More specifically, good enough to be an consistent starter for Manchester city?

He’s the opposite of efficient, and that’s my take wether playing for city or the national team.

That was my first impression when he came over to England 4 years ago. But I don't see much evolution. And it's not a city issue, just look at Raheem's growth.

Again I don't watch city that much, maybe I'm just missing his great performances, but I doubt it.