Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #32999

Subject: "RE: seriously, u are in full "whining" mode right now" Previous topic | Next topic
k_orr
Charter member
80197 posts
Thu Jun-02-05 02:32 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy listClick to send message via AOL IM
42. "RE: seriously, u are in full "whining" mode right now"
In response to In response to 39


  

          

>>The problem that you and Suave Bro are having, is that you
>>don't realize that black people are not monolithic.
>
>- see there you all go again puting peoples opinions on a
>message board before real world events - if what you just
>typed out is true, it would reflect in the market. allow me to
>break it down for you in the most simple way i know how...if u
>put 20 black folks in a room and 17 of them want to see UPN,
>SoulPlane, listen to ying yang twinz and lil john and the
>other 3 want to watch Hotel Rwanda, listen to BlackStar and
>dead prez, want to go to the poetry sessions and protest and
>march etc., those 3 are simply SOL when it comes to the media!
>what station/media outlet can survive by simply catering to 4%
>of a population?

How old are these people?

I know my parents and their friends (black parents and elders have more money than the children they support) don't want to watch UPN and the like.

So if you're coming up with an ad for "Swiffer", and you want to show it on Gospel Sunday on BET, do you call in Slim Thug to do the voice over? Do you call in Mos Def? Obviously not. You get Claire Huxtable or Lynn Whitfield, or someone that the people with the money identify with.

I see you trying to box black people into a box, but I actually know black people, and don't exist in some sort of fake racially distorted vaccuum in which every black person is represented on the videos shown for 106 and Park.

>>I guess that comes from looking @ black issues from white
>>eyes, and thinking that there can only be 1 way to look at
>>it.
>
>- once again, that is simply your frustration talking - hell,
>you wouldnt be debating anything if what we were saying wasn't
>true.

Actually, anytime I see people make dumb arguments I have to stifle myself to not comment on them.

I know tons of black folks, from criminals I work with, to their church going grand parents who pay their legal fees. I know teachers, lawyers, mechanics, unemployed mf's, homeless cats....

Blackness is diverse.
To think otherwise is to close your eyes from the way of the world.

>>As to Suave, the sheer fact that Bill Cosby's attitude
>towards
>>lots of issues in black american life is shared by nearly a
>>majority of black folks, should tell us all that it's very
>>difficult to figure out what black people are about - and
>that
>>it;s silly to generalize in this context.
>
>- well an overwhelming majority of black folks that agree with
>cosby are OLDER than my generation. anybody that knows
>anything about the media knows that it has to cater to the
>group that spends/GENERATES the most money and thats
>teenagers/young folks.

Actually, what marketers want is to attract young people who have oodles and oodles of disposable income.

But if you stay on the topic and look @ the products that pulphustler was trying to promote, your generation is not going out in droves to scoop up some koolaid.

So you really have to distort what is being discussed in order to arrive at your foregone conclusion.

look @ BET, they have gotten rid of ALL
>of their programming for "adults" because teenagers watching
>the bullshit boosts those ratings and im not mad @ them,
>ratings are the ONLY thing in the television industry. this
>isnt 1995...

And you know this because you sat in on the Viacom BET meetings, which were of course open to the public.

>>The article however goes out of its way to show how much
>white
>>industry, in this case advertising, is unwilling to
>>acknowledge the diversity of black, insists on obvious (ie
>>stereotypical black cues), and only if it's consistent with
>a
>>white understanding of blackness.
>
>- once again, u are waiting on an outside influence to "help
>us out"...your frustration and whining stems from the fact
>that black folks are complacent and apathetic towards this
>"problem" which they dont see as a problem at all.

Actually I'm not waiting on anything.

What is going to change the minds of black people, the ones you're talking about, about how they want to live their lives is not going to come from Madison Avenue.

It doesn't come from Church, cause half the mf'ers out getting drunk and fucking on Saturday night, clean up for Sunday morning.

It doesn't come from school, cause we've seen how much those things have been an abysmal failure.

It's certainly not popular media, cause black people as a whole didn't suddenly start making moves when PE was running the airwaves.

Life is far more complex than that.

There's no one domino to tip over, an everything falls into place.

You keep stressing personal responsibility, but you fail to see how little value PR is to folks who are still stuck in the same environment.

The good kid still goes to poor schools and might catch a stray.
Those same good kids go to college and can't compete with their suburban counterparts.
The suburban black kids get tracked into sports and music and not math and science.

And their 'educated" parents encourage lil Darnell to run track, and not run the debate team.

I could go on and on, but whatever problem you want to talk about, has lots and lots of factors - none of which lead to some sort of clear solution, that "if only black people did...."

The thing is black people are doing that shit, in millions, and it's not getting them anywhere.

now what?
k. orr

  

Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote


more on how marketers co-opt black culture... [View all] , PulpHustler, Sun May-29-05 12:30 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
love the liner note for missy elliot...
May 29th 2005
1
opt out
May 30th 2005
2
can't..
May 31st 2005
8
RE: love the liner note for missy elliot...
May 30th 2005
5
      minority marketers and advertisers everywhere feel like they're getting ...
May 31st 2005
9
dope article
May 30th 2005
3
dawg, I didn't know this was your book
May 30th 2005
4
RE: dawg, I didn't know this was your book
Jun 01st 2005
22
All I DO is shit on urban marketing goons.
May 30th 2005
6
Just added your book to my wish list on Amazon
May 30th 2005
7
could someone..
May 31st 2005
10
Because Black folks are getting the shortest end
May 31st 2005
11
RE: Because Black folks are getting the shortest end
May 31st 2005
12
      RE: Because Black folks are getting the shortest end
May 31st 2005
13
           RE: Because Black folks are getting the shortest end
May 31st 2005
15
           Consumer is king?
May 31st 2005
19
                RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 01st 2005
23
                     RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 01st 2005
24
                          RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 01st 2005
25
                               RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 01st 2005
26
                                    RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 01st 2005
27
                                         RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 01st 2005
30
                                              RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 02nd 2005
31
                                                   RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 02nd 2005
32
                                                        RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 02nd 2005
37
                                                             RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 03rd 2005
57
                                                                  RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 03rd 2005
58
                                                                       RE: Consumer is king?
Jun 05th 2005
60
           I agree
May 31st 2005
18
it's another form of blameshifting
May 31st 2005
14
i sorta got the vibe...
May 31st 2005
16
exactly.
May 31st 2005
17
Here's a site for you
May 31st 2005
20
reality...somehow?!?
Jun 01st 2005
21
nothing is wrong with it
Jun 01st 2005
28
      RE: nothing is wrong with it
Jun 01st 2005
29
           @ the end of the day though
Jun 02nd 2005
34
                RE: @ the end of the day though
Jun 02nd 2005
36
                RE: @ the end of the day though
Jun 02nd 2005
38
                seriously, u are in full "whining" mode right now
Jun 02nd 2005
39
                     RE: seriously, u are in full "whining" mode right now
Jun 02nd 2005
41
                     RE: seriously, u are in full "whining" mode right now
Jun 02nd 2005
44
                    
                you're right, black people wouldn't eat at McDonalds or drink Kool-Aid
Jun 02nd 2005
40
                     you are using terrible examples
Jun 02nd 2005
43
                          RE: you are using terrible examples
Jun 02nd 2005
45
                          who is"they"?
Jun 02nd 2005
48
                               RE: who is"they"?
Jun 02nd 2005
50
                                    so go respond to her
Jun 02nd 2005
52
                                    are you blind...
Jun 03rd 2005
56
                                         so why are you responding about it in me & suave's convo?
Jun 03rd 2005
59
                                    Nope
Jun 05th 2005
66
                          no, *these* are terrible examples:
Jun 02nd 2005
47
                               RE: no, *these* are terrible examples:
Jun 02nd 2005
49
                                    RE: no, *these* are terrible examples:
Jun 02nd 2005
51
                                         RE: no, *these* are terrible examples:
Jun 03rd 2005
54
                                              RE: no, *these* are terrible examples:
Jun 03rd 2005
55
                it ain't my argument, but i can't bite my lip
Jun 05th 2005
61
                     RE: it ain't my argument, but i can't bite my lip
Jun 05th 2005
63
                     RE: it ain't my argument, but i can't bite my lip
Jun 06th 2005
67
                          I'm reading
Jun 06th 2005
70
                               RE: I'm reading
Jun 07th 2005
72
                                    RE: I'm reading
Jun 07th 2005
74
                                         RE: I'm reading
Jun 10th 2005
75
                                              RE: I'm reading
Jun 10th 2005
76
                     you should have just bit that lip.
Jun 05th 2005
64
                          you're right....i should have
Jun 06th 2005
68
                               Good one
Jun 06th 2005
69
                               hopeless rant...
Jun 06th 2005
71
                               RE: you're right....i should have
Jun 07th 2005
73
RE: more on how marketers co-opt black culture...
Jun 02nd 2005
33
And there you have it.
Jun 02nd 2005
35
      My Two Cents...
Jun 02nd 2005
46
           Co-sign all of this.....
Jun 03rd 2005
53
           RE: My Two Cents...
Jun 05th 2005
62
           Co-sign on the delegation of personal responsibility!
Jun 05th 2005
65

Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #32999 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com