Go back to previous topic
Forum namePass The Popcorn
Topic subjectRE: This is actually the crux of the "fan service" debate
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=6&topic_id=718024&mesg_id=718611
718611, RE: This is actually the crux of the "fan service" debate
Posted by Heinz, Thu Dec-22-16 04:11 PM
>Nobody said cut the action, it's the best part of the movie.
>
>But, for instance, you could cut Tarkin taking over command of
>the Death Star, which is only there to give Krennic as reason
>to go see Darth Vader, who immediately gives control back to
>Krennic. I see little point to this section besides getting
>Darth Vader into the movie earlier (and I wouldn't be
>surprised if this was one of the scenes that was added.)
>
I don't count this as fan service. It's more interesting than any motivation they could've shown that I said I wish was there. But those reasons for the motivation shown didn't have enough reason's to back it up. This plot of the story give's Krennic those reasons for his motivation. It would be stupid to take it out. They just needed to do the same justification for the Rebels. Calling it "fan service" doesn't make sense at all. Those words are being thrown around recklessly.

>I get that fans are geeked about seeing Darth in his
>incubator-thingy but I'd have preferred that they spent more
>time with the actual main characters of this movie instead.

No. Theres no reason why both couldn't have been shown other than time. II wouldve just made the movie a tad longer to show those motivations better. Which in turn would've developed them. It didnt even feel long to me so I wouldnt have cared.