Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn Pass The Popcorn Archives topic #7354

Subject: "you know, I'm not seeing how" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
REDeye
Charter member
6598 posts
Fri Sep-19-03 06:02 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
26. "you know, I'm not seeing how"
In response to In response to 20


          

Bellucci's career illustrates your point.

She was a model, not an Oxford student. She wasn't trained on the Shakespearean stage. She's from Italy. She made more high-minded European movies because, well, that's what they make over there. Even still, she managed to show up in Brotherhood of the Wolf, which is part of this recent movement of European and Asian filmmakers to try to mimic Hollywood-style films (Shiri from Korea, France's With a Friend Like Harry, Crimson Rivers, and others.) So she's made Europe's version of the crap you're blasting Beckinsale for, and she's now catching up on her share of Hollywood crap too. Perhaps she would have done Irreversible if it wasn't her husband's film, but I doubt it. Not that it isn't in her to do, but she would have had no impetus to do something so dangerous.

I'm not completely familiar with her earliest work, but it looks to me like I can say the same thing about her that you said about Beckinsale. Basically, she started out dong small stuff until she had a chance to do larger, more commercial stuff. She worked on tiny projects, little seen foreign productions, and now she's trying to get paid just like the rest of them. I don't think she set out to be an actress just to get paid, but the point Beckinsale's defenders seem to be making is that once presented with a chance to get paid, why turn it down? Not saying that's right or wrong, but I think Bellucci is part of that same trend.

RED
Ora et labora

RED
http://arrena.blogspot.com

  

Printer-friendly copy


Career Trajectory Misgivings (Kate Beckinsale) - [View all] , Sight and Sound, Thu Sep-18-03 12:46 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Exhibit A (c) AnaStezia
Sep 18th 2003
1
post more often
Sep 18th 2003
2
RE: Career Trajectory Misgivings (Kate Beckinsale) -
Sep 18th 2003
3
sarah polley
Sep 18th 2003
5
sarah polley
Sep 18th 2003
16
RE: inexperienced actors
Sep 18th 2003
7
RE: Career Trajectory Misgivings (Kate Beckinsale) -
Sep 18th 2003
8
its what people want
Sep 18th 2003
15
      RE: its what people want
Sep 18th 2003
17
           RE: its what people want
Sep 19th 2003
18
                nobody deserves
Sep 19th 2003
19
                except maybe Keanu
Sep 19th 2003
23
                RE: Well...
Sep 19th 2003
24
                     they all blow him out of the water
Sep 19th 2003
27
                          RE: they all blow him out of the water
Sep 19th 2003
38
                RE: its what people want
Sep 19th 2003
28
                     *applause*
Sep 19th 2003
40
                     RE: its what people want
Sep 19th 2003
45
                          RE: its what people want
Sep 19th 2003
46
                               :
Sep 19th 2003
50
                                    RE: :
Sep 19th 2003
51
                                         RE: :
Sep 19th 2003
55
she gotta pay rent
Sep 18th 2003
4
RE: Career Trajectory Misgivings (Kate Beckinsale) -
Sep 18th 2003
6
the shanghai movies are great
Sep 18th 2003
13
RE: Career Trajectory Misgivings (Kate Beckinsale) -
Sep 19th 2003
25
Gerard Depardieu
Sep 18th 2003
9
yeah. my father the hero
Sep 18th 2003
10
      In defense of Kate Beckinsale
Sep 18th 2003
11
           Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
21
                Addendum
Sep 19th 2003
22
                RE: Addendum
Sep 19th 2003
31
                     RE: Addendum
Sep 19th 2003
35
                RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
30
                     RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
34
                          RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
41
                               RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
42
                                    RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
44
                                         RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
47
                                         RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
48
                                         RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
53
                                         RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
52
                                              RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
54
                                         RE: Retort -
Sep 19th 2003
49
What would you do?
Sep 18th 2003
12
and look at how
Sep 18th 2003
14
Dichotomy -
Sep 19th 2003
20
     
           Hmmm -
Sep 19th 2003
29
                I just don't think it's a fair comparison
Sep 19th 2003
33
                     Not so sure -
Sep 19th 2003
36
                          maybe not
Sep 19th 2003
39
                               Wrap -
Sep 19th 2003
43
Exhibit B (c) AnaStezia
Sep 19th 2003
32
RE: Exhibit B (c) AnaStezia
Sep 19th 2003
37

Lobby Pass The Popcorn Pass The Popcorn Archives topic #7354 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com