| Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
 Best Short Story |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 1
|
 The Animal Man origin in 52. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 69
|
| Principle Stan. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 102
|
 There was an all-pictures one I read in Flight vol. 2 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 127
|
| Best Single Issue (or One-Shot) |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 2
|
| The Illuminatti, by Bendis. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 70
|
| CW#2. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 103
|
| Frankenstein #3 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 110
|
| 52 #27, for Ralph Dibny's scene alone |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 130
|
| Ultimates 2 # 9 |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 235
|
| New Avengers #22 |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 248
|
| Best Serialized Story |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 3
|
| My guess is that Chris Ware's Building Stories would go here |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 159
|
| um, does 'y: the last man' fit here? |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 167
|
| This category is for Best Story Arc (sorry) |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 175
|
| Devil in Cell Block D! |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 178
|
| how about you stay out of MY head, bucko |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 180
|
| Best Continuing Series |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 4
|
| Action Comics, for now! |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 71
|
| Daredevil. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 104
|
| so many to choose from |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 154
|
| Astonishing or Ultimates 2... |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 192
|
| Ex Machina? |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 249
|
| Best Limited Series |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 5
|
| 52 or Frankenstein |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 55
|
| 52 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 72
|
| 1. 52; 2. Secret Six; 3. Sam Noir, Samurai Detective |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 126
|
| Justice... |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 193
|
| honorable mention: paul pope's batman: year one hundred. |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 222
|
| Uncle Sam & the Freedom Fighters... n/m |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 246
|
| Doc Strange the Oath |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 250
|
| Best New Series |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 6
|
| All Star Superman |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 43
|
 . |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 45
|
| yeah, it debuted in november '05 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 60
|
| Dr. Strange: The Oath is MARVEL's best book out. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 73
|
| checkmate |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 114
|
| CO-SIGN! |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 145
|
| It's this or The Boys.... |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 201
|
| have you been reading 'a man named kev'? |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 218
|
| Nah, it didn't really grab me.... |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 237
|
| Secret Six or The Boys |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 155
|
| X-factor, if it makes the cut |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 251
|
| Best Writer |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 7
|
| Ed Brubaker |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 42
|
| AGREED. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 44
|
| Yep, definitely going to check for his older stuff.. |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 177
|
| Grant Morrison |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 74
|
| hate to say it, Grant got caught slippin' a couple times in the 06 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 94
|
| that first batman arc disappointed in the end |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 97
|
| Dude, there was a Bat Rocket and Man-Bat Ninjas |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 100
|
| gail simone |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 99
|
| I second that. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 128
|
| Bendis: For his work on Illuminati, DD, New Avengers, Powers, |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 105
|
| Brian K. Vaughn |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 163
|
| ..i'm grateful for this caveat |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 186
|
| Gets my vote for sure |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 196
|
| ^^^^^yup |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 252
|
| Best Penciller/Inker |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 8
|
| Andy Kubert. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 75
|
| Frank Quietly |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 161
|
| TIED: JH Williams III + Frank Quitely |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 171
|
| How could I have forgotten Steve McNiven? |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 207
|
| ohhhh yeahhhhhhh! |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 215
|
| Best Cover Artist |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 9
|
| tie: Dave Johnson (100 Bullets) & Frazer Irving (Iron Man the Inevitable... |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 23
|
| JG Jones |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 36
|
| shit.... i forgot about him! |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 61
|
| Co-sign |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 241
|
| James Jean (Fables) |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 53
|
| Alex Ross for Justice |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 54
|
| RE: Alex Ross for Justice |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 122
|
| Arthur Suydam (Marvel Zombies, y'all!) |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 65
|
| Two for Frazer Irving. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 76
|
| Best Event |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 10
|
| CIVIL WAR |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 31
|
| ^What he said^ |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 194
|
| 52 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 37
|
| 52 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 47
|
| 52 (c) Red Tornado |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 129
|
| Seven Soldiers |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 77
|
| Infiinite Crisis! |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 98
|
| Civil War!!! (52 doesn't feel like an 'event' to me) |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 160
|
| Best Hero |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 11
|
| Hal Jordan |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 78
|
| Black Adam and Frankenstein |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 96
|
| Spider-man. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 106
|
| RE: Spider-man. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 123
|
| agreed |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 151
|
| welp, I'm convinced! |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 179
|
| Yup... |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 195
|
| Cap is really the only other dude in the running. But I'm a Marvel guy. |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 202
|
| Best Villain |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 12
|
| Iron Man |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 39
|
| Enter: Reed Richards, The Retard! |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 79
|
| Skeets and Luthor |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 95
|
| 2 fer Skeets |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 131
|
| tres para los Skeetos!! |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 168
|
| Make that Quatro Skeets-o |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 189
|
| Wacker. lol |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 107
|
| Best Comic You Think No One Is Reading |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 13
|
| New X-Men... |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 34
|
| ^ Agree 100% |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 81
|
| Jack Staff. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 64
|
| Fell |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 101
|
| Sidekick. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 108
|
| Manhunter |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 132
|
| Y, Fables, Rex Mundi |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 184
|
| Tales of the Unexpected... |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 197
|
| Walking Dead |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 242
|
| Godland |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 247
|
| Best "Surprise" |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 14
|
| Civil War #2 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 25
|
| Co-sign on CW #2 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 33
|
| There's really no competition |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 58
|
| Skeets goin' Rambo was pretty unexpected |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 66
|
| Skeets "murking" Booster's relative. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 82
|
| Quesada's jersey should hang from the rafters for CW#2. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 109
|
| Best Fight |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 15
|
| Frankenstein fighting The Sheeda in #4 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 83
|
| Daredevil vs. Kingping vs. Bullseye vs. Punisher vs. Rykers. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 111
|
| Superboy Prime vs. Teen Titans (past and present) & Doom Patrol |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 156
|
| ummm the Cap-Iron Man fight in CW |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 162
|
| Best DC Book |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 16
|
| Justice League America |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 35
|
| Justice, followed by 52 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 56
|
| 52 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 84
|
| yeah, 52 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 93
|
| Nah, that's it! You SHOW 'em, mate! 52! 52! |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 133
|
| how IS the tornado man speaking- |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 214
|
| *shrug* |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 223
|
| RE: Best DC Book |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 139
|
| a tie between Teen Titans and Secret Six |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 152
|
| FIFTY-TWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 157
|
| Fables |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 176
|
| Best Marvel Book |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 17
|
| Daredevil |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 40
|
| hear, hear |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 49
|
| Yep. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 59
|
| cosign on Daredevil |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 68
|
| RE: cosign on Daredevil |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 226
|
| Agreed, followed by much of Runaways |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 134
|
| New Avengers |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 50
|
| Honestly? Ultimate X-Men |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 85
|
| The Incredible Hulk |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 153
|
| Surely this gotta be Ultimates 2? |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 200
|
| Imma give runner-up to Nextwave |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 210
|
| Best Indie |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 18
|
| Tales Designed to Thrizzle |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 51
|
| (tie) Local and Fell |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 57
|
| RE: (tie) Local and Fell |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 140
|
| Chicanos |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 86
|
| Is Dark Horse considered an indie? If so, Escapists. |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 135
|
| Best Turnaround for a once shitty comic |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 19
|
| Aquaman. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 120
|
| Best Series You Just Started Reading This Year (not debuting in 2006) |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 20
|
| Manhunter |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 41
|
| Agreed. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 88
|
| Daredevil |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 136
|
| Scott Pilgrim |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 164
|
| Ex Machina or Fables.... |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 198
|
| this year I discovered Alan Moore's Top Ten |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 217
|
| Best Graphic Novel |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 21
|
| Pride of Baghdad |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 38
|
| Easily |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 142
|
| Hands down. |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 199
|
| Tie: Stagger Lee and Bluesman |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 137
|
| ..i haven't read either |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 144
|
| Let me know when you do, I'll compile companion mixes |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 146
|
| thank ye kindly- |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 181
|
| TOP TEN: THE 49ERS |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 166
|
| Best Comic Book Inspired Media (Movie, Television) |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 22
|
| V for Vendetta |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 117
|
| I gotta go with 'Onslaught Back' |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 170
|
| sometimes, when I'm bored (sometimes when I'm not) |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 191
|
| i *just* saw this |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 187
|
| to my knowledge he never saw it nor read the screenplay |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 205
|
| Saddest farewell (character, book, or creator from a book) |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 24
|
| SOLO |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 32
|
| absolutely- |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 115
|
| Superman/Batman #25, dedicated to & written by Sam Loeb |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 48
|
| It was very poignant and moving. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 89
|
| Lucifer #75 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 52
|
| RE: Lucifer #75 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 124
|
| The end of Gotham Central |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 62
|
| indeed. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 118
|
| Goliath. That shit was depressing on so many levels to me. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 112
|
| Geoff Johns from the Flash |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 125
|
| ..and why they didn't finish with johns' run, rather than that |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 143
|
| i don't know |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 147
|
| WHERE'S WALLY? |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 148
|
| Hard Time |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 190
|
| Best Death |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 26
|
| Damn, I'll just point to NEW XMEN! |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 90
|
| Superchief. |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 138
|
| PANTHA!!! |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 149
|
| Straw Sue Dibny |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 158
|
| cosign |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 165
|
| but she was once, twice.. a lady |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 183
|
| Next is stick Sue |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 185
|
| oh, he'll huff and he'll puff |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 208
|
| RE: Best Death |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 227
|
| Best New Character |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 27
|
| The third Kryptonian. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 91
|
| RE: Best New Character |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 228
|
| Best Cover |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 28
|
| 52 #1 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 46
|
| f'real? i thought #1 was the weakest cover of the whole series. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 63
|
| nah, I thought it was dope. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 67
|
| #1 is pretty iconic, plus it was floating around the net for so long |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 80
|
| it served its purpose, but i agree. |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 87
|
| JUSTICE #8 |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 92
|
| Best Quote |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 29
|
| 'CAN'T STOP THE A-TRAIN!' |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 30
|
| ^knows what's up^ |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 119
|
| "TEENAGE KIX ARE COMIN' ATCHA!!" |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 121
|
| immediate gut reaction, but... |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 141
|
| "I'll be straight with you, Stoat," |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 113
|
| from jla #0: |
|
Nov 17th 2006 | 116
|
| "NO MORE SILLY FACES!" |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 150
|
| WHAT SO FUNNY ABOUT TOFURKEY!!!!! |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 169
|
| ^^^^^^ |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 244
|
| "Geekasm."--The Tinkerer |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 209
|
| "No good can come of a robot in a dress." |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 211
|
| Best New Writer |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 172
|
| again (cheating somewhat), new to me |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 188
|
| Honorable Mention: Marc Guggenheim |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 203
|
| Jason Aaron (The Other Side) |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 206
|
| ^^Thinks he's Charles Xavier. |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 212
|
| To Me, My Posse!!! |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 216
|
| Best New Artist |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 173
|
| cast my vote for Gabriel Ba |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 174
|
| new to me? |
|
Nov 18th 2006 | 182
|
| until this year, Van Sciver was just another fill-in guy |
|
Nov 19th 2006 | 204
|
| New to me? Cameron Stewart. |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 213
|
| best comics website. |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 219
|
| The Diary Of Ralph Dibny |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 220
|
| That is quite outstanding. |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 224
|
| merely 'shockzilla' in these ones, i'm afraid. |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 232
|
| Dr. McNinja. |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 221
|
| I'm changing my answer to the Dibny blog. |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 225
|
| Biggest WTF of the Year |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 229
|
| Mister Miracle |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 231
|
| SEVEN SOLDIERS #1 |
|
Dec 02nd 2006 | 238
|
| Co-sign |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 243
|
| Most effectively revived/revised/retconned character |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 230
|
| Captain America |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 233
|
| I can't call it between Skeets & the Mad Hatter |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 234
|
| RE: Captain America |
|
Nov 20th 2006 | 236
|
| most criminally overlooked miniseries by paul pope. |
|
Dec 02nd 2006 | 239
|
| batman: year 100 |
|
Dec 02nd 2006 | 240
|
| shit was criminally overpriced |
|
Dec 12th 2006 | 245
|
Printer-friendly copy 
Email this topic to a friend
Pass The Popcorn 
