Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn Pass The Popcorn Archives topic #104217

Subject: "I think Stephen Levitt is a great big fraud" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
janey
Charter member
123124 posts
Thu Dec-28-06 02:19 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
5. "I think Stephen Levitt is a great big fraud"
In response to In response to 0


  

          

If you like that stuff, try A Mathematician Reads The Newspaper, instead.

You can also run a search for my name as author and you'll get a lot of book threads.

Here are my all time favorites, but there are other worthy books out there, too, like this one I'm reading now, Man Gone Down....


Fiction

The Goldbug Variations, by Richard Powers (or maybe Plowing the Dark)

What's great about Powers is that he always takes more than one story line, usually seemingly unconnected, and ultimately binds them together really strongly and deeply. His first book, Three Farmers On Their Way To A Dance, is a good example of this. So is Plowing the Dark.

Sometimes it's not directly two different story lines but different times in the same story, but times so far removed that they seem irreconcilable. Gold Bug Variations is a good example of this.

Sometimes he takes the same story and emphasizes different aspects of it. Well, okay, here I'm thinking of The Time of Our Singing and the themes of music and race, but this one could also fall into either of the preceding categories.

So he makes you see how disparate ideas and seemingly unconnected stories all work together.

I sometimes feel as though reading his work enriches my life because he gives words to intuitions that I've had that I haven't had words for. Sometimes I think he has identified emotions or responses that I felt but couldn't articulate. So I actually believe that I am a more whole person emotionally than I was before I started reading his writing, and that is an extremely unusual experience for me with respect to a novelist. I think mostly what I get from books is recognizable and known emotion, or imparted intelligence/knowledge. I don't think any other writer has actually enriched my life in this way.

The Sparrow, by Mary Doria Russell

Russell is an anthropologist and a cradle Catholic who converted to Judaism. She wanted to write about the meeting of two cultures that have nothing in common and the role of faith in such a meeting and the only way she could do this is to set her book in the future and include space travel, because every culture on Earth is permeated by Gap and Starbucks. So she brings her anthropology background and her thoughtful exploration of faith to this, her first (and best) novel. The story is fun (including the idea that the only organization with the will and the funds to undertake space exploration is the Society of Jesus (the Jesuits), who have a long and dark history of exploration already, lol) and compelling (and beautiful and ugly and sad and uplifting and a lot of things), but what's really going on here is the question of the role of God in one's life, and what does it mean to your faith if you feel as though you have been abandoned by God. It's a kind of modern day Dark Night of the Soul, but it completely sneaks up on you.

The Names of the Dead, by Stewart O'Nan

This is the first book I ever read that made me think that Vietnam War lit would have anything to add to my life. This is the story of a man in search of himself, a man struggling to be a good man and a whole man and a good father and so forth, and also struggling to assimilate or work through his experiences in Vietnam. It also has aspects of thriller/mystery, which keeps the plot moving along.

The Human Stain, by Philip Roth

I could never quite get why people raved so much about Roth until I read The Human Stain. It has passages of some of the best writing I've read in recent years, and it's sad and it's thought-provoking and it's funny. The film could never match the book because of the nature of film. The book is written from a particular point of view -- the perennial Zuckerman, who looks at Coleman Silk and thinks about how Silk's life happened to move in the paths that it did. This is a FAR cry from just telling Silk's story, which the film more or less purports to do. In the book Zuckerman is always saying to himself things like: So I thought about what it would have been like or what would have motivated him.... And that makes it very moving in a really quiet and lovely way. But there are also just hysterically funny passages. And the characters are drawn so vividly. There are other books of Roth's that I like a lot, but to my mind nothing measures up to this.

Cloud Atlas, by David Mitchell

This book is like those Russian nested dolls. You open one and there's another, and you open that, and there's another one. Cloud Atlas is six nested stories, all different genres, all very lightly connected thematically. Story A begins and abruptly stops in the middle, and then Story B begins and, again, abruptly stops halfway through. Same with C, D and E. Then you get all of Story F, then the last half of Stories E, D, C, B, and A. Sounds gimmicky and very complicated. And yes, it's a gimmick, but it works. And yes, it's complicated but the stories are so different that they're easy to keep track of.

So then, past the structure, the substance of the book is really remarkable. It's about bondage and freedom and how we bind ourselves and how others enslave us and where true freedom lies. And there are portions of it that are really so beautiful and sad that you'll cry. There aren't a whole lot of books that make me cry, although I think every one that exists is on this list.

The Last Samurai, by Helen DeWitt

Not about Japan and only about samurais in the respect that the son uses Seven Samurai as a model for searching for his father.

It's about what makes a worthwhile life or a life worth living.

And it's about the value of granting an individual autonomy over his/her own existence and what, if anything, we can responsibly do to aid a person who is in distress without compromising their autonomy.

And it's about what it means to look for your father, and who is a father, and what is it to have a father.

And it's about brilliance and the limitations of brilliance.

The Known World, by Edward P. Jones

Again, a book with interwoven plot lines and shifting times. Apparently this structure works for me. The writing is magnificent and the story is heartbreaking. It's a family saga, but it's not like any you have ever read before. In part because the story deals with Black families who owned slaves around the time of the Civil War. It is haunting and beautiful and dreamlike and razor-sharp.

The Secret History, by Donna Tartt

This one is strange. I don't exactly know how it fits into this list. I'm not even sure exactly what it is that makes me love this book so much. Maybe it's because it evokes the environment of my own college experience so well even if the events are so dramatically different. If you read this and like it, I also recommend Bret Easton Ellis's book The Rules of Attraction. There are a lot of connections between the two, including some rather direct allusions in The Rules of Attraction to people and events in The Secret History, and there is some thought that Ellis helped Tartt write her book much in the way that Capote helped Harper Lee. Tartt of course denies this vehemently, but I still believe it.

The Map of Love, by Ahdaf Soueif

This is another book that tells more than one story and winds it together perfectly. Here, it's two love stories that take place years apart in Egypt. One is the story of a British woman at the turn of the century and the Egyptian man she falls in love with, and the other is the story of her great-granddaughter, a New Yorker, who falls in love with an Egyptian man in about the late 1990s. They're tied together by a third woman, Egyptian, who is observer and narrator and translator, and whose life we see in part as well. The backdrop of the love stories is the political climate in Egypt and the various difficulties of the Middle East vs. the West, especially as reflected in interpersonal relationships.


Non Fiction

Causing Death and Saving Lives, by Jonathon Glover

Glover is a moral philosopher with excellent credentials. This book raises the question, first, whether we can consciously and intentionally create a coherent moral philosophy about killing. In other words, is morality rational? and Is it possible to have a non-contradictory moral philosophy on this question?

Then he discusses how such a philosophy would be grounded. Like, do we object to killing on the basis of "sanctity of life"? on a sense that killing is *always* inherently wrong? on a belief that killing is wrong but can be outweighed by other principles (and if so, what would those principles be?) or on the basis of a general principle that it is better to increase happiness in the world? or on other principles?

Then he applies the question to various issues surrounding killing, ranging from: war, assassination, capital punishment, abortion, contraception, infanticide, euthanasia, suicide, you name it.

It is mind blowing. And engaging. And completely accessible. I STRONGLY recommend it. Not because he tells you what to think, not at ALL. He just describes ways of thinking and then tests them for contradictions and for utility.

And these issues are very important. It's true that most of us don't have to come face to face with many of the practical questions he raises, like for instance, I don't have to myself wonder whether I should be a conscientious objector if drafted to serve in a war. On the other hand, we all hold opinions on all of these questions, and it is good for us, as human beings, to think through all of our opinions to see where they lead and how strongly we hold them.

Mountains Beyond Mountains, by Tracy Kidder

The biography of Paul Farmer. Farmer is a doctor (specialist in infectious diseases) and anthropologist who has undertaken the treatment of AIDS in Haiti and multi-drug resistant tuberculosis in Russia (and elsewhere), and who looks at disease as social/cultural ill and poverty as the single most significant factor in healthcare issues. He makes a powerful case in his own writings for a radically new picture of the politics of health and the allocation of resources, and this book is a great introduction to him and his writings, because he tends to disappear in his own books. His own story is very much worth reading. He scoffs at the idea of "sustainable" programs (i.e., AIDS prevention to the detriment of AIDS treatment) and just tackles what is in front of him with all his force and determination. In the offices of his non-profit org, one of his co-workers has a little sign posted that says "If Paul is the model, we're fucked." And that's a good reminder. I mean, this book could totally inspire you or it could make you throw your hands in the air and think that if you can't give everything, the way the Farmer does, there's no point in trying. But Farmer, via Kidder, would say with Gandhi that everything you do will be insignificant, but it is very important that you do it.

Love Thy Neighbor, by Peter Maas

I'd already been reading about genocide when I ran across an essay by Maas in The New Killing Fields, and I was so shaken by some of the things he wrote that I immediately sought out and read this one. It ranks among the most moving accounts of current issues, right up there with We Wish To Inform You That Tomorrow We Will Be Killed With Our Families.

War Is A Force That Gives Us Meaning, by Chris Hedges

Hedges is a really interesting guy. He did most of a theology graduate degree at Harvard Divinity School and then became completely disillusioned and became a war correspondent. So he thinks and writes about issues from a perspective that most war correspondents don't have. This short book helps frame the issue that my cat Boo keeps asking about: Why is there war?

White Like Me, by Tim Wise

Wise is a hero of mine and his columns (available at www.timwise.org and his recent article on PETA at http://www.lipmagazine.org/~timwise/animalwhites.html ) are incredibly smart, sharp and insightful. His thinking is really clear and he articulates his message powerfully even while he writes in a remarkably accessible manner. White Like Me crystallized a lot of my own thinking and put concepts into words for me in ways that I can get my arms around. I think this is one of the best books on white privilege out there (and there are more and more every day, thank God). He writes about his own history and that of his family and he doesn't pull any punches on any of them. I think it's really important for white people to know that there are in fact other white people who are committed to social change and to have someone like Wise as a role model.

  

Printer-friendly copy


2007 reading list: leave no author unturned, no book unrecommended [View all] , Darryl_Licke, Wed Dec-27-06 08:35 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
I'll recommend Cloud Atlas before janey has the chance.
Dec 27th 2006
1
gotta co-sign this
Dec 28th 2006
2
for the sports peeps: The Blind Side by Michael Lewis
Dec 28th 2006
3
You're not joking at all, huh? Is it actually good? Don't lie.
Dec 29th 2006
15
      i like the book a lot
Dec 31st 2006
43
           You should really read "How Tracy Austin Broke My Heart"
Dec 31st 2006
45
                Have you read the tennis essay in
Dec 31st 2006
46
                     Yeah, I agree about the collection, but...
Dec 31st 2006
48
                          chrue
Jan 03rd 2007
73
my resolution is to read more
Dec 28th 2006
4
For short stories:
Dec 28th 2006
7
      I just bought ZZ Packer
Dec 29th 2006
17
my favorite books of 2006
Dec 28th 2006
6
fuck
Dec 28th 2006
8
i always feel in over my head with the readers on here but...
Dec 28th 2006
9
did you read The Polysyllabic Spree?
Dec 28th 2006
10
i totally agree...
Dec 28th 2006
13
      xxoo
Dec 29th 2006
21
           i'll have to check it out.
Dec 29th 2006
25
                lmao
Dec 29th 2006
28
                     i think his introduction to 'hvd' is meant for them as well.
Dec 29th 2006
31
and p.s.
Dec 28th 2006
12
I'm going to up this but since janey said search her name
Dec 28th 2006
11
Pick up some Raymond Carver
Dec 29th 2006
14
I just started reading Joan Didion again, I wish more people would
Dec 29th 2006
16
lol fuck you I was reading Didion before you were born
Dec 29th 2006
22
      Yeah well why'd you let everyone else stop reading it?
Dec 29th 2006
29
           My favorite is actually The Book of Common Prayer
Dec 29th 2006
32
                Yeah, I can see that -- some of her stuff is transcendent though
Dec 30th 2006
37
i'm reading posts on OKP
Dec 29th 2006
18
i know, write!
Dec 29th 2006
19
damn, i need to read A LOT more.
Dec 29th 2006
20
and nick hornby
Dec 29th 2006
23
that's him
Dec 29th 2006
24
his non-fiction too!
Dec 29th 2006
26
      fever pitch didn't do a whole lot for me
Dec 29th 2006
27
           i must seem like a fanboy.
Dec 29th 2006
30
                yeah, you know, he's one of those conversational writers
Dec 29th 2006
33
                     i'll definitely add that to my list.
Dec 29th 2006
34
                          I know! It's like for 40 years I ONLY read fiction
Dec 29th 2006
35
                               when i was in high school...
Dec 29th 2006
36
for the people:
Dec 30th 2006
38
what be this?
Jan 03rd 2007
70
oh!
Dec 30th 2006
39
Haruki Murakami
Dec 31st 2006
40
I was able to attend his first and (probably) last press conference
Jan 03rd 2007
63
The Road, by Cormac McCarthy
Dec 31st 2006
41
RE: 2007 reading list: leave no author unturned, no book unrecommended
Dec 31st 2006
42
Anything by Christopher Moore
Dec 31st 2006
44
Just picked up The Last Samurai and Cloud Atlas
Dec 31st 2006
47
I heartily approve, lol
Jan 02nd 2007
49
      I'm reading Drama City right now
Jan 02nd 2007
51
           I liked Drama City but he hit a groove with Right As Rain
Jan 02nd 2007
53
           I read a few more chapters at lunch
Jan 02nd 2007
56
                is this your first Pelecanos?
Jan 02nd 2007
58
                     I've read some Lehane
Jan 02nd 2007
59
                          Samaritan
Jan 03rd 2007
66
                               I concur. n/m
Jan 08th 2007
81
           I thought Drama City was great...
Jan 08th 2007
82
I really like the Charlie Huston trilogy of
Jan 02nd 2007
50
the people of paper by salvador plascenscia and
Jan 02nd 2007
52
RE: the people of paper by salvador plascenscia
Jan 03rd 2007
60
a book a week...
Jan 02nd 2007
54
I just ordered that Randall Kennedy book
Jan 02nd 2007
55
if you read Gravity's Rainbow in a week, you're a beast
Jan 03rd 2007
61
I'm reading 'Sex, Drugs and Cocoa Puffs' right now
Jan 02nd 2007
57
just finished Lunar Park thanks to my 3 day binge
Jan 03rd 2007
62
honestly, I'm at a point
Jan 03rd 2007
69
      RE: honestly, I'm at a point
Jan 03rd 2007
71
           I like Rules of Attraction a lot
Jan 03rd 2007
72
                and i'll definitely be rereading that
Jan 03rd 2007
74
                     this is funny
Jan 03rd 2007
75
                          i think i might seriously go through and highlight certain lines that i ...
Jan 03rd 2007
76
                               Chapter titles alone can keep me in stitches
Jan 03rd 2007
77
                                    oh? Like......"Brings Uzi to Gym"? Lol
Jan 03rd 2007
78
                                         or "Tries to Cook and Eat Girl"
Jan 03rd 2007
79
I'm telling ya'll "Beasts Of No Nation"
Jan 03rd 2007
64
alright janey...
Jan 03rd 2007
65
Perdido Street Station, by China Mieville
Jan 03rd 2007
67
cant go wrong with The Count Of Monte Cristo
Jan 03rd 2007
68
just started two that are great so far...
Jan 08th 2007
80
I've been thinking about buying the audiobook.
Jan 08th 2007
83
i've never listened to an audio book
Jan 08th 2007
85
Me neither, actually!
Jan 08th 2007
89
      If I hadn't already read it,
Jan 08th 2007
90
I have the soundtrack for Hard Revolution if you want it
Jan 08th 2007
86
      Yeah, I already have that. Thanks, tho'. lol - n/m
Jan 08th 2007
88
kitchen confidential is dope
Jun 05th 2007
100
so that damn book of best american essays
Jan 08th 2007
84
is that the 'best non-required reading for 2006' thing?
Jan 08th 2007
87
      No, although I have that as well
Jan 08th 2007
91
'The Professor's Daughter' - Emily Raboteau n/m
Jan 09th 2007
92
I just ordered 'Love Is A Mix Tape' by Rob Sheffield
Jan 09th 2007
93
RE: 2007 reading list: leave no author unturned, no book unrecommended
Jan 10th 2007
94
Let us know what you think about Corrections
Jan 10th 2007
96
things i've read recently...
Jan 10th 2007
95
3 Nights in August - Buzz Billinger
Jan 10th 2007
97
Up for the 6 month summer update
Jun 05th 2007
98
I've read everything Octavia E. Butler has written. What's first of hers
Jun 05th 2007
99
wild seed, dawn, adulthood rites
Jun 05th 2007
103
      let me know what you think about them ...
Jun 06th 2007
104
RE: 2007 reading list: leave no author unturned, no book unrecommended
Jun 05th 2007
101
have you read the archived thread on Everything is Illuminated?
Jun 05th 2007
102
      i didn't know there was one.
Jun 06th 2007
105
           I re-read it yesterday
Jun 06th 2007
106
                that was a good thread.
Jun 06th 2007
107
                     I should clarify
Jun 07th 2007
108
                          i almost
Jun 07th 2007
109

Lobby Pass The Popcorn Pass The Popcorn Archives topic #104217 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com