People were going off on the show heading into a level of fantasy. I would have been fine if someone had said, "Guys, this story isn't going to turn into Lord of the Rings."

Although, this show is a little different because Sepinwall only saw four episodes so it's not like he knows the end game. It's just something that gets debunked early on.

Perhaps the bigger issue is that unless something happens NEXT episode to put the idea to bed, nothing in this episode debunked it outright. The gun she used wasn't the one that Marsden gave her, the fact that she walks over to Jimmy doesn't necessarily mean it's the same timeline (she was on a horse when she took off from the house.)

In the future though, I'll refrain from posting stuff like this since people think it's spoilery.