Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby General Discussion topic #12388132

Subject: "CC's Broad City vs HBO's Girls" Previous topic | Next topic
double negative
Member since Dec 14th 2007
22151 posts
Sun Mar-23-14 01:12 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
"CC's Broad City vs HBO's Girls"
Sun Mar-23-14 01:18 PM by double negative

  

          

I just got into Broad City last night and I managed to tear through a four episode marathon.

I love this show.

And at the same time I also love Girls.

I couldnt help but compare the two shows because they are taken from the perspective of young white women in New York City.

What makes Broad City work is that you're able to see some grime and grit while laughing about the trials that come with the daily struggle. Girls on the other hand looks very inward and addresses feelings and navel gazing.


Girls got shit on for not having people of color on the show, this was combated by having Hannah fuck Donald Glover in the beginning of season 2. Broad City just straight up opened with Ilana (who strangely has a hot thing going on) hooking up with Hannibal a show regular and character. Which btw, I kind of enjoy the fact that he is the responsible one being an employed dentist.



I'm glad this show exists.

edit:

OH SHIT! I remember these girls, the did Do The Right Thing tribute a few years back, peep it - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kfErkHGPJrA

***********************************************************
https://soundcloud.com/swageyph/yph-die-with-me

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


CC's Broad City vs HBO's Girls [View all] , double negative, Sun Mar-23-14 01:12 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
it took me a couple of episodes, but I like Broad City
Mar 23rd 2014
1
Broad City and it's not even close.
Mar 23rd 2014
2
broad city's incest was less gross than girls' regular sex.
Mar 23rd 2014
5
Broad City's a much better show
Mar 23rd 2014
3
^^^^
Mar 23rd 2014
4
      you know what tho
Mar 23rd 2014
6
           i dont know or cant imagine anyone
Mar 23rd 2014
8
                Everything all y'all said is why Broad City is better show. nm
Mar 31st 2014
33
Love em both. Not sure why they're comparable, though.
Mar 23rd 2014
7
all i could think about was Girls when I was watching BC
Mar 23rd 2014
10
yeah both for me, though
Mar 23rd 2014
11
Because they are both half hour comedies set in Willliamsburg
Mar 24th 2014
18
      I'd call Girls more of a comedic drama, but still...
Mar 24th 2014
20
           ^^
Mar 24th 2014
22
           I think it's a fair comparison.
Mar 24th 2014
24
           I mean 'two different goals' in that...
Mar 24th 2014
26
           I guess I am stuck on this notion you can't compare them because
Mar 24th 2014
25
Broad City
Mar 23rd 2014
9
this should be a poll..
Mar 23rd 2014
12
Broad City has characters you actually like and want to meet
Mar 23rd 2014
13
yeah i'd like to hang w/ all of them.
Mar 23rd 2014
14
Broad City's theme is the illest
Mar 24th 2014
15
It's Latino N' Proud by DJ Raff
Mar 24th 2014
16
      RE: It's Latino N' Proud by DJ Raff
Mar 24th 2014
27
Why the comparison?
Mar 24th 2014
17
she liked a photo of mine on Instagram and i giggled like
Mar 24th 2014
23
RE: CC's Broad City vs HBO's Girls
Mar 24th 2014
19
Broad City is my sh*t, but this season of Girls was very solid
Mar 24th 2014
21
Lincoln and Illana really want that threesome, lmao
Mar 29th 2014
28
Broad City>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Girls
Mar 30th 2014
29
Because BC achieves a goal, it's funny
Mar 30th 2014
30
      Providing us with the voice of the most important generation
Apr 01st 2014
37
Hannibal be killing it . . . LOL
Mar 30th 2014
31
I like Broad City. Never really cared for Girls.
Mar 30th 2014
32
Which would be a more sensible comparison.
Mar 31st 2014
34
okp really is opposite world.
Mar 31st 2014
35
I'ma call you Muhammed Ali. Cause you playin yaself.
Sep 11th 2015
38
"They just found a dead girl on Rikers Island . . . was it Abby?"
Apr 01st 2014
36

Lobby General Discussion topic #12388132 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com