Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #28816

Subject: "RE: maybe, but the drawbacks would outweigh the benefits" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
stravinskian
Member since Feb 24th 2003
12501 posts
Tue Mar-08-05 08:56 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
9. "RE: maybe, but the drawbacks would outweigh the benefits"
In response to In response to 7


          

>>Sure, but vouchers are not the only exit route the
>>government could open from shitty public schools. The best
>>thing they can do is to make the public schools less shitty.
>
>Well, we've been waiting for the government to make the
>schools less shitty for decades, IMO, it's time to try
>something different.

This is why I'm so happy about this thing at Howard, and hopeful that other schools follow their lead, especially public universities which could pull it off, using state funding, without charging tuition.

I think that's our difference of opinion here. I like the charter school movement as much as you do. But I think it's dangerous for the government to lump all non-public schools together, funding them through vouchers which are spent according to popular opinion rather than academic quality.

>If the government can find a way to
>make schools less shitty, great, but why should a poor child
>have to wait around for this to happen while the parents of
>a rich child have the options of pulling them out and
>sending them to a better school?

Sure, but in the vast majority of cases, vouchers are not enough to cover tuition as a good private school. The problem is that there are also shitty private schools. If a school is free from government oversight, and is encouraged to cut costs in order to survive on voucher money alone, they are likely to do so by hiring unqualified teachers.


  

Printer-friendly copy


Howard University to open math & science middle school (swipe) [View all] , tha8thjewel, Tue Mar-08-05 04:17 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
already posted
Mar 08th 2005
1
beautiful
Mar 08th 2005
2
RE: Howard University to open math & science middle school (swipe)
Mar 08th 2005
3
maybe, but the drawbacks would outweigh the benefits
Mar 08th 2005
4
RE: maybe, but the drawbacks would outweigh the benefits
Mar 08th 2005
5
      RE: maybe, but the drawbacks would outweigh the benefits
Mar 08th 2005
6
           RE: maybe, but the drawbacks would outweigh the benefits
Mar 08th 2005
7
               
                     RE: maybe, but the drawbacks would outweigh the benefits
Mar 08th 2005
10
                          Charter schools have nothing to do with school vouchers.
Mar 08th 2005
12
No.
Mar 08th 2005
11
RE: No.
Mar 08th 2005
13
RE: Howard University to open math & science middle school (swipe)
Mar 08th 2005
14
maybe they'll hire me to teach.
Mar 08th 2005
8

Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #28816 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com