Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #25992

Subject: "RE: you're rejecting the criminality of zionism" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
insanejake
Member since Feb 18th 2003
4885 posts
Thu Dec-09-04 09:19 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
105. "RE: you're rejecting the criminality of zionism"
In response to In response to 103


  

          

>you still like to believe that zionists just bought land and
>moved into Palestinian land.

A lot of them did. Some of them didnt.

you try to marginalize and
>legitimize israeli state terrorism by comparing it to
>palestinian terrorism, when palestinian terrorism is
>severely DWARFED by israeli terrorism.

Our atrocities are morally right because we are smaller than you. Moral relativisim anyone?

then you go on to
>question the credibility of the article because of the
>israeli soldiers' confessions
>
>and you asking me what you've rejected?

Im rejecting your rhetoric. You are rejecting Zionism. So we are both rejectionists...


>no, its exactly accurate. the nazis considered German state
>terroism against the partisian resistance throughout europe
>as being counter-terrorist actions against partisian
>terrorism. the German military's so-called
>"counter-terrorism" strategy was studied by the militaries
>of the U.S., apartheid S. Africa, and Israel. numerous
>military analysts have even went so far as to point out
>flaws of the german strategy, and what more effective
>"solutions" would have been.

But Im sure you arent referring to the Nazis because of that. Otherwise you could use other, better examples. Of which there are several. Again we come back to the point of why you would want to use the most offensive example possible. To make a point? To shock? To demonise the Israelis? To try and evoke the holocaust? And you throw the charge of intellectual dishonesty at me...


>>Belligerent means warlike. They are soldiers. Go figure.
>
>This is a pathetic attempt to excuse their criminal actions
>by treating it like its justified.

Nope, its an attempt to try to get you to use words you understand the meaning of.

The irony is that you
>criticize American soldiers in Iraq for the same thing, and
>instead of admitting that your emotionally fueled response
>predisposes you to white-washing israel's crimes, you
>continue on your downward spiral.

At what point did I whitewash the Israelis? I have said on many occasions they act badly, and commit atrocities. The difference is, Israelis face repeated terrorist attacks from Palestinian extremists, whereas the US had no reason to go to war with Iraq...

>>>Difference is that zionism is an ideology rooted in hate.
>>>the Palestinians hatred is rooted in oppression.
>>
>>Aha, and the Palestinians dont hate the Israelis? Did it
>>ever occur to you that the Zionists just dont care that much
>>about the Palestinians (not that that is right either)?
>
>your bigotry reveals itself once more. in a previous
>exchange, you seemed content with interchangeably using the
>word "Palestinian" with the word "terrorist".

I apologised for my oversight, and explained my reasoning. I dont believe all Palestinians are terrorists. Have you ever apologised for the things you said?

note how i had
>never made such a horrendous mistake of committing a
>fallacious substitute.

Your views on Jews are pretty clear from your choice of sources amongst other things. You may as well go the whole way...

Yet you seem content to make statements
>implicating uniform hatred for jews among Palestinians.

There is wide spread anti-jewish feeling amongst the Palestinians, and the Arab world in general. Saying this, not all Palestinians or Arabs hate Jews.

and
>you said that in response to me pointing out how zionism is
>an ideology rooted in hate. "Palestinian" is not an
>ideology. "zionism" is. there is no such thing as
>Palestinianism. there is such a thing as zionism.

Ok then, militant Palestinianism. There doesnt have to be a name to be an ideology. As an ideologue of undisclosed ideology you should be able to see that...

>and what on earth were you trying to say by pointing out
>zionists don't care about the Palestinians??? its obvious
>the zionists dont care for the Palestinians. that's why they
>want to ethnically clense them.

You are misunderstanding not caring. There is a difference between intent and lack of intent. Its a subtle one, and you havent grasped it yet. Most of the zionists dont give a fuck one way or another...


>Palestinian terrorism does not affect the physical,
>emotional, and psychological well-being of the average
>Israeli on any remotely comparable levels with how Israeli
>terrorism affects Palestinians.

Moral Relativism again anyone? Ive had my fill of that one..

>

>Kill 'em all, let yahwey sort 'em out, right? You're a
>fucking lunatic. Don't even compare this to a gun fight.
>this isn't small arms exchange fool. you don't raze whole
>neighborhoods because one resident fired a shot. collective
>punishment is a war crime.

Unlike suicide bombing civilians which is legitimate resistance. Seriously now. Im not condoning the Israeli actions, but it isnt completely mistifying is it?

>>In other words, "they started it". This is puerile and
>>facile to say the least....
>
>this is why you can never be intellectually honest.

Why, because you are puerile and facile?

>
>>Unlike the leaders of the suicide bombers who are desperate
>>for peace at any cost?
>
>see CAUSE AND EFFECT. israel's leaders direct national
>policy.

let me guess "they started it?"

terrorist leaders direct their respective terrorist
>group, not the Palestinian people. your constant comparison
>of the israeli state w/ individual groups is almost as
>flawed as your train of thought.

I see, and the Palestinian people dont support these groups at all?

>>By the way, how often have legitimate
>>palestinian democratic leadership elections been held. Dont
>>be too quick to throw the term "fascist" around. It might
>>come back at you like a boomerang...
>
>WTF kind of point is that shit? You're fucking pathetic man.
>anything that's fascist deserves to be called so. how often
>were the palestinians in a position where they could
>actually have a government??

Even if you dont have a government, you need a leadership, otherwise the man with the most money and guns wins...


"This isnt an argument, you are just contradicting everything Im saying"

"No Im not"
******************
"Dont open your mind too much or your brain will fall out"

******************************

Its 2005, where's my hoverboard and jetpack?

  

Printer-friendly copy


Germans force French city to take down anti-Nazi sign [View all] , zewari, Fri Nov-19-04 04:02 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
RE: Germans force French city to take down anti-Nazi sign
Nov 20th 2004
1
lol
Nov 20th 2004
2
Ha!
Nov 20th 2004
3
seriously
Nov 22nd 2004
47
It's irony...a flip-side to the coin
Nov 20th 2004
4
Man, I think you're going about this the wrong way.
Nov 20th 2004
5
Zionists policies heavily mirror Nazi tactics
Nov 20th 2004
6
      You can do better than this.
Nov 20th 2004
7
           the Nazi comparison is completely valid
Nov 20th 2004
10
                no its not
Nov 21st 2004
13
                the analogy stands, and you are confusing the issues...
Nov 21st 2004
15
                     RE: the analogy stands, and you are confusing the issues...
Nov 21st 2004
17
                          was that supposed to be a serious response?
Nov 21st 2004
18
                          No it wasn't, it was a gut reaction to your ignorance.
Nov 21st 2004
29
                               I'll respond after finals cause this is bullshit...
Nov 21st 2004
30
                                    Did you even go to the other sites?
Nov 21st 2004
31
                                         answer the question
Nov 21st 2004
32
                                              RE: answer the question
Nov 21st 2004
34
                                                   do better.
Nov 21st 2004
35
                                                        Do better?
Nov 21st 2004
38
                                                             you said that specific article was HATEFUL...
Nov 21st 2004
39
                          Co sign this guy
Nov 21st 2004
27
                RE: the Nazi comparison is completely valid
Mar 08th 2005
124
                     look @ this tough guy here.
Mar 08th 2005
126
How can I take you seriously
Nov 20th 2004
8
read response #10
Nov 20th 2004
11
      How does that make it any less offensive?
Nov 21st 2004
14
      you are reacting emotionally and illogically
Nov 21st 2004
16
           Read Mein Kampf
Nov 21st 2004
19
                incomparable.
Nov 21st 2004
20
                     How so?
Nov 21st 2004
21
                          read again.
Nov 21st 2004
23
                               RE: read again.
Nov 21st 2004
25
      what does anti-semtic mean?
Nov 21st 2004
41
           even more so...
Nov 22nd 2004
65
                Co-freakin'-sign
Nov 22nd 2004
66
                     yup i agree
Nov 26th 2004
82
this IS a legitimate comparison....
Nov 20th 2004
9
Picture and article about the anti-Sharon sign
Nov 20th 2004
12
Blacks force klan to take down burning cross.
Nov 21st 2004
22
read posts #10 and #15
Nov 21st 2004
24
      Im making a fair analogy
Nov 21st 2004
26
           Actually that analogy was gross
Nov 21st 2004
28
                I agree
Nov 22nd 2004
42
                     while i won't comment
Nov 22nd 2004
43
                          Neither does his
Nov 22nd 2004
44
                               point taken, however
Nov 22nd 2004
45
                                    I can make an analogy for anything
Nov 22nd 2004
46
                                         RE: I can make an analogy for anything
Nov 22nd 2004
48
                                         RE: I can make an analogy for anything
Nov 22nd 2004
59
                                              Yes it is
Nov 22nd 2004
67
                                                   That's it right there
Nov 29th 2004
91
                                         you are LYING
Nov 22nd 2004
50
Jewish professor accused of "anti-semitism" by Canadian Jewish Congress
Nov 21st 2004
33
RE: Jewish professor accused of "anti-semitism" by Canadian Jewish Congr
Nov 21st 2004
36
      triple major
Nov 21st 2004
37
           Respect, thats alot of work.
Nov 21st 2004
40
Ha'aretz: Israel-Nazi comparison is VALID
Nov 22nd 2004
49
you still put a misleading title on this post
Nov 22nd 2004
56
      is that supposed to be a serious comment??
Nov 22nd 2004
57
           the title was
Nov 22nd 2004
58
                its called symbollism.
Nov 22nd 2004
60
                     that's a bullshit defense
Nov 22nd 2004
61
                          I'm not defending anything cause there's nothing to defend
Nov 22nd 2004
62
                               because you didn't post it as an analogy
Nov 22nd 2004
63
                                    the analogy was freakin' OBVIOUS
Nov 22nd 2004
64
                                         I have 3 more
Nov 23rd 2004
68
                                              yeah... ok
Nov 23rd 2004
69
                                                   well it read kinda like bitterness
Nov 23rd 2004
70
Einstein & 27 prominent Jews compared zionists to Nazis
Nov 22nd 2004
51
Rabbi Rabbi Michael Dov Weissmandl asks 10 questions to zionists
Nov 22nd 2004
52
Collection of statements from Rabbis AGAINST zionism
Nov 22nd 2004
53
      Rabbi Mordechai Gifter: ZIONISTS ARE MURDERERS
Nov 22nd 2004
54
British Jewish MPs liken Gaza to Nazi Ghettos
Nov 22nd 2004
55
^up for the zionist appologists^
Nov 26th 2004
71
You gonna cry cos people disagree with you?
Nov 26th 2004
73
all you do is 'object' cause you can't validate your argument.
Nov 26th 2004
76
      I posted some sources for you to ignore
Nov 26th 2004
77
           on what planet?
Nov 26th 2004
78
                On planet bullshit
Nov 26th 2004
80
                     that's a stupid objective.
Nov 29th 2004
86
                          Sure it was
Nov 29th 2004
89
                               FACT is NOT OBJECTIVE
Nov 29th 2004
90
                                    So you believe in universal truth?
Nov 29th 2004
92
                                         FACTS are not subject to interpretation
Dec 08th 2004
104
                                              Its not indisputable though
Dec 14th 2004
108
                                                   1+1=2
Dec 14th 2004
110
                                                        Numbers are symbols
Dec 15th 2004
112
RE: ^up for the zionist appologists^
Nov 26th 2004
74
      the charge of anti-semiticism makes NO sense
Nov 26th 2004
75
           RE: the charge of anti-semiticism makes NO sense
Nov 26th 2004
79
                RE: the charge of anti-semiticism makes NO sense
Nov 29th 2004
87
up
Nov 26th 2004
72
so, you're anti semetic?
Nov 26th 2004
81
nope, i AM semitic
Nov 27th 2004
85
you sound like a damn nazi
Nov 27th 2004
83
you're anti-semitic
Nov 27th 2004
84
Israeli TV EXPOSED Zionists' EUGENICS Campaign
Nov 29th 2004
88
Jerusalem Post: Over 50% of Germans equate IDF w/ Nazi army
Dec 08th 2004
93
Who are they to talk?
Dec 08th 2004
95
      people w/ first hand experience of Nazi tactics
Dec 08th 2004
97
           Clearly not
Dec 08th 2004
98
                so only people who've been to israel can understand...
Dec 08th 2004
100
                     Nope
Dec 08th 2004
102
Israeli soldiers expose maniacal belligerence towards defenseless Palest
Dec 08th 2004
94
Soldiers are belligerent?
Dec 08th 2004
96
      you represent rejectionism @ its worst
Dec 08th 2004
99
           What am I rejecting
Dec 08th 2004
101
                you're rejecting the criminality of zionism
Dec 08th 2004
103
                    
                          you seriously place Palestinian terrorism on par with Israeli terrorism?
Dec 14th 2004
106
                               Sigh
Dec 14th 2004
107
                                    this is exactly why you're a pathetic rejectionist.
Dec 14th 2004
109
                                         BOO
Dec 15th 2004
111
                                              you're either delusional, in denial, or willingly rejecting FACTS.
Dec 21st 2004
113
                                                   I question your "sources"
Dec 28th 2004
115
                                                        you are thoroughly disgusting
Dec 28th 2004
116
                                                             Yup, that solved it
Dec 29th 2004
117
UN Resolution 3379 identified zionism as a form of racism
Dec 21st 2004
114
request to archive
Jan 20th 2005
118
anti-NAZI is NAZI
Jan 22nd 2005
119
hhhwaaaaaaaatt??? (c) Lil' John
Jan 22nd 2005
120
      it was creative license
Mar 08th 2005
123
Israeli measures to silence the voices of truth
Feb 11th 2005
121
London's Mayor speaks out
Mar 08th 2005
122
RE: London's Mayor speaks out
Mar 08th 2005
125
crack really is a helluva drug
Mar 08th 2005
127
Wonderful, a corrupt turncoat hypocrite speaks out.
Mar 15th 2005
128

Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #25992 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com