I think RG3 deserves it and Wilson is definitely in the conversation, but he's been penciled in as ROY since January 2011. Just living up to the hype is the biggest battle for #1 picks.

Take away the hype and judge them strictly on performance, I think RG3 gets it (don't really care who comes in second). But the hype plays a big role so Luck started with a headstart and has held his own (which is kinda crazy to say because he's been very good... I just think RG3 has been better).