Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #4699

Subject: "I understand your..." This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
dhalgren718
Member since Jun 20th 2002
16992 posts
Wed Jun-25-03 01:11 PM

Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
4. "I understand your..."
In response to In response to 2


  

          

... point about fudnamental access, and how it is lacking from jump street... BUT:

Schools and their funding largely are representative of local mores: fiscal, cultural, and religious (last two overlap, but aren't the same). States, then counties, then town/cities decide how their public schools run. If East Cupcake, Long Island decides to flood its schools with dough, to the detriment of enarby Central Cupcake, Long Island; what is FedGov to do to even the scales?

Affirmative action is a Federal action to make at least a pandering effort to even the chronic imbalances that START locally. I agree with Grimm's assessment of its origins. White people blast it because they feel somehow cheated – "He took my place when I was more/just as qualified because he's BLACK!" But the truth is, for a LOOOOOOONNNNNG time, it's been the other way around: "He took my place when I was more/just as qualified because he's WHITE!" So what's a little payback amongst friends?

Also, even if its helping marginal students get access to universities; these marginal students will have a better chance at social mobility, and hopefully, their descendents will be LESS dependant on AA. So even evaluated at its worst – as reverse discrimination – it is an attempt to diminish long-term race distinctions, by adding EXTRA access at the end of the tunnel.

http://50yearsfromnow.blogspot.com
MONGO IS A RACIST PIECE OF SHIT.

  

Printer-friendly copy


Why Affirmative Action? [View all] , FireBrand, Wed Jun-25-03 10:52 AM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
RE: Why Affirmative Action?
Jun 25th 2003
1
So what are YOUR thoughts on the matter?
Jun 25th 2003
2
      RE: I understand your...
Jun 25th 2003
6
      RE: I understand your...
Jun 25th 2003
7
           i can understand that assessment
Jun 25th 2003
8
                No, and I...
Jun 25th 2003
16
                     he should try to tell that
Jun 25th 2003
17
                          he has...
Jun 25th 2003
18
      I got your cupcake right here, tough guy!
Jul 01st 2003
31
RE: Why Affirmative Action?
Jun 25th 2003
9
RE: Why Affirmative Action?
Jun 25th 2003
13
      RE: Why Affirmative Action?
Jun 25th 2003
19
      RE: Why Affirmative Action?
Jun 26th 2003
27
      actually, both of you are wrong.
Jun 25th 2003
21
           RE: actually, both of you are wrong.
Jun 25th 2003
22
                RE: actually, both of you are wrong.
Jun 26th 2003
26
RE: Why Affirmative Action?
Jun 25th 2003
11
      RE: Why Affirmative Action?
Jun 25th 2003
14
i have no words
Jun 25th 2003
3
Colorizing the elite class
Jun 25th 2003
5
RE: Colorizing the elite class
Jun 25th 2003
10
RE: Why Affirmative Action?
Jun 25th 2003
12
affirmative action is bigger than schooling though
Jun 25th 2003
15
      RE: affirmative action is bigger than schooling though
Jun 26th 2003
29
In college admissions...
Jun 25th 2003
20
RE: In college admissions...
Jun 26th 2003
25
RE: Why Affirmative Action?
Jun 25th 2003
23
All things equal
Jun 26th 2003
24
Great discussion ya'll . For real. Thanx for sharing.
Jun 26th 2003
28
Can we archive this? There is some cool debate here.
Jun 27th 2003
30
RE: Why Affirmative Action?
Jul 02nd 2003
32

Lobby Okay Activist Archives topic #4699 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com