you made a bad argument, and now you're bending the truth to support it.

you can't claim hershel (who appeared in 37 episodes) was a
'major character' and then dismiss beth (50 eps) and tyreese (31)
as sacrificial redshirts on a par with deanna (14) and noah (10)

hershel, beth and tyreese all appeared in multiple story arcs
over multiple seasons, and all were credited with the main cast
in the opening titles. whereas deanna and noah never rose above
recurring / also starring, and neither even made it through a
full season of episodes. so that isn't a valid comparison.

the show's never had an issue with killing off main cast members.
any suggestion otherwise is just ignoring the facts.






>They weren't major. Just background characters that they
>tried to flesh out just before they killed them off. They did
>the same with Bob, Noah, Deana, ect. Bring them in, they
>mostly do nothing and then get a little story arc before their
>death.