Okayplayer.com Boards - Printer friendly page, topic ID #2110607 -

Forum name

Okay Sports

Topic subject

Jim "Machine Gun" Kelly versus Payton Manning who got?

Topic URL

http://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=8&topic_id=2110607

2110607, Jim "Machine Gun" Kelly versus Payton Manning who got?
Posted by mistermaxxx08, Wed Dec-31-69 07:00 PM

aside from winning a Super Bowl is Payton Manning that much better than the Great Jim Kelly?

i mean you could make the argument that Jim Kelly was a better postseason QB and had stats,etc...

Poll question: Jim "Machine Gun" Kelly versus Payton Manning who got?

Poll result (8 votes)
Jim Kelly	(1 votes)	Vote
PaYTON Manning	(0 votes)	Vote
a draw	(0 votes)	Vote
only a Bills fan would bring this debate up	(7 votes)	Vote

2110613, oh, dear
Posted by Dstl1, Sun Jan-13-13 02:57 PM

.

2110622, Aside from superbowl, MVPs, pro bowls, yards, TDs and QB rating?
Posted by Y2Flound, Sun Jan-13-13 03:05 PM

And also pretty much every other stat?

2110624, Cmon ... Peyton better
Posted by ConcreteCharlie, Sun Jan-13-13 03:06 PM

2110633, Your thoughts on Marrone?
Posted by Rick Fox Jr, Sun Jan-13-13 03:13 PM