Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #18801

Subject: "don't agree" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
krewcial
Charter member
3268 posts
Wed Jan-10-01 11:37 AM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
19. "don't agree"
In response to In response to 18


  

          

>The discussion is for everyone.
>If you guys want to
>take it to e-mail we
>can. So don't single
>me out as if you're
>only talking to me.

Wasn't my intention, but I did reply to YOUR post, okay ?

>Yes it's a bad situation, but
>you are making it sound
>as if the citizens in
>this area are completely powerless
>and have no choice.
>As if they were slaves.
> But recent history has
>shown us that this is
>not the case.

Please elaborate.
I don't know what you mean by 'completely powerless'.

In a certain sense I could say the same thing about the slavery in the US, where slaves weren't completely 'powerless' either, only 'detail' being that expressing or using their power automatically resulted in death or lifelong consequences at best.

When there is a lack of viable alternatives (other ways to provide your family with an income that suffices to survive) people are in a certain way forced to do certain things. So YES, choice is indeed very limited. From 'a little slavery' to 'very slavery'.

>>Your references to 'us' (read Western
>>organisations) not having the authority/right
>>to 'impose' our human right
>>standards on people there, makes
>>no sense, since all Western
>>companies have been doing the
>>last 20-30 years (and way
>>longer) is impose a 'foreign'
>>economical system
>
>When did capitalism become a foreign
>way to do business?
>And what is wrong with other
>countries following that model if
>it is a Western Idea?

Come on.
'following' that model ? That's like rewriting history.

Like all African colonized countries spontaneously chose to organize their economy by 'following' the capitalist model ...

Like they didn't have their own ways of trading, selling, ...
Like they didn't have their own agriculture ...

If they had chosen the capitalist route, they wouldn't be as poor today, with the resources they have. The Congolese rubber was stolen by my government about 160 years ago, same thing continues today with diamonds from Shaba, all concessions are controlled by either American or Belgian companies.

>We aren't forcing anything on them.
>They want to be
>like us. Tell me
>I'm wrong.

First, we tell the whole world how good life is in Western society.
Then, we're surprised people want to migrate to Western countries, and we do everything to stop them from coming (by treating 'm like shit, locking 'm up in camps, ...)

Propaganda's a bitch. Ask people in ex-East Germany how they feel about our great economical and social system.

>>with
>>no respect for the local
>>culture whatsoever.
>
>So Nike makes the watch Melrose,
>eat Pizza, and speak in
>English?

I never said that.

American soaps are so successfull cos they're so cheap (does mass production ring a bell ?). That's all it is, not cos American morals or culture would be better. But most of the US entertainment IS propaganda for US entertainment.

American cultural imperialism is rampant. And as a reaction people react to that over here.

People speak English cos of imperialistic & colonial (you'd probably call this 'historical') reasons and cos it's an easy language to learn.

However, I think more people speak Spanish and Chinese right now, so your statement is incorrect.

>No, the exact opposite.
>I believe that we in
>the West shouldn't be trying
>to influence a person's goverment
>or culture and replace them
>with our own values.

That is exactly what's happening though.
Have you ever been outside North America, and if you did, did you go outside American hotels ?

>I didn't agree with the
>gulf slaughter, nor trying to
>quell the violence in Somalia
>for oil. But I
>also don't believe in telling
>another sovereign nation how they
>should allocate their priorities.

Unfortunately, this seems to be the exact US interpretation of 'free trade'.

>I don't think the anti-sweatshop arguments
>have been persuasive on either
>a moral or practical grounds.
>You mean to bring
>the entire world labor force
>to an arbitrary minimum standard
>that not every economy can
>sustain.

Nope, maybe other people do but I don't. At least not in absolute terms. However, I do in relative terms.

And I DO believe that people shouldn't have an armed person at the job to prevent 'm from going to the toilet. However, it probably wouldn't be the best idea to tell the guy ... Understand what I'm trying to say ?

>it's who has the power
>to set the agenda.

Then I don't see your problem with people resisting sweatshop tactics ... I'm just using my power as a consumer.



krewc
http://www.vinylators.com

krewcial
www.krewcial.com
www.myspace.com/krewcial
www.okayplayer.com/cgi-bin/dcforum/dcboard.cgi?az=show_thread&om=23051&forum=lesson

http://www.23hq.com/krewcial/photo/1085564?album_id=1085556

Nashville recording sessions : www.krewcial.com/nashville

  

Printer-friendly copy


okaygear: sweatshop free? [View all] , notnac, Wed Jan-03-01 04:35 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
i love y'all
Jan 03rd 2001
1
Okay Merch question
Jan 04th 2001
2
      Isn't Shaq's TWISM line
Jan 04th 2001
3
up!
Jan 05th 2001
4
RE: up!
Indigenous
Jan 05th 2001
5
      so my money is better spent on polo?
Jan 05th 2001
6
           RE: so my money is better spent on polo?
Jan 05th 2001
8
                Sophistry
Jan 09th 2001
10
                Widen your conceptions...
Jan 09th 2001
13
                RE: Widen your conceptions...
Jan 10th 2001
16
                     k_orr
Jan 10th 2001
17
                     Krewcial, and everyone else
Jan 10th 2001
18
                         
                               RE: don't agree
Jan 10th 2001
20
                                    HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUE...
Jan 10th 2001
21
                                    This is a great discussion
Jan 11th 2001
27
                                         RE: This is a great discussion
Jan 11th 2001
32
                                    RE: don't agree
Jan 10th 2001
24
                                         RE: don't agree
Jan 11th 2001
28
                                              reply
Jan 11th 2001
35
                     I'm going to try again...
Jan 10th 2001
22
                          RE: I'm going to try again...
Jan 11th 2001
29
                               Argh...
Jan 11th 2001
33
                RE: Sophistry & misunderstanding of colonialism and world economy
d-Best
Jan 31st 2001
39
                     This is 3 weeks old
Jan 31st 2001
40
                          Still good, though....
Jan 31st 2001
41
                               PLUS...
Feb 01st 2001
42
                               quick response
Feb 01st 2001
44
                                    Aha...
Feb 01st 2001
45
                                         i'm suggesting that they become
Feb 01st 2001
46
                                              Okay...
Feb 01st 2001
48
                               RE: Still good, though....
Feb 01st 2001
43
                                    re
Feb 01st 2001
47
                                         RE: re
Feb 01st 2001
49
                                              RE: re
Feb 02nd 2001
50
                                                   Respond to this
Feb 02nd 2001
51
                                                        RE: Respond to this
asiasticONE
Feb 02nd 2001
52
                                                        Why?
Feb 03rd 2001
53
                                                             Basically
Feb 05th 2001
54
                                                                  exactly!
asiasticONE
Feb 07th 2001
56
                Great point. Still...
Jan 19th 2001
38
the whole fashion industry is guilty world-wide..
Jan 05th 2001
7
RE: okaygear: sweatshop free?
Tex
Jan 06th 2001
9
As far as I know...
Jan 09th 2001
11
Hanes...nope.
Jan 09th 2001
12
Ensemblado en Mexico
Feb 07th 2001
55
is okayplayer.com sweatshop free?
Jan 09th 2001
14
a solution ?
Jan 09th 2001
15
terrific suggestion.
Jan 10th 2001
23
Oakley
Jan 11th 2001
25
RE: Oakley
Jan 11th 2001
26
We should be calling out Okayplayer for
Jan 11th 2001
30
RE: Oakley
Jan 11th 2001
31
New Balance
Jan 11th 2001
34
I'm gonna guess no...
Jan 19th 2001
36
Also, RATM...
Jan 19th 2001
37

Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #18801 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com