> (Also, I'm not so
>sure what Sepinwall's "debunking" was but I feel like it
>wouldn't be TOO crazy for the Man in Black theory to be true.
>Not sure we've seen anything that completely blows it out of
>the water.)

Dolores sees the man in black (a memory) before she kills the one guy in the barn...the she rides off and ends up meeting up with the guy in the white hat. This all happens the same night. Unless they are really trying to trick us, it wouldn't make any sense for them to be the same guy. This is the first time Dolores has gone off the reservation.