |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 243
|
rage on! hope this is helping ur blood pressure |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 273
|
thank you. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 278
|
More likely because it's a white boy |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 103
|
yall need to stop hiding behind D'Angelo and this racial angle |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 181
|
nah, it's an obvious attempt at recreating |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 224
|
gyeah |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 21
|
Every hip hop producer should get sued according to some of you |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 23
|
to quote the legendary pete rock 'flip the bass and erase any |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 116
|
LOL the jury doesn't know what the fuck they're talking about |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 24
|
the Pauls Boutique of now |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 32
|
This is setting a horrible precedent. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 33
|
they can and probably will appeal. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 39
|
How expensve will the appeal's process be though? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 189
|
He and Willliams can afford it. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 191
|
RE: He and Willliams can afford it. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 213
|
this jury trial decision is not binding precedent. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 218
|
Interesting. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 258
|
the fact thicke filed suit first |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 37
|
naw. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 41
|
The fact someone files a lawsuit means it has merit? SMH. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 |
|
The fact someone files a lawsuit means it has merit? SMH. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 52
|
Good! |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 45
|
combat jack's view as an entertainment lawyer: |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 47
|
but Williams and Thicke didn't replay music from GTGIU. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 49
|
his example is entirely different. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 60
|
base |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 70
|
more: |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 72
|
as i'm sure you and Jack know, sampling isn't an issue here. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 75
|
this shit aint rocket science man. them niggas gambled and lost. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 118
|
yup, I knlw a producer who is alwahs being sued and he admits he jacks s... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 133
|
The defendants participated in settlement negotiation. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 186
|
wow woe ! Music as we know it is ruined!!!! Woe woe |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 48
|
yes and whitey is dead now that Thicke has to pay the Gayes. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 50
|
oh I don't mind robin thicke at all, find pharell very annoying. But ple... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 53
|
oh my bad. i didn't know Pharrell stole your lunch money |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 58
|
RE: oh I don't mind robin thicke at all, find pharell very annoying. But... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 61
|
Alicia Keys' 'Like You'll Never See Me Again' |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 62
|
Shit, Alicia Keys' "Fallin'". It's JB's "It's a Man's Man's Man's World" |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 76
|
that's a sample, isn't it? |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 80
|
It is not. In fact, I dug up my CD booklet to find the liner notes. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 87
|
You're right. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 89
|
I'm stunned. I never even gave that a second thought. Wow. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 106
|
Clive Davis is a lawyer and Lawyers run the business |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 144
|
So they just _let_ her take it? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 173
|
if so it's b/c BMG owns both recordings. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 177
|
Warner/Chappell owns IAMMMW, EMI owns Fallin' |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 203
|
then i really don't get it. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 205
|
Clive Davis is a lawyer and if he could handle the puffy sampling |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 264
|
Prince loves her and she introduced him at the rock and roll |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 266
|
it ain't ruined, but don't think that |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 55
|
Bruno Mars and Mark Ronson are sweating a bit today. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 59
|
I'll kick in to a crowdfunding site to help Morris Day file suit |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 437
|
^ |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 68
|
you don't sound very bright. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 67
|
Much like the merit of the suit, your opinion is based on "feel", not fa... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 71
|
agreed |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 73
|
ikr? how dare we offer differing opinions |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 77
|
*DEAD* |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 182
|
OKP wrong yet again... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 54
|
smart dumb niggas |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 78
|
fuck, you people are idiots. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 84
|
lol, yall just mad for being on the wrong side |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 94
|
or, we know how much great music jacked older music. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 101
|
why the fuck are yall arguing for songs to be jacked without repercussio... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 110
|
nobody could pay enough. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 113
|
aint no one thinking about that song |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 117
|
a song ppl are thinking of is probaly a jack. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 121
|
been listening to music since the 70's... have a shit load of wax from t... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 124
|
which is why i'm calling you a fucking idiot. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 153
|
lol, you mad as shit |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 174
|
i don't deny it. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 188
|
I think fuck off fuckwitt gave it away...lol. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 194
|
if you think it will be alright |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 209
|
GOOD!!! |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 63
|
Who's suing for uptown funk |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 69
|
Or Ed Sheeran's Thinking out Loud? |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 93
|
lawyers already do this shit... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 141
|
Kellz is gonna get reamed. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 79
|
RE: Kellz is gonna get reamed. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 82
|
some of this should be protected by statute of limitations |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 88
|
the Gaye Family Loves Kellz and steps with the CHI TOwn's best |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 135
|
know what's MOST ridiculous about this? GTGIU is a ripoff itself. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 81
|
i don't think Gaye would've filed the suit. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 83
|
we're right >< |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 85
|
/ |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 86
|
people sue all the time because they think a song "sounds" like theirs |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 97
|
and in the past those artists have been sent home... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 98
|
sometimes they win, sometimes they lose... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 122
|
god damn u stupid son |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 225
|
chill b. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 324
|
Fuck that shit, Robin Thicke is tryin' to kill me(c)Scarface |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 397
|
If I recall, there was little structure to it originally |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 96
|
RE: Gaye family wins $7.4 mil in Blurred Lines case. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 90
|
because this was before the music industry was broke as fuck |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 226
|
RE: Gaye family wins $7.4 mil in Blurred Lines case. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 92
|
gtfoh.... lawsuits happen all the time |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 95
|
I don't think you follow as to what just happened here.... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 104
|
he won't get it. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 |
|
have several seats... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 108
|
ppl aplauding this verdict haven't done their research. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 99
|
continues to nod to a song that was jacked from an old song... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 109
|
good for them. not sure why ppl think this is the end of music |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 100
|
well, yeah. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 102
|
smh |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 105
|
i decided to go away from the original snark |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 107
|
it wont result in less creativity, just means more checks will get cut b... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 111
|
dude, all these songs out here are jacks. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 115
|
fuck that lil song... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 120
|
computer love is a jack and so is oak tree. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 123
|
great... so if someone takes them to court, pay up. If not... oh well. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 126
|
lol Oak Tree |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 127
|
I'm just throwing out jams from back in the day...lol |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 130
|
I know, that one was funny lol |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 131
|
so tell these niggas to do better in the way of originality or pay up |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 125
|
exactly, if it aint original or borrows too much.. pay up. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 128
|
and honestly LD i could care less...i aint anti sampling...i came |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 134
|
I take pride in catching samples... I dig, I grew up on 70s and 80s.. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 140
|
no ideas original (c) nas |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 132
|
if the person who D is 'inspired by' comes to him then sit |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 137
|
aint noooooo one trying to take the few nickels D is making mumbling on ... |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 138
|
I think you missed my point. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 142
|
it doesnt matter. if u can get away with it, so be it. if not pay. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 145
|
yup...and playing that D card won't work |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 179
|
or it'll mean fewer songs like 'Blurred Lines' or 'Stay With Me' get |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 178
|
RE: or it'll mean fewer songs like 'Blurred Lines' or 'Stay With Me' get |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 180
|
Since you know me so well what color are my drawers today? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 185
|
dirty |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 195
|
it could change it drastically. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 199
|
"this could be the end" is some shit people say when they lose... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 201
|
i love "master blaster." |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 204
|
RE: i love "master blaster." |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 219
|
I hated Master Blaster |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 233
|
jammin', bob marley. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 262
|
If you don't hear Jammin in Master Blaster then ionno... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 317
|
i don't think it'll end music as we know it. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 208
|
this is like saying the jury got the trayvon case right |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 232
|
you really bringing up Trayvon? Cmon bruh.. that's foul |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 319
|
Fakerell and Robin Hood got what they deserved |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 136
|
but rick james doesn't owe p-funk any money, right? |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 143
|
FYI George Clinton admired and Respected RIck James |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 147
|
"I don't care if ppl jack me, I jacked it from somebody else." |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 149
|
Rick James never got sued like these two jive turkeys |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 158
|
LOL. Kellz is gonna get so fucked by this decision. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 154
|
how you figure? Kellz been influenced by alot of acts |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 159
|
the real loser in this is the James Brown Estate |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 139
|
aren't you an r. kelly fan? |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 148
|
big time R.Kelly fan and here and he ain't getting sued |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 160
|
I'm curious, if jazz had only come into existence in this century |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 146
|
it would look completely different. |
|
Mar 10th 2015 | 150
|
yes because it would be less profitable than panhandling |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 163
|
I suppose I wanted to / should add to my hypothetical |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 166
|
th people behind Kid Ink's new album should be shuddering too. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 152
|
Blurred Lines is a McDougall's |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 156
|
^ gets it. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 192
|
music copyrights should expire after 20 years |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 161
|
nah man because then it would be open season on classics |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 164
|
but i welcome open season on classics |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 165
|
especially in this 'my nerd dick is bigger than yours' world |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 167
|
RE: music copyrights should expire after 20 years |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 277
|
YES! At first I thought they had a great shot, then I listened to TOKPR |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 162
|
As Sha alluded to, Bruno & Mark gotta pay Morris Day & The Time for UF. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 168
|
which is ridiculous. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 170
|
True, getting caught doing some shady mess can have terrifying results. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 171
|
<sigh> |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 172
|
see also - the jury in this case. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 176
|
yep. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 190
|
I bet there was a battl of experts. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 193
|
If you think what Pharrell did was shady, you can't know anything |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 175
|
saying it over and over doesn't make it true bruh... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 183
|
It's self evident at this point. Your opinion is based on how you feel. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 184
|
well, my feelings were correct on this one |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 197
|
maybe we just like and know more music than you. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 202
|
or maybe not? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 215
|
not if you're taking this tack, friend. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 221
|
leave me lone, fuckwitt |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 228
|
you seem to be wearing that cap, since it fits |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 237
|
fuckwitt is hilarious tho...it really showed your anger. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 322
|
anger - and also alliteration. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 357
|
dead @ |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 234
|
T.I. is a very very happy man. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 187
|
http://erkekakli.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/tumblr_moeb2psuf41svxy91... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 198
|
Welp, say goodbye to D'Angelo. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 196
|
D will be fine |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 200
|
he owes the stylistics and the delphonics and prince royalties |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 206
|
Black Messiah isn't selling enough for anyone to give a fuck |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 220
|
lmao, he's performing it too |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 230
|
money IS the only reason the estate moved on this... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 329
|
he owes the stylistics and the delphonics and prince royalties |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 207
|
not if his label isn't willing to pay artists he pays homage |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 211
|
black messiah would cost millions to clear. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 212
|
potentially, yeah. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 216
|
Ronson is screwed. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 223
|
Correct. That Mystikal song alone.... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 239
|
RE: not if his label isn't willing to pay artists he pays homage |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 214
|
Drake jacked #hashtag rap, so he'd be the one paying. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 569
|
"Got-to-give-it- up!"...mwahahahahaha |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 210
|
yo, you're hilarious. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 222
|
ERRYBODY PAY UP!! |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 229
|
HEY HEY HEY...LOL |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 231
|
LOL |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 235
|
lol! |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 236
|
LOL. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 244
|
LOL. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 245
|
LOL. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 246
|
Don't think it was the right decision. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 227
|
Iggy gotta pay Da Brat & all Blk women w/ pear shapes + fat asses. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 238
|
wow so u ppl are like fuck marvin gaye's kids and cant even |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 240
|
i don't know people's motives for being happy about it |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 250
|
the Gayes ain't starving. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 251
|
lol ikr? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 252
|
The Gaye family never said it was about the money. It's the prinicple. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 255
|
u honestly think this was about money for them? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 265
|
100%. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 272
|
yeah. i do. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 274
|
none of these dudes are starving |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 323
|
OKP has a bunch of creatives + lovers of art who see the bigger picture |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 254
|
i could give a fuck about robin thicke or 'blurred lines' |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 261
|
i couldnt read beyond u saying nona gaye was crying we won |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 268
|
YOU BEING VERY CASE ONE IN THIS POST, BLACK PRINCE |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 279
|
he's trolling for sure. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 284
|
im with the gaye family and happy they won, ill take a wait and |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 285
|
and then after you cash your check from the Gaye estate |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 309
|
when does your album drop? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 326
|
after i settle w/the Gaye estate. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 328
|
how many checks does prince owe carlos santana? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 269
|
clueless. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 259
|
reply 74 oh and also stay mad lmao |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 271
|
die in a fire. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 313
|
the cash from the Gaye estate check will make great kindling. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 314
|
damn yo.. you really are mad. Not like this fam. LOL... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 327
|
ppl in here bein REAL disrespectful and talkin tuff over this shit dog..... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 343
|
real disrespectful fam..lol |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 358
|
buddy told fam to go die in a fire!! cot damn lol |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 373
|
fuck that guy. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 414
|
IDIOTS!!!! ur ruining music!! *bangs fists into head furiously* |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 356
|
be careful fam, they are driving down 85S to set it off. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 362
|
blasting nothing but Thicke music the whole way. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 366
|
whatever u may be (and thats many things...).... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 424
|
same to you, player. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 425
|
So.... once again... this is about your feelings, not the facts. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 267
|
reading thru these responses i have to agree with legsdiamond |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 276
|
the way you make me feel jacked thousands of blues records. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 282
|
i dunno but shockzilla is about to shoot up a coffee shop or |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 283
|
lol. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 364
|
i hope u dont think ur replies in here demonstrate ur intelligence lol |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 420
|
jury verdicts are always correct? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 286
|
no more than they are always wrong |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 293
|
and this jury made a wrong decision, IMO. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 294
|
that sets the bar mad fucking low |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 299
|
RE: that sets the bar mad fucking low |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 310
|
why did Pharell say some bullshit? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 315
|
do you read or play music? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 331
|
he's completely trolling. LOL |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 334
|
trolling because I'm not agreeing with you? LOL... cmon bruh |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 337
|
i'm so mad i'm over here deleting all Gaye songs off my iPod. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 341
|
so mad your jokes arent hittin |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 344
|
|
yep, try again tomorrow |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 351
|
the world ends tomorrow. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 359
|
shieeet, the way yall acting I thought it would end tonight |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 368
|
it might, actually. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 369
|
word. lol |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 338
|
Fronted a live band for 8 years, opened for Amel, Roots, Outkast |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 336
|
yeah...so much for trollin' |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 355
|
then you know that songs use the same progressions all the time. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 374
|
I never argued it was a sample... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 392
|
Ray couldn't have created Soul music in this new climate. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 394
|
he got away with it- good for him. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 399
|
a short list of estates that will be billionares in a week... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 396
|
RE: why did Pharell say some bullshit? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 379
|
bingo G-money |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 287
|
how does a case with no legs get this far and win? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 332
|
wrong spot |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 339
|
smh, them Lyle, Lyle Crocodile ass tears... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 290
|
And do u all think those small indie artists will be getting sued en mas... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 295
|
the apocalypse starts tomorrow. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 301
|
of course not. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 307
|
not en masse, and hopefully not even in very large numbers. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 402
|
wtf lmao |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 566
|
yall ready?..Bette Davis Eyes:Little Red Corvette |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 242
|
ICGFT:Billy Jean:Like A Virgin:Carribean Queen |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 247
|
there is a song that predates the melody in 'got to give it up' |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 248
|
Disco Lady? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 |
|
no, it was a pre-reggae song |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 257
|
Disco Lady? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 249
|
Ain't gonna take long for a ?uestlove type nigga |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 253
|
crate diggin:legal diggin |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 256
|
great analysis of the songs in here: |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 260
|
B-B-B-BUT IT FEEEEEEELS THE SAME!!!!! |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 270
|
RE: B-B-B-BUT IT FEEEEEEELS THE SAME!!!!! |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 280
|
i seriously think (w/o having seen the trial) that the jurors |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 292
|
RE: i seriously think (w/o having seen the trial) that the jurors |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 297
|
^^^^^THIS is why i ain't mad at the verdict^^^^^^ |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 347
|
why were they lying? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 352
|
b/c satan. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 360
|
white or black satan? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 367
|
white one, of course. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 370
|
Thy're lying like many artists lie that take these |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 411
|
That's a great breakdown. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 281
|
i agree. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 288
|
^^^researched that while typing out his murder-suicide manifesto |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 296
|
I came to the same conclusion playing both bass lines on piano. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 300
|
i've tried singing BL on top of GTGIU |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 306
|
^^^had nothing to say about the clear evidence |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 302
|
So happy for Nona Gaye and her siblings, justice was served |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 305
|
tomorrow, not in 2 weeks. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 308
|
are you still a Van Hunt fan? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 405
|
i sure am and i'll be sure to check everyday to see how the lawsuits |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 421
|
lmao |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 311
|
LOL.. chill b. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 340
|
MJ owes thousands of blues artists money for TWYMMF. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 275
|
he owes the Gayes for Don't Stop Til You Get Enough |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 289
|
I'm sure they are on it now lol |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 298
|
the Jackson estate has a statute of limitations defense |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 303
|
interesting, thanks |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 312
|
i would like to see that knock down drag out case frankly |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 304
|
he owes Mavis for using "Shamon!" |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 350
|
^ actual and factual. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 361
|
and stevie for "hee hee" |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 372
|
40 pop songs that are all "the same." (jack black video) |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 316
|
this video is great. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 320
|
and it shows why this verdict is ridiculous. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 325
|
oh, they'll never get it. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 330
|
Whoaaaaaa this is amazing and I only know 1/3 of the songs |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 408
|
Jack Black? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 503
|
Post-verdict, Gayes mull over 'Happy' vs. 'Ain't That Peculiar' (link) |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 318
|
Marvin. didn't. write. that. song. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 321
|
Just reporting related news is all; hadn't looked up the writers... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 333
|
word. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 335
|
Written by Smokey Robinson & three of the Miracles |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 404
|
I just HOLLERED. For the reason SoWhat said and |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 403
|
Wow, that's way more ridiculous than even the current claim. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 430
|
RE: Gaye family wins $7.4 mil in Blurred Lines case. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 342
|
Pharrell might've been better off |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 345
|
his testimony was trash..lol |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 353
|
i'd have disregarded him and gone w/the experts. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 363
|
not smarter, just a lawyer |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 371
|
and pretty too. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 378
|
sweet doctor |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 382
|
I'm that. Plus I'm clever. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 387
|
I dont know, why but I believe you... |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 390
|
RE: his testimony was trash..lol |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 380
|
so why are people so mad? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 383
|
Bc Nona ain't giving up the nappy dugout. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 385
|
RE: so why are people so mad? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 386
|
maybe they win.. maybe they wont |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 393
|
RE: maybe they win.. maybe they wont |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 398
|
this is how i know you are trolling. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 401
|
the sheet music for Stay With Me and Dont Back Down was posted twice in ... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 415
|
this is how I know you aren't actually reading |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 419
|
so now Robin Thicke & Pharrell have to sue Nickelodeon |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 348
|
Uh oh |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 376
|
Im joking but yeah |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 388
|
I almost wanna instigate and see if it happens |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 400
|
GREAT breakdown of why this decision is horseshit. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 349
|
Yupp, I agree! |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 354
|
For those siding with verdict, how do you think sub-genres are created? |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 365
|
Ray Charles 'created' Soul music by secularizing Gospel songs. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 375
|
they come up with new shit, son. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 377
|
whatever you create, if you borrow and get called out on it |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 381
|
i'm gonna invent some new notes to play! |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 384
|
you are so smart I think you can do it |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 389
|
based on your responses, i think you think i can. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 391
|
if you are from VA you can do anything |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 395
|
Agreed |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 417
|
What will this verdict mean for works like "Hairspray" the musical |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 406
|
stop asking pertinent questions. |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 407
|
Thicke's track was obnoxiously biterific but shouldn't be illegal |
|
Mar 11th 2015 | 409
|
Stevie Wonder sez: WRONG |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 412
|
el Debarge channeled and was motivated |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 413
|
after a bit of thought |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 416
|
stop trolling |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 418
|
lol |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 453
|
IDIOT!!!!!!!!!!! how dare u not be enraged and dismayed |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 423
|
it's not the same song. (c) Stevie Wonder. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 427
|
Not according to a jury of your peers though. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 434
|
So? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 488
|
i don't hear it frankly either |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 452
|
What did she say about black or white ppl tho? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 505
|
k. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 539
|
yeah thats one of the most base themes in this post and |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 547
|
damn. i'm so concerned w/your opinion of me and my posts |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 550
|
LOL, I notice this a lot with very specific posters on here... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 572
|
I dunno about them but *i* do it bc I'm trying to fuck. |
|
Mar 13th 2015 | 582
|
But they didn't use anything from the song. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 429
|
pharell admitted he based it |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 457
|
I've been sayin' for years that he bit Prince's "Crazy You" on |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 422
|
the world without music....Day 1 |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 426
|
^ made it rain @ Swinging Richard's all night w/Gaye family cash. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 428
|
I was afraid I wouldn't wake up this morning |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 445
|
im afraid to turn on my radio in the car bcz all ill hear is static!!! |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 450
|
Okay To Hate Thicke, but Verdict is Bad For Pop Music (Washington Post S... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 431
|
common sense = people/articles that agree with me |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 440
|
RE: common sense = people/articles that agree with me |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 449
|
George Clinton worked with Outkast, so nah he won't sue them. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 508
|
bottom line as well, some get caught and called and some don't |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 516
|
Ripped off or not, the real tragedy |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 432
|
RE: Ripped off or not, the real tragedy |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 433
|
I dunno bro, I'm talking about the incident at hand. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 435
|
RE: I dunno bro, I'm talking about the incident at hand. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 436
|
No, that does not make objective sense. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 439
|
RE: No, that does not make objective sense. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 442
|
Exactly, we can go on and on, but the law has spoken. Shrug. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 455
|
RE: Exactly, we can go on and on, but the law has spoken. Shrug. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 459
|
Which particulars are you referring to? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 462
|
RE: Which particulars are you referring to? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 471
|
#509 |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 511
|
In other words, you don't know what you're talking about. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 438
|
Every artist is not on the stand. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 441
|
if you don't agree with them, you just don't get it. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 443
|
that is correct. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 448
|
In other words, you don't know what you're talking about. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 451
|
More anecdotal evidence that has no place in the case. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 454
|
RE: More anecdotal evidence that has no place in the case. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 467
|
I already stated it was the wrong decision. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 509
|
RE: I already stated it was the wrong decision. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 534
|
Sounds fair. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 548
|
when ray charles started out he sound like Nat king cole and others |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 510
|
er thats always been the state of music |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 456
|
No, it hasn't. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 460
|
yes actually it has |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 464
|
No, it actually hasn't. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 469
|
the beatles and nirvana sound nothing alike. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 473
|
Before we continue |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 476
|
I saw her standing there | on a plain |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 489
|
You're reaching with that one. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 492
|
blurred lines and gtgiu are not in the same key, either. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 500
|
Sure, but they sound alike. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 504
|
all songs sound like other songs. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 518
|
No they don't. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 524
|
reply 458. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 527
|
Cool, here is something of mine. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 553
|
once again yes it is |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 483
|
I don't think we are debating the same thing. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 486
|
lol |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 465
|
where do songs come from? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 444
|
until we hear your music, we will never know.. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 447
|
this is the first song i ever recorded. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 458
|
when you get a few million downloads |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 461
|
every song is written like that. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 463
|
they just don't get it, man |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 487
|
welp initiationofplato believes in those fairies |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 466
|
you made the same argument in 416 though. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 470
|
yep |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 477
|
You clearly have not studied music. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 472
|
geniuses do the opposite of that. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 475
|
Not in my opinion. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 480
|
in other words, you jack other ppl's shit. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 491
|
No, you are choosing to play within the confines of what makes *Jazz* |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 495
|
you have no idea what you are talking about |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 478
|
I'm pretty sure I do. Thanks for your participation. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 481
|
you keep typing and showing us you don't |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 484
|
whatever ;) |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 485
|
no, you really don't, 'Tek |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 490
|
Listen bob. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 493
|
wikipedia quotes? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 507
|
Bob, we all have opinions. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 522
|
fair enough |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 536
|
Sounds good & Sure do. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 549
|
Here you go. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 552
|
To those defending this nonsense.... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 446
|
Niggas want art but don't understand how art is made. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 468
|
.....oooooorrrrrr, pharrell and thicke got caught up in their own |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 479
|
and these people mad as shit about it...lol |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 502
|
basically. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 494
|
1. ppl really hate pharrel it seems. 2. early ska and reggae would be fu... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 474
|
i like pharell, i like(d) that song |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 482
|
+1, I like the song and I'm a big Pharrell fan... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 497
|
people are fucking clueless. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 496
|
pretty much |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 514
|
RE: 1. ppl really hate pharrel it seems. 2. early ska and reggae would b... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 498
|
only thing I hate are those big ass hats |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 501
|
i didn't like that new black shit |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 532
|
Why The “Blurred Lines” Verdict Probably Won’t Change (link) |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 499
|
oh cool....I can make a straw man, too. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 512
|
you've proven that already |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 513
|
I started this post being serious, now I am trolling. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 520
|
Were yall this mad when Sam Smith had to pay Tom Petty? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 506
|
Were the similarities enough to where the chord structures are exactly t... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 519
|
he doesn't understand your question. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 521
|
RE: Were yall this mad when Sam Smith had to pay Tom Petty? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 535
|
nope. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 540
|
Nicholas Payton weighs in (shits diarrhea on Pharrell) (SWiPe) |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 515
|
He's essentially admitting that there are enough differences.... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 523
|
N.Payton has a very non-eurocentric view of Black music. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 526
|
it's bullshit, dude. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 529
|
reminds me of my white band mates who didn't like hot shit |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 531
|
Haha, word. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 544
|
That shit that makes your soul burn slow |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 528
|
lol. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 530
|
another well informed musician whos opinion might actually carry |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 533
|
he's a great writer, but he frequently goes off on weird tangents. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 537
|
lol, come on fam. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 |
|
every song doesnt remind me of another song...as a matter of |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 560
|
basically |
|
Mar 13th 2015 | 583
|
Good points. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 543
|
it's not the same song. (c) Stevie Wonder. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 546
|
yup |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 551
|
He can go get run over by a Brinks Truck. "Fuck hip-hop" indeed |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 557
|
LMAO, everyone is bias |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 559
|
Like god damn all the issues getting unpacked |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 577
|
Thank you. I didn't have time earlier to break down... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 561
|
You think he doesn't have a point about sampling though? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 563
|
We had those sample arguments decades ago of it being 'stealing' and 'la... |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 565
|
So he does have a point... or did you avoid that on purpose? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 570
|
I can feel the spittle in my face with the way he used 'steal' |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 573
|
...because musicians don't steal? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 576
|
Ew puffy though |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 575
|
Justin Timberlake was smart |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 517
|
country music is doomed |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 525
|
This part right here: |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 538
|
i doubt Marvin would've filed the suit |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 541
|
right. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 542
|
I'm inclined to agree. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 545
|
still lol @ Oak Tree |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 554
|
Shake your leaves |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 558
|
RE: Shake your leaves |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 574
|
Nicholas Payton on the verdict (SWiPe) --- Posted today 3/12/15 |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 555
|
He writes like he's a member of the Black Israelite Jazz Club. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 564
|
or a sovereign citizen. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 568
|
RE: or a sovereign citizen. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 578
|
Black American Music club #BAM |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 571
|
I'm wondering when someone's gonna address post 446? |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 562
|
when they understand the implications of your question. |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 579
|
A+ post, would read again |
|
Mar 12th 2015 | 567
|
Nicholas Payton's (current) take |
|
Mar 13th 2015 | 580
|
Posted it in #555. Glad to see someone else fuckin with it tho. |
|
Mar 13th 2015 | 584
|
Day 2 and music is still being played on the radio |
|
Mar 13th 2015 | 581
|
Ronson & Mars covering ass, Official remix with Trinidad James |
|
Mar 14th 2015 | 585
|