as a minority of people are making it out to be. I think they couldn't have made a better depiction of how he was animated being that the movie itself looked really GOOD as far as cinematography goes...it was gritty, unlike the prequels which was overdone with too much environmental CGI..and too clean whereas a Tarkin like character would stand out as probably the most quality piece in a movie like the prequels.....but Rogue One just "looked" too different for that character to blend in as well as we would like. And when he is on screen for that extended time, the contrasts show.



And then some say that they should have had the dude that played Tarkin from Ep. 3. (i forget the actor's name)

But...Im on the train where i believe Tarkin HAD to be there.