Go back to previous topic
Forum nameOkay Sports
Topic subjectIs Frank Gore a Hall of Famer?
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=8&topic_id=2626057
2626057, Is Frank Gore a Hall of Famer?
Posted by ThaTruth, Wed Dec-31-69 07:00 PM
Initially I didn't think HOF when I heard Gore's name until just heard them say on MNF that he is 7th on the all-time rushing list. By the end of the season he will be at least top 5.

Poll question: Is Frank Gore a Hall of Famer?

Poll result (31 votes)
Yes (14 votes)Vote
No (16 votes)Vote
I'm Danny Woodhead (1 votes)Vote

  

2626058, never the best back in the league but a true all-purpose
Posted by will_5198, Mon Oct-16-17 08:31 PM
running back that could help every way possible from scrimmage. tough inside runner at the goal-line, stick mover between the 20s, pass protecting beast and hell of an outlet receiver.

depending on how Adrian Peterson's last few seasons go, it's going to be a *long* time before we see another running back in the 13k club. the nearest active player under 30 is DeMarco Murray -- and he's only halfway there.
2626059, RE: never the best back in the league but a true all-purpose
Posted by ThaTruth, Mon Oct-16-17 08:37 PM
>running back that could help every way possible from
>scrimmage. tough inside runner at the goal-line, stick mover
>between the 20s, pass protecting beast and hell of an outlet
>receiver.
>
>depending on how Adrian Peterson's last few seasons go, it's
>going to be a *long* time before we see another running back
>in the 13k club. the nearest active player under 30 is DeMarco
>Murray -- and he's only halfway there.

Shady?

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/leaders/rush_yds_career.htm
2626061, goof
Posted by will_5198, Mon Oct-16-17 08:55 PM
yeah, he's closest. I'd say his jump-cut style won't age very well, so that'll be interesting.
2626067, Yeah overall it’s crazy how disposable RB’s have become and also...
Posted by ThaTruth, Mon Oct-16-17 09:52 PM
it’s crazy how durable Gore has been in the NFL, didn’t he tear both ACL’s in college?
2626073, yeah he did tear both. Also, it's crazy he ended up being the best
Posted by dillinjah, Mon Oct-16-17 10:39 PM
>it’s crazy how durable Gore has been in the NFL, didn’t
>he tear both ACL’s in college?

back in the pros from the 2001 hurricanes.

At the time, between Najeh Davenport, McGahee, Portis and Gore, there's no way you coulda told me that Gore would have the best career in the league.
2626417, His Freshman year was inanely productive. He had damn near 1,000
Posted by Mignight Maruder, Wed Oct-18-17 04:13 PM
yards averaging 8+ ypc. Then the 2 ACL tears in back to back years happened and he never quite had the chance to showcase his full potential. I remember thinking that he would be a beast in the NFL if he could ever stay healthy. Amazingly he did.

I still think peak McGahee at Miami was better, but their both great backs.
2626426, yeah he was next. would've blocked McGahee in 2002
Posted by will_5198, Wed Oct-18-17 04:32 PM
and 2003 too depending on how long he wanted to stay in college.

that era was so ridiculous for Miami...it's one thing to have a bunch of NFL players, but they had Pro Bowlers backing up Pro Bowlers at the same damn positions
2626068, WOW!!!! Never would have thought he had that many yards.
Posted by Castro, Mon Oct-16-17 09:55 PM
2626069, Yes
Posted by Anonymous, Mon Oct-16-17 09:55 PM
2626072, Yes, but I'm biased.
Posted by mrhood75, Mon Oct-16-17 10:35 PM
Certainly goes on the Niners Mt. Rushmore.

Really wish they could have gotten him that SB win.
2626185, that hurts the most man...
Posted by roamr1, Tue Oct-17-17 05:33 PM
that he didn't get that ring. i read stories how he was the last guy in the locker room that night, just sat there crying. you know he would have fought for those 5 yards if given the chance.
2626079, yes, I thought he retired...lol
Posted by legsdiamond, Tue Oct-17-17 07:27 AM
I was shocked when I heard his name last night
2626080, 12/13 straight years being his teams leading rusher is pretty impressive
Posted by Ceej, Tue Oct-17-17 07:45 AM
2626104, I was hoping Roger Craig would
Posted by go mack, Tue Oct-17-17 10:09 AM
mainly cuz of the Husker connection but he appears to have gotten passed by now.

I didn't think of Gore but yeah, he probably does seeing the stats.
2626116, Craig was HOF caliber IMO. He was the best West Coast offense back
Posted by Castro, Tue Oct-17-17 12:30 PM
at its inception. He defined the role later perfected by LaDainian.
2626120, yep, first guy to get 1000yds rushing & receiving, he's hurt because his...
Posted by ThaTruth, Tue Oct-17-17 01:01 PM
numbers aren't quite as flashy as other running backs but people forget that he spent the first 4-5 years of his career playing fullback
2626187, this is a very biased hell yes...
Posted by roamr1, Tue Oct-17-17 05:41 PM
-for durability
-for overall career numbers
-for the things that he did better than most other rb's (blocking)
-for his locker room presence

if TO is not a HOF because he was a pain in the ass in the locker room, you then have to say that being a true locker room leader has to have some value...and there's no question that's what gore brought to the table.

not to mention, if you think of who votes (the writers)...gore was great to writers. everyone that covered him loved him. this is not a point that argues whether he should be in the hall but one that argues if he will be.

i lived through joe, jerry, ronnie, steve...gore is hands down my favorite 49er of all time. he never complained, he was a workhorse when we didn't have ANY weapons. he's arguably one of the best feel good stories over a career. he goes to the school that produces BEAST rb's, tears both ACLs, he becomes the least known of the RBs to come out of that school...but then proves everyone wrong over a 10+ year career. who goes from questions about his durability to basically building a HOF career based on his durability?

2626310, Excellent argument. Ok, I'm on board.
Posted by Castro, Tue Oct-17-17 11:49 PM
2626327, yeah he kind of had a weird career, his rushing totals say he absolutely...
Posted by ThaTruth, Wed Oct-18-17 08:33 AM
has to be in but without looking at those most people don't think of him in that light. He spent most of his prime on bad teams. Like someone said earlier at no point was he ever really considered the best RB in the NFL. Even his best season in 2006 when he ran for 1695 yards and 8 touchdowns was overshadowed by LaDanian Tomlinson's ridiculous 1815 yard, 28 touchdown MVP season. That's another thing despite Gore being 7th all-rushing he's not in the top 20 in rushing TD's, he only had double-digit rushing TD's(10) once in his career.
2626328, Also will Edgerrin James ever get in or has that ship sailed?
Posted by ThaTruth, Wed Oct-18-17 08:33 AM
2626428, he should definitely get reconsideration
Posted by will_5198, Wed Oct-18-17 04:35 PM
fuck, he's got 12k+ yards in a much shorter span

another all-everything back, he could do anything you needed in the passing game

and there was a period where he *was* the best back in the conference
2626490, hall of very good to me but i wouldnt be mad at all if he made it
Posted by ConcreteCharlie, Wed Oct-18-17 08:48 PM
he was a man's man and frankly given how fucked up his knees were he could have had no career at all. i liked watching him play a lot but i don't considering him to be the spectacular, dominant sort of player i would say are HOF'ers. he was more about longevity, steadiness and versatility.
2751156, apparently his son is a pretty good cfb player…
Posted by ThaTruth, Sat Nov-20-21 08:27 AM
https://www.sportingnews.com/us/ncaa-football/news/frank-gore-jr-southern-mississippi/123anieaenf0m1my1f36zr09ii
2751167, The NFL Hall of Fame is more of a buddy, buddy club
Posted by allStah, Sat Nov-20-21 11:42 AM
It’s standards or process is not as strict or stern as baseball’s
hall of fame.

More than likely, Frank Gore will get in because he will
be perceived as last of the Mohicans, and he is a very likable person.
He has the numbers as well, even though those numbers came by way
of longevity, as opposed to being a dominant running back in every
season.

In baseball, he would be seen as a good player, but not a great player.





2751411, Best player for years on a shitty ass team
Posted by Beamer6178, Tue Nov-23-21 07:35 PM
then still a star when they got good. Harbaugh and Roman were smoking crack when they took the ball out of his hands against the smurfs in the NFC championship in 2012. They COULD NOT STOP HIM, he was hitting them for 5+ yards a carry. Some of the stupidest game calling I had ever seen. THAT was our Super Bowl year, even moreso than with the Ravens, because the Defense was better in 2011.

Running back on a shitty team is a tough position to put up great numbers on. You're THE weapon and you still get yours. On a better team, his numbers are even better.

His heart and spirit were next level, but numbers alone, I say yes.
2751619, Definitely.. dude is like the Cal Ripken of the NFL
Posted by legsdiamond, Sat Nov-27-21 01:55 PM
2751625, yes. full stop.
Posted by cgonz00cc, Sat Nov-27-21 02:16 PM