there are far better players in the league than Melo, so not top 10(unless you go off of scoring and don't consider leadership and other parts of the game), but he cracks top 15 fairly easily. Reality is, Melo is just not that good, and definitely not as good as he was supposed to be.

For instance:

Lebron
D12
Rose
Deron
Rondo
Durant
Westbrook
Bean
Wade
Dirk
Tony Parker
Andrew Bynum (yeah, he is)
CP3