| Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
 There Will Be Blood, slightly |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 1
|
| I don't see much of a debate on this one. |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 2
|
 Even though I like There Will Be Blood a lot... |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 8
|
| Agree with BigWorm on all points |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 9
|
| If you think the score for TWBB was awkward then you need to study film |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 13
|
 you're right, that is an asshole thing to say |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 25
|
 Well did the score to The Shining didn't fit? |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 29
|
| Most top critics loved Gran Torino. I don't base my opinions on them. |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 48
|
| no, the score to The Shining worked |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 51
|
| zuma1986 wrote how I feel exactly...nm |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 34
|
| easily. No Country is the best American film of the decade. |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 16
|
| I thought TWBB was fairly good |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 27
|
| that's basically how i felt |
|
Mar 21st 2010 | 112
|
| especially when you consider the acting performances, |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 3
|
| RE: It's time again: No Country For Old Men vs. There Will Be Blood |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 4
|
| i'm mad there ain't a third option... |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 5
|
| Ralph Nader? |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 14
|
| No, M------ C------ |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 15
|
| Ensemble vs Dominant Lead/Writing vs Directing |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 6
|
| Interesting. I think NCFOM may be the best directed film of the 00s. |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 7
|
| As I said, it's neck and neck for me. |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 11
|
| I havent re-watch NCFOM yet... |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 10
|
| No Country For Old Men is overrated |
|
Dec 29th 2009 | 12
|
| every film ever released has been "overrated" |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 17
|
| exactly |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 30
|
| This is running on from another thread |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 32
|
| THANK YOU!!! |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 35
|
| it implies that there is some universal standard |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 53
|
| I guessed you missed this line |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 54
|
| it means nothing. |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 55
|
| Haven't got the time to really go into this now |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 60
|
| it's absolutely about semantics |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 70
|
| According to your premise |
|
Jan 02nd 2010 | 72
|
| that's not my premise. |
|
Jan 02nd 2010 | 73
|
| Reading this entire debate is overrated. |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 76
|
| Is it even rated? |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 77
|
| did the one person in this thread who used the term "overrated" |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 78
|
| Returning to the original point |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 79
|
| lol, we're both 12 replies and a few days deep into this |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 80
|
| Yeah we really should call this a day |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 83
|
| ^ this |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 75
|
| FOH with that |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 33
|
| Still NCOM |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 18
|
| I forgot about the brother shit. |
|
Jan 06th 2010 | 102
|
| RE: I forgot about the brother shit. |
|
Jan 06th 2010 | 104
|
| I haven't been able to sit through There Will be Blood a second time |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 19
|
| really? |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 56
|
| Film? No Country. |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 20
|
| My answer today, tomorrow, and forever will be No Country |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 21
|
| i prefer NC4OM, TWBB is right up there tho. DDL's perf is an all-timer. |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 22
|
| There Will Be Blood for me here |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 23
|
| Milkshake |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 24
|
| Very well said (n/m) |
|
Jan 06th 2010 | 103
|
| RE: It's time again: No Country For Old Men vs. There Will Be Blood |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 26
|
| I've never even heard of Zodiac |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 28
|
| They're on the same level to me |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 36
|
| Zodiac has placed on many best of the decade lists |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 42
|
| yes...yes...YES |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 37
|
| RE: yes...yes...YES |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 43
|
| Cosign much of this, especially regarding Bardem and TLJ's acting. |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 38
|
| I'm reading OIL! right now, and so far it seems like Dano nailed it |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 39
|
| He took HUGE liberties |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 47
|
| yeah, the most noticable difference 100+ pages in |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 63
|
| Right on, Sponge. |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 41
|
| Yup same here re: this - |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 45
|
| Zodiac is so slept-on. |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 62
|
| Nothing has chganged |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 31
|
| Better Film: No Country. More entertaining (for me): TWBB |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 40
|
| The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 44
|
| No Country easily |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 46
|
| No Country is the better film, TWBB has better individual scenes |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 49
|
| No Country still rules. There Will Be Blood still drools. |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 50
|
| i really like both but i give it to no country |
|
Dec 30th 2009 | 52
|
| i still fall on the side of No Country easily |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 57
|
| No Country |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 58
|
| RE: No Country |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 59
|
| There Will Be Blood is much better than Inglourious Basterds. |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 69
|
| RE: No Country |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 71
|
| Anton's hair > There Will Be Blood |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 61
|
| I DRINK IT UP |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 64
|
| i don;t think i really understand TWBB. why does he murder the preacher? |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 65
|
| RE: i don;t think i really understand TWBB. why does he murder the preac... |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 66
|
| but that guy wasn't an obstacle at that point |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 67
|
| RE: but that guy wasn't an obstacle at that point |
|
Dec 31st 2009 | 68
|
| yes, but like I said he was overdue |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 74
|
| you didn't understand NCFOM either |
|
Jan 08th 2010 | 110
|
| I find it hard to find anything wrong with There Will Be Blood... |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 81
|
| can someone explain the "point" of No Country to me? |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 82
|
| RE: can someone explain the "point" of No Country to me? |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 84
|
| I can take it from here |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 85
|
| RE: I can take it from here |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 86
|
| Yep. I'll elaborate further. |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 87
|
| RE: Yep. I'll elaborate further. |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 88
|
| RE: Yep. I'll elaborate further. |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 89
|
| ^^^ that. |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 92
|
| it's one of my favorite scenes in the movie. |
|
Jan 04th 2010 | 95
|
| Yeah, most importantly this: |
|
Jan 05th 2010 | 100
|
| RE: Yep. I'll elaborate further. |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 90
|
| Well, it's open for interpretation. Death can be one take, I suppose. |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 93
|
| I've been thinking about this point since you wrote it. |
|
Jan 06th 2010 | 101
|
| What's great is how perfectly it works for BOTH. |
|
Jan 06th 2010 | 107
|
| To me, the movie is more about choice and chance |
|
Jan 06th 2010 | 109
|
| RE: I can take it from here |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 91
|
| Cosign. He's the one who changes, who "grows" to some degree. |
|
Jan 03rd 2010 | 94
|
| I agree, but I think Jones was overlooked because-- |
|
Jan 04th 2010 | 99
|
| I summed it up a while ago pretty well I thought |
|
Jan 04th 2010 | 96
|
| There will be blood. |
|
Jan 04th 2010 | 97
|
| there will be blood |
|
Jan 04th 2010 | 98
|
| Red but its weird to me that NCFOM seems to be the one people |
|
Jan 06th 2010 | 105
|
| ??? |
|
Jan 06th 2010 | 106
|
| I voted TWBB but this thread has been a great read |
|
Jan 06th 2010 | 108
|
| well, i think we have our winner |
|
Jan 08th 2010 | 111
|
Printer-friendly copy 
Email this topic to a friend
Pass The Popcorn 
(50 votes)
(34 votes)
