There's no argument for Luck, tho.

Wilson looks as good or better than RG3, in my opinion. And he's one of the main reasons the Seahawks are the best team in the NFL right now. His numbers are close enough to RG3 that, if you also factor in the defenses he's accumulated them against and the dominance of his team, combine to make a great case for OROY.

Any votes Luck gets are guys voting in the hopes that the lightbulb goes on in the future and he looks like the right choice 5 years from now.

The Colts weren't a real 2-14 team - that argument is garbage. Half the teams in this league are 2-14 with Curtis Painter starting as many games as he did. Both the Skins and the Colts got 2 wins in their final 12 games of 2011, yet RG3 walked into a "much better situation" than Luck.