Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Pass The Popcorn Pass The Popcorn Archives topic #22077

Subject: "5/26 -- Three...Extremes and 36" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
kurlyswirl
Member since Jul 13th 2002
16693 posts
Fri May-27-05 02:03 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy listClick to send message via AOL IM
43. "5/26 -- Three...Extremes and 36"
In response to In response to 0
Fri May-27-05 02:04 PM by kurlyswirl

  

          

Three... Extremes -- (Hong Kong/South Korea/Japan- 2004) -- Directors: Fruit Chan, Park Chan-wook, Takashi Miike.

Three reigning masters of Asian cinema team up on these macabre tales. DUMPLINGS finds a woman willing to go to extreme lengths to stay young. CUT features a film director faced with a diabolical dilemma designed by a disgruntled extra. And a young woman with a tragic past is confronted by Takashi Miike’s BOX.

Dumplings (Fruit Chan)-- An aging TV actress with a cheating husband takes extreme measures to regain her youthful appearance by going to Aunt Mei (played by Bai Ling) for dumplings containing a very special ingredient. (Urp!) It's probably best that I don't give you even a hint of what it is, but if you really want to know, inbox me. This one was definitely my favorite of the three. The cinematographer is Chris Doyle, btw. I didn't know beforehand that there is an extended 90 minute version of this film, so I'm downloading it now. A-

Cut (Park Chan-wook) -- A bitter and sadistic extra holds a film director and his wife hostage in their own home/movie set. He strings up the wife, a pianist, with wire and superglues her fingers to the piano keys, threatening to cut off each of her fingers unless the director strangles a child he (the extra) supposedly picked up off the street. For a situation so intense and torturous, I thought there was a little too much humor injected into the story, but maybe that's just me. This was my second favorite of the three. B

Box (Takashi Miike) -- This was a weird one. (Well, they all were, but...) It reminded me a bit of Carnivale (the few episodes I've seen of it) because as a little girl, Kyoko was a dancer in her father's (assuming he was her father) travelling show. In a fit of jealousy, she was responsible for the accidental death of her twin sister as a little girl. Every night, she is haunted by nightmares of being locked in a box and buried alive. It was certainly beautiful to look at...all those shades of blue and the snow...and the costume design was great. But the story was lacking...something. I can't help but think this would've been a little better with another 20 minutes or so to flesh out what was Kyoko's dream and what was reality. The ending confused me a bit, but someone on IMDb likened it to an Edgar Allan Poe story and that made a lot of sense to me. B-

Overall: B



36 -- (France/2004) --Director: Olivier Marchal

An atmospheric neo-noir thriller. Two legendary stars of French cinema, Daniel Auteuil and Gérard Depardieu, play police division heads striving for a promotion. The retiring chief tells them it’ll go to whoever brings down a gang of armored truck robbers, which sets off a brutal competition.

This film certainly had its flaws, most of all the out-of-the-blue subplot thrown in late in the game to set up the all too implausible and convenient ending. Very stylistic...if not for the French language and actors, you might think it was an American cop drama, perhaps by Michael Mann. Some of the night shots reminded me of Collateral. I'm not saying that's necessarily a bad thing, just that for a French film, it wasn't very French. Daniel Auteuil did an excellent job with what he had to work with, and I did find it highly entertaining. Considering it didn't start 'til 9:40 (25 minutes late) and I was sleepy from the heat, that I managed to stay wide awake has to count for something, right? B+


~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~

My diminutive DVD collection: http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.html?cat=1&id=kurlyswirl

I be Scrobblin': http://www.audioscrobbler.com/user/TasteeTreat/

  

Printer-friendly copy


kurly's Super-Duper Awesome SIFF Post [View all] , kurlyswirl, Tue May-24-05 04:02 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
these sound interesting
May 24th 2005
1
You're damn lucky
May 24th 2005
2
who doesn't have a crush on her?
May 24th 2005
6
This is true
May 25th 2005
9
June 12.
May 25th 2005
11
      Ah crap
May 25th 2005
32
           Noooooo! There's good stuff those last few days!
May 25th 2005
34
RE: kurly's Super-Duper Awesome SIFF Post
May 24th 2005
3
RE: kurly's Super-Duper Awesome SIFF Post
May 24th 2005
4
RE: 3-iron
May 25th 2005
15
LOL
May 25th 2005
14
well
May 25th 2005
17
      Maaaan, don't even get me started on that!
May 25th 2005
20
      RE: Maaaan, don't even get me started on that!
May 25th 2005
23
           No, I'm going to South America tonight.
May 25th 2005
24
                RE: No, I'm going to South America tonight.
May 25th 2005
27
                     That's what they said on NPR yesterday...
May 25th 2005
29
      BTW...
May 25th 2005
25
           sadly, none
May 25th 2005
26
I'm tempted to see Brothers again.
May 24th 2005
5
Ah yes, Nikolaj Lie Kaas...
May 25th 2005
10
      Reconstruction
May 26th 2005
40
dangit. I hate you
May 24th 2005
7
I don't know what the hell you're talking about, but it's spelled SITH
May 24th 2005
8
The failure of our educational system
May 25th 2005
19
No, dawg, it's PIFF. Kurls, you should know better, you're on OKP.
May 25th 2005
21
AKA The Movies 1/1000000th of America Will Get to See Post.
May 25th 2005
12
More like The Movies 1/1000000th of America Will CHOOSE to See.
May 25th 2005
13
5/24 -- Born into Brothels
May 25th 2005
16
RE: 5/24 -- Born into Brothels
May 25th 2005
18
      Dearest King_Friday,
May 25th 2005
22
           Dear friend, dear delight --
May 25th 2005
28
           Just one...
May 25th 2005
30
                I haven't heard of it
May 25th 2005
35
           RE: Dearest King_Friday,
May 27th 2005
41
                RE: Dearest King_Friday,
May 27th 2005
42
                dont lie now, KF.....
Jun 07th 2005
51
                     RE: dont lie now, KF.....
Jun 07th 2005
54
are you going to see 9 Songs?
May 25th 2005
31
I definitely seeing Vital. Passing on 9 Songs. n/m
May 25th 2005
33
5/25 -- La Sierra and Almost Brothers
May 26th 2005
36
Almost Brothers
May 26th 2005
39
RE: kurly's Super-Duper Awesome SIFF Post
May 26th 2005
37
Ha!
May 26th 2005
38
Um, I meant to give 36 a B-.
May 27th 2005
44
5/28 -- Earth and Ashes and The World
May 30th 2005
45
5/29 -- The Real Dirt on Farmer John, Cape of Good Hope and...
May 31st 2005
46
Farmer John and the bee lady
Jun 01st 2005
48
      lol
Jun 01st 2005
49
           yep. Big age difference.
Jun 07th 2005
53
Either this post took a trip to bizarro world or I did.
Jun 01st 2005
47
6/3 -- Unconscious and Dead Man's Shoes
Jun 04th 2005
50
Jun 07th 2005
52
6/7 -- Uno and 5 x 2
Jun 08th 2005
55
6/9 -- Clean and Niceland
Jun 12th 2005
56
Jun 13th 2005
57
6/11 -- The Heart of the Game and Ellie Parker
Jun 13th 2005
58
6/12 -- Lonesome Jim, Machuca and Vital
Jun 13th 2005
59
R-chive
Jun 13th 2005
60
Thanks. :-)
Jun 14th 2005
62
In conclusion: My picks for best and worst b/w SIFF awards
Jun 13th 2005
61
Machuca >>>>>> 3 Iron
Jun 14th 2005
63
      I'll concede to that...
Jun 15th 2005
64
           RE: I'll concede to that...
Jun 15th 2005
65
                RE: I'll concede to that...
Jun 15th 2005
66
check ur inbox
Jun 15th 2005
67

Lobby Pass The Popcorn Pass The Popcorn Archives topic #22077 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com