>But I cant bring myself to judge beyond who tests clean and
>who tests dirty
>
>If he's passing tests, then I go by that

Well put. It's not our job do the governing body's dirty work.

Gatlin... makes it tough though. He's even coached by Dennis "boldest excuse for a positive test ever" Mitchell. I didn't really realize how much I also kind of wanted athletes to talk the "I'm clean" talk until I saw how little he gave a shit what we thought.

Still, you have the most sensible viewpoint.

edit: and i *totally* missed your subject line. apologies.