took a team from last place to the playoffs, when virtually no one thought that would happen going into the season. he did this with the head coach being absent for half the season due to leukemia. He was immediately able to step out of Peyton's shadow. it also seems like Luck was given the entire playbook from game one whereas RG3 and Russell were managed the first half of the season

the only knock against him is the INTs

there's a strong case for each qb imo