Watt is obviously finished as an elite player, but his prime was Reggie White-esque. That is rarefied air.

John Randle was always the prototype undersized DT to me. Just an amazing player who was consistently great for a long time. Donald took the bar he set and somehow raised it to the point where he already has Randle's career fading in his rearview

Who was better at their best?

Poll question: JJ Watt or Aaron Donald?

Poll result (9 votes) Watt (1 votes) Vote Donald (8 votes) Vote