Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend
Lobby The Lesson The Lesson Archives topic #145828

Subject: "I agree in principle....BUT." This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
disco dj
Charter member
84260 posts
Sun Nov-07-10 04:34 PM

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profileClick to add this author to your buddy list
12. "I agree in principle....BUT."
In response to In response to 6


  

          

>I dont agree with this punishment tactic.

I do. this shit went to trial. She had THREE chances to settle for lesser amounts. But her lawyers wanted to make her into a Civic hero.


>
>a kid who stole some jeans doesnt get 5 years in the fed
>pen...these people CANT pay the millions of dollars in
>restitution...so now what?


Don't do the crime if you can't do the tiiiiiiiiiiiiime. (C) Sammy


do we throw them in the joint?...we
>barely have enough room in the joint for the murderers and
>rapists...so these are hollow victories...


c'mon man. That's bullshit. OBVIOUSLY some crimes are greater than others. It's not a hollow victory. It's breaking up criminal activity, are we as a society in a place to pick and choose which crimes we enforce? you on that Bunny Colvin right about now...
>
>a four figure restitution makes a lot more sense.


and they offered her a small settlement. But her lawyers tried to Shawn Fanning the situation. "FUCK that, your honor...our client is a HEROINE!!!! She ain't gon pay SHIT!!!!!"


...its enough
>to make folks think twice but not clogging the legal system
>with endless appeals, etc because these folks dont have a few
>million to pay the RIAA for their duress...

bingo.


>
>yes, illegal downloading is a crime, but its like any other
>crime--not gonna stop anytime soon...
>


true.


>even if there were no way to download music illegally...folks
>would still trade music amongst themselves...that's been going
>on long before downloading...in the 80's, the dual cassette
>recorder allowed mad unauthorized duplication....same with
>VCRs....
>


which is why artists make royalties on blank media.

>
>we also have mixtapes and white labels...all illegal...

again, you speak truth.


>
>I think the industry, both artists and labels, need to focus
>on making the PRODUCT attractive to the consumer....people
>spend millions of dollars on bullshit erryday, recession or
>not...and when you look at the numbers, people still buy the
>shit they WANT TO buy...ask Taylor Swift or Lil Wayne...its
>the eternal business question--How can we make the consumer
>WANT to spend their money with us?

I think that's irrelevant, and people who say they download because of the lack of quality are full of shit. Am I supposed to believe they buy "good" stuff, but decide not to pay for marginal ones? Really?



>
>Speaking for myself, my problem is not with downloading per se
>but the mentality that folks HAVE THE RIGHT to
>download...people who are stupid and arrogant enough to think
>that its costs nothing to make music...


Testify, brother.



>
>I'm on some James Brown shit--take some, leave some...these
>days, even artists you trust are out to fleece you
>*coughQuincycough* and we dont think about THAT enough...its
>okay for artists to rob fans with shitty albums, shitty
>performances, and shitty attitudes("dont like my new wack
>money grubbing music? youre a hater!!!)but its not okay to try
>before you buy?


listening stations, man. AND let's be real. There's a lot of shit we should KNOW to stay away from,F'rill. we have to download a T-Pain cut to find out that it sucks?


>.you will hear/see only what
>these multimedia giants want you to hear and see...and youre
>going to hear it and see it INCESSANTLY until you like
>it.


Dog. As many conversations as you and I have had about new music, you're HONESTLY Typing this shit?

Did the Multimedia Giants put you on to Jazzanova? What about Studio Apartment? Owusu and Hannibal? oh...we went out and found them.



..too oftenm what I hear from young people is, "we know
>this is garbage, but its what we have...."...THAT'S fucked
>up...go on you tube and pull up some old song then read the
>comments...people, young and old, are saying BRING THIS KIND
>OF MUSIC BACK...


>
>the trust is gone...the relationship btwn the industry and the
>consumer is one-sided and abusive...a rebellion was
>inevitable...the industry so far has been unwilling to cater
>to the consumer...the bitterness and indifference will
>continue from comsumers if this does not change, on both a
>mainstream and indie level...


true.
>
>but on the consumer side...there's NO WAY your large
>collection of music should come from only illegal
>means...people need to be mindful that this is how some folks
>eat...you may not be sure about buying that new Jamiroquai
>album, but on the other hand, EVERY sale counts for some like
>Bilal(that kid just put out his SECOND record in 9 years
>because yall refused to lay your money down)...just be
>cognizant of that...that you can literally make or break an
>artist, that your selfishness can cause an artists to HAVE to
>close up shop...Jean Grae is living hand to mouth while Flo
>Rida is rolling in dough..that aint right...think to yourself
>just WHO youre throwing up that middle finger to---the
>industry or your favorite artist


agreed.


>
>In my opinion, if its an artist you aint sure about or the
>artist is inconsistent--give it a listen...if you like, gon
>head and lay that money down...and if the artist is someone
>that you are really into, you should most definitely BUY their
>album...and if the artist is independent, for God's sake tell
>a friend....youre not really a fan if you dont support...your
>sale is a vote for that artist...how will the industry know
>that you want more if you dont let them know that you want
>some in the first place?
>
>this aint a cut and dry issue to me...its far too
>complex...Justin Bieber can take a hit, Quadron cant...there
>are too many variables...
>
>

______________



http://www.windimoto.com


http://ten2one.wordpress.com/ <-FEB

http://wallpapershi.net/wallpapers/2012/01/boba-fett-star-wars-star-wars-boba-fett-movie-anime-1080x1920.jpg

  

Printer-friendly copy


So who still thinks "Music is Free"? *Swipe* [View all] , disco dj, Sun Nov-07-10 01:53 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
well, contrary to your post title, people *do* think music is free
Nov 07th 2010
1
we've had this discussion Ad Nauseum. it's not free.
Nov 07th 2010
2
well, you're basically arguing semantics
Nov 07th 2010
10
      So basically you're argument that it's free because somebody else
Nov 07th 2010
13
      see post 16
Nov 07th 2010
17
      no. i'm not.
Nov 07th 2010
15
           RE: no. i'm not.
Nov 07th 2010
16
           philosophically, this is huge
Nov 07th 2010
38
           The pants were free if you didn't pay for them
Nov 07th 2010
20
           You going into the store to take the pants
Nov 07th 2010
21
                THERE IS NO ANALOGY
Nov 07th 2010
34
           You can't own no 1's & 0's!!!
Nov 07th 2010
33
           ain't no lock on the door playa
Nov 08th 2010
77
my question is
Nov 07th 2010
3
i know you weren't asking me, but here's my thoughts...
Nov 07th 2010
4
I see it
Nov 07th 2010
5
'Cuz it's stolen goods...
Nov 07th 2010
8
      The bootleg CD on the block is not stolen goods n/m
Nov 07th 2010
35
           Of course to the people buying bootlegs it ain't "stolen"...
Nov 07th 2010
44
                Perhaps the bootlegger is the label head's cousin n/m
Nov 07th 2010
50
                     lol. Then perhaps the label head needs to be investigated...
Nov 07th 2010
64
                          or cooks
Nov 07th 2010
69
I don't understand this...
Nov 07th 2010
11
      RE: I don't understand this...
Nov 07th 2010
14
           Yup...
Nov 07th 2010
18
                *cough* http://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_...
Nov 07th 2010
37
                     But there's a difference between being forced...
Nov 07th 2010
62
we all know music aint free, however...
Nov 07th 2010
6
^^ sense & sensibility ^^
Nov 07th 2010
7
RE: we all know music aint free, however...
Nov 07th 2010
9
I agree w/punishment, but to clarify...
Nov 07th 2010
22
If you have ONE hi-speed dub cassette in your crib... n/m
Nov 07th 2010
31
that was ONE of my points...
Nov 07th 2010
52
I'm saying.....
Nov 08th 2010
76
that was a good answer
Nov 08th 2010
83
RE: we all know music aint free, however...
Nov 10th 2010
107
Who still thinks the laws about this are bullshit?
Nov 07th 2010
19
RE: So who still thinks "Music is Free"? *Swipe*
Nov 07th 2010
23
semantics.
Nov 07th 2010
24
RE: semantics.
Nov 07th 2010
25
      does it matter, though?
Nov 07th 2010
27
           Yes it matters.
Nov 07th 2010
28
           Don't let me find a VHS tape with a Super Bowl on it n/m
Nov 07th 2010
32
I think the sharer is the guilty one.
Nov 07th 2010
26
      From the little research I've done...
Nov 07th 2010
29
Nov 07th 2010
30
Nov 07th 2010
36
i think the price comes from the amount of people who got it.
Nov 07th 2010
42
I've had engineering/production gigs with acts -
Nov 07th 2010
39
^^dry snitching^^^
Nov 07th 2010
43
      not even
Nov 07th 2010
51
           i'm just givin' you shit, man. It's all jokes...
Nov 07th 2010
55
           Logic is an amazing example
Nov 07th 2010
57
                also, it definitely boosted the sales of macs substantially
Nov 07th 2010
67
where are you getting this from?
Nov 07th 2010
41
      "Projected Illegal Downloads" is on spreadsheets fam
Nov 07th 2010
47
today's musicians shouldn't waste their time complaining about piracy
Nov 07th 2010
40
this reply was just dumb....
Nov 07th 2010
45
since you're so smart
Nov 07th 2010
49
      It is dumb. I don't think it even needs any explanation.
Nov 07th 2010
53
      dumb for who ?
Nov 07th 2010
56
           it is easy to explain but why bother?
Nov 07th 2010
59
      funny you should ask....
Nov 07th 2010
54
           just cause i'm in a contrarian mood
Nov 07th 2010
58
           You really believe this hippie b.s.?
Nov 07th 2010
60
                People think I'm joking when I say I'm an art evangelist
Nov 07th 2010
61
                     Funny thing is that I am also an art evangelist.
Nov 07th 2010
63
                          $ can be a reason to _make_ art but not to *make* art
Nov 07th 2010
70
           no industry
Nov 07th 2010
66
you're an idiot.
Nov 07th 2010
74
      tu mado ?
Nov 08th 2010
79
and who punishes the labels that leak their own shit?
Nov 07th 2010
46
They would never do that n/m
Nov 07th 2010
48
conflict of interest
Nov 08th 2010
81
what ppl never mention is how money makes music
Nov 07th 2010
65
interesting, but i completely disagree
Nov 07th 2010
68
      music will exist, but only as a bunch of amateurs
Nov 07th 2010
71
           whatever dude
Nov 08th 2010
80
                Yeah and what's the average age of those dudes
Nov 08th 2010
87
                     I agree
Nov 08th 2010
88
This Is The Part That Seems So Wrong & Infamous About The Situation
Nov 07th 2010
72
technology fucked the record industry
Nov 07th 2010
73
This poast seems a bit out of touch famb.
Nov 07th 2010
75
Leaving out moral judgements and personal biases.......
Nov 08th 2010
78
^^^^^
Nov 08th 2010
84
Im pretty sure this person is being sued for sharing music not dling
Nov 08th 2010
82
Re-examine "money".
Nov 08th 2010
85
it's not my problem/i don't care/it is free.
Nov 08th 2010
86
I can dig that, BUT.
Nov 08th 2010
91
      this is capitalism.
Nov 09th 2010
94
is it freely available? is there means of obtaining it free?
Nov 08th 2010
89
Half-agree.
Nov 09th 2010
93
Music is not free
Nov 08th 2010
90
*applause*
Nov 08th 2010
92
ahh, the moral/paying-for-music-makes-me-feel-good argument
Nov 09th 2010
99
      i wasn't really looking at it from paying to not worry about ...
Nov 09th 2010
100
           Don't mind them, dude... I know exactly what you're talking about.
Nov 10th 2010
101
           doesn't happen w/me b/c i listen to it all the same way.
Nov 10th 2010
103
                but you don't have a different 'feeling' or attachment to the music...
Nov 10th 2010
104
                     not at all.
Nov 10th 2010
105
           i get you
Nov 10th 2010
102
she needs to file bankruptcy like last weekend!
Nov 09th 2010
95
You guys should start using PEERBLOCK.
Nov 09th 2010
96
1) read more Mike Masnick
Nov 09th 2010
97
Does this happen to people who use mediafire, megaupload etc.
Nov 09th 2010
98
RE: So who still thinks "Music is Free"? *Swipe*
Nov 10th 2010
106
"Cost" and "(Intrinsic) Value" are two different things.
Nov 15th 2010
108

Lobby The Lesson The Lesson Archives topic #145828 Previous topic | Next topic
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.25
Copyright © DCScripts.com