the handsome, chosen alpha male that women should be throwing themselves at. In his manifesto and his posts, he railed against nerd/slob/beta male types who did better with women than he did because they "didn't deserve it."

I don't think seeing Jonah Hill (kind of) get with Emma Stone in Superbad was a wish fulfillment for him. If anything, it just would've made him madder, because in his mind those types of women were supposed to belong to him.