Go back to previous topic
Forum namePass The Popcorn
Topic subjectWho would win in an all out fight? Dr Doom or Magneto?
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=6&topic_id=393984
393984, Who would win in an all out fight? Dr Doom or Magneto?
Posted by normal35762, Wed Dec-31-69 07:00 PM
I don't know who would win but Id be rooting for Dr.Doom.

Poll question: Who would win in an all out fight? Dr Doom or Magneto?

Poll result (32 votes)
Dr. Doom (9 votes)Vote
Magneto (23 votes)Vote

  

393987, Depends
Posted by El_Pistolero, Mon Aug-11-08 02:51 PM
Is Dr. Doom wearing his traditional suit or one made out of plastic?
393989, he got a plastic one?
Posted by normal35762, Mon Aug-11-08 02:53 PM
393995, No but why would he fight Magneto in his regular one?
Posted by El_Pistolero, Mon Aug-11-08 03:01 PM
He would be rendered useless.
394003, I was thinking he'd have a force field to block Magnetos powers...
Posted by normal35762, Mon Aug-11-08 03:15 PM
from touching him.
394253, Doom has everything you best remember this you pissant!
Posted by ShinobiShaw, Tue Aug-12-08 01:12 PM

<------ Boho Model Madness Presents: Dimepiece

http://www.rareformnyc.com
http://www.myspace.com/shinobishaw
http://www.myspace.com/djshinobishaw
http://www.last.fm/user/ShinoShaw
393998, Doom depends too much on metal and equipment to stand a chance.
Posted by McDeezNuts, Mon Aug-11-08 03:06 PM
But if Doom had "prep time" to build a plastic suit and some specialized means of neutralizing Magneto's powers, then sure.

Doom is a genius of incedible magnitude (much more so than Batman); I wouldn't count him out against anyone if he has enough time. Not to say that Magneto couldn't make good use of prep time too.

Still, Magneto is way more powerful as is.
394004, Magneto has killed people by slowing the flow of iron in their bloodstream
Posted by Melanism, Mon Aug-11-08 03:18 PM
He's got my vote.
-------------------
"Fuck yo couch, nigga!" - Tom Cruise

http://melanism.com
http://preptimeposse.blogspot.com
http://myblogisanopenbook.blogspot.com
http://www.myspace.com/melanism
http://www.last.fm/user/Melanism/
394021, Yup.
Posted by CaptNish, Mon Aug-11-08 04:11 PM
.
394011, been there, done that
Posted by spades, Mon Aug-11-08 03:38 PM
Magneto won.
394033, Any Normal Day = Magneto. Prep-Time = Doom hands down.
Posted by WarriorPoet415, Mon Aug-11-08 05:28 PM
Between his evil genius and the fact that he has a time machine, he wins.

But if Doom just chillin' bump into Magneto and steps on his jordans, his ass is toast.
______________________________________________________________________________

R.I.P. Sean Taylor, 1983-2007

http://cscpov.blogspot.com/

"There's a fine line between persistence and foolishness..."
-unknown

"To Each His Reach"
-George Clinton
394034, LOL
Posted by 40thStreetBlack, Mon Aug-11-08 05:33 PM
>But if Doom just chillin' bump into Magneto and steps on his
>jordans, his ass is toast.


394053, lmfao
Posted by BrooklynWHAT, Mon Aug-11-08 06:46 PM
414354, RE: Any Normal Day = Magneto. Prep-Time = Doom hands down.
Posted by electricflower, Sun Nov-16-08 09:41 AM
Oh shit! , * spits drinks *
394042, Mag
Posted by las raises, Mon Aug-11-08 06:14 PM
.
394043, Batman.
Posted by mrhood75, Mon Aug-11-08 06:20 PM
394044, ever squeeze a can of Alpo really, really hard?
Posted by buckshot defunct, Mon Aug-11-08 06:21 PM
Yeah. It'd look something like that.
394047, Doom has magic, aight.
Posted by kevlar skully, Mon Aug-11-08 06:25 PM
Magic.



Doom wins.
394071, You didn't really think this one out, did you?
Posted by icecold21, Mon Aug-11-08 08:15 PM
Doom is hella powerful, but he wears a suit of armor that is made of metal. When you consider this, along with the fact that Magneto is probably the most powerful mutant in existence, Doom takes a big-sized L. The only way Doom has a chance is if he knows a fight is about to go down and he sets some type of trap.
394079, i really fuckin hate Magneto
Posted by Calico, Mon Aug-11-08 08:48 PM
not the concept, or even the earlier stories, but since the "X-Men" title was launched in the 90's he's become this uber powerful almost unstoppable force..in fact, half the time i wonder how the X-Men EVER beat the guy, cause no matter how you come at him, "technically" there's some bullshit defense for it.....most of the recent stories that involve him are wack, and that just helps to make the character MORE annoying...and this fool isn't even an Omega level mutant...anyway....i think Doom could beat him, but he'd have to have a device that shut off or nullified maggie's powers...
394080, Everyone's focused on what kind of suit Doom would have on
Posted by Melanism, Mon Aug-11-08 08:55 PM
Mag would grab every piece of metal around him and squeeze the shit out of him.

Doom can't a guy who's power is stretching his arms.
-------------------
"Fuck yo couch, nigga!" - Tom Cruise

http://melanism.com
http://preptimeposse.blogspot.com
http://myblogisanopenbook.blogspot.com
http://www.myspace.com/melanism
http://www.last.fm/user/Melanism/
394257, FOH we all know Reed Richards aint rolling solo
Posted by ShinobiShaw, Tue Aug-12-08 01:14 PM

<------ Boho Model Madness Presents: Dimepiece

http://www.rareformnyc.com
http://www.myspace.com/shinobishaw
http://www.myspace.com/djshinobishaw
http://www.last.fm/user/ShinoShaw
394086, Doom...he's like tony stark + dr strange
Posted by kayru99, Mon Aug-11-08 09:34 PM
and he really should wipe the floor with the Fantastic Four on a regular basis
394142, not even
Posted by McDeezNuts, Tue Aug-12-08 07:53 AM
Dr. Strange is "sorcerer supreme."

While Dr. Doom does know magic, he is probably best described as a dabbler rather than a sorcerer or supreme anything.

So Dr. Doom is most definitely not Iron Man + Dr. Strange.


By the way, Magneto would easily destroy Iron Man, and it would be one of his most lopsided vistories. Unless Iron Man has prep-time, creates a plastic suit, and renames himself Polymer Man.
394372, doom regularly went to hell to get his momma's soul back
Posted by kayru99, Tue Aug-12-08 05:57 PM
among other things
that's a lil more than dabbling

magneto's power is all based on physics. Magic + high level tech trumps physics.

Which leads to an interesting question:

How do you rank comic powers?

I see'em like this:

Cosmic>>
Magic>>>>>>>>>>>
Physical>
Tech

Except in rare cases like molecule man or dr light or starks
394377, how exactly would Doom use his supernatural mommy hunting powers
Posted by buckshot defunct, Tue Aug-12-08 06:16 PM
To defeat the Master of Magnetism
394380, send magneto's metallic bending ass
Posted by kayru99, Tue Aug-12-08 06:26 PM
to hell.

Or send some freaky plastic nazi demon after his ass.
Or just trap his soul in some freaky dimension.

Magnetism can't do much against one of those magical-type dudes. Theoretically, he could fuck up magneto on some astral plane type shit.

Shit, he could just use a time machine on that ass, go back and get some magic lessons and pussy from morgan le fey, then show up in 30's poland and murk lil erik lensherr.

Dude got a machine that jacked the powers from the silver surfer and put them in his own body. I think he should be able to reasonably kick the shit outta most marvel characters

Just cuz a character is poorly written don't make him a bad character

394405, you're talking some serious prep time
Posted by McDeezNuts, Tue Aug-12-08 07:44 PM
>RE: send magneto's metallic bending assto hell.

If this is in his power, why hasn't he done this to the FF everytime they get in his way?
{Or did he try it and Reed outsmarted him? Sounds familiar but I can't remember}

Still, he can't just send people to hell on a whim.


>Or send some freaky plastic nazi demon after his ass.

WTF?

>Or just trap his soul in some freaky dimension.

Again, has he ever done this to someone? You're talking about some epic level magic shit. Doom has been to hell, but sending other people there without prep or trapping souls? Nope.



>Magnetism can't do much against one of those magical-type
>dudes. Theoretically, he could fuck up magneto on some astral
>plane type shit.

But he's not one of those astral plane type dudes. Strange is; Doom is not. His magic is specialized and not very powerful in the whole scheme of things.


>Shit, he could just use a time machine on that ass, go back
>and get some magic lessons and pussy from morgan le fey, then
>show up in 30's poland and murk lil erik lensherr.

Again, lots of prep time required there.

And is this time machine made of plastic? If not, Magneto can just send pieces of it directly into Doom's heart - right through his plastic armor.


>Dude got a machine that jacked the powers from the silver
>surfer and put them in his own body. I think he should be
>able to reasonably kick the shit outta most marvel characters

With enough prep time to build shit. But that's a copout for any genius character with resources. Why hasn't Doom done this to infant versions of the FF?


>Just cuz a character is poorly written don't make him a bad
>character

But Doom hasn't shown the levels of magic you're talking about, and if it would be so eady to stomp out Magneto (one of the most powerful non-epic Marvel characters in existance), why hasn't he gotten rid of the FF permanently yet?
394089, Isn't Doom's armor and mask made of... y'know... um... metal?
Posted by Frank Longo, Mon Aug-11-08 09:57 PM
He'd be FUCKED.
394258, Doom is never "fucked" don't pretend to know the workings of Doom
Posted by ShinobiShaw, Tue Aug-12-08 01:15 PM
you knave

<------ Boho Model Madness Presents: Dimepiece

http://www.rareformnyc.com
http://www.myspace.com/shinobishaw
http://www.myspace.com/djshinobishaw
http://www.last.fm/user/ShinoShaw
394119, dr doom is a better villian name
Posted by B.WilkZ, Tue Aug-12-08 02:54 AM

--------------------------------

92.1 FM -- THE GOOD WORD //
Pittsburgh PA - Sat 7 to 9PM

www.thegoodwordradioshow.com
394260, Doom is pleased with your answer
Posted by ShinobiShaw, Tue Aug-12-08 01:16 PM

<------ Boho Model Madness Presents: Dimepiece

http://www.rareformnyc.com
http://www.myspace.com/shinobishaw
http://www.myspace.com/djshinobishaw
http://www.last.fm/user/ShinoShaw
394216, What about leather-armor-wearing-magic Doom?
Posted by Ashy_Mike, Tue Aug-12-08 11:54 AM
Mags would get stomped
394374, fighting where? In a rubber coliseum on Planet Nerf?
Posted by buckshot defunct, Tue Aug-12-08 06:11 PM
Face it y'all, Mags got this.
414155, LMAO
Posted by spades, Fri Nov-14-08 08:12 PM
414696, pure okp comedic genius at its best
Posted by forte, Mon Nov-17-08 03:07 PM
414723, LMAO @ Planet Nerf
Posted by dunk, Mon Nov-17-08 03:55 PM
414742, *cries*
Posted by Bridgetown, Mon Nov-17-08 04:34 PM
414242, leather ain't an insulator lol
Posted by Bruce Belafonte, Sat Nov-15-08 03:40 PM
394373, Blue.
Posted by Reed_Richards, Tue Aug-12-08 06:05 PM


414206, I would assume that at this point Doom is ready for Mags
Posted by The European Miracle, Sat Nov-15-08 10:41 AM
for the simple reason that they've fought before and Doom took the L. Doom can adapt to make sure that doesn't happen again, Mags is still Mags.

Of course, Doom IS, at heart, an idiot, so yeah...Mags.

Doom one of those smart/dumb dictators (c) Ghostface
414222, ?
Posted by Frank Longo, Sat Nov-15-08 01:20 PM

>Of course, Doom IS, at heart, an idiot, so yeah...Mags.
414455, reply 39, basically.
Posted by The European Miracle, Sun Nov-16-08 06:49 PM
414457, That was meant as a joke though
Posted by icecold21, Sun Nov-16-08 07:05 PM
414562, But it's true.
Posted by The European Miracle, Mon Nov-17-08 10:23 AM
It's like local rappers that have an album title, a cover, wardrobe, all types of shit before they actually record a single fucking song. One of those dudes always talking about they're about to go into or just came from "the studio".

I swear Doom starts planning the "I killed Richards" parade as the FIRST part of any diabolical scheme he concocts, and blows most of his creative energy too early. When it comes to the actual killing Richards part, he fizzles out.
414254, Doom. Magneto, always loses because he makes premature...
Posted by JRennolds, Sat Nov-15-08 05:07 PM
...victory speeches! He has had the XMEN, on the brink but couldn't shut his yapper. And Doom, has PREP TIME!
414353, Ha. Doom is the king of victory speeches
Posted by Melanism, Sun Nov-16-08 09:19 AM
Shit, they've had whole issues of Doom monologing
414419, Magneto, nigga! The greatest (mutant) of all times!
Posted by Poisonous Dart, Sun Nov-16-08 04:42 PM
*breaks mic stand in half, throws it down and walks off*

Even with a premeditated, well thought out attack and supreme preparation he might be to take down Magnus for a while but in the end Magneto will find a way to win.

If Reed Richards can find a way to beat him through pure science and tenacity then Magneto would surely end up the victor. I'd love to write a graphic novel where that actually jumped off, though.

One.
414501, Apolcalypse is .... The greatest (mutant) of all times!
Posted by Lil Rabies, Mon Nov-17-08 01:13 AM
Mags would win, but I loves me some Doom. I can understand the question though. Both have transcended villain and are more like forces.
414541, coughcoughcoughWRONGcoughcough
Posted by Melanism, Mon Nov-17-08 09:09 AM
http://image.comicvine.com/uploads/item/41000/40752/78104-age-of-apocalypse_400.jpg
414536, Doom, because he's a Latvian Nazi.
Posted by isaaaa, Mon Nov-17-08 06:11 AM

http://cockygold.blogspot.com/ (updated daily)

Get 25% off www.karmaloop.com w/ rep code JR9103 at checkout!
414578, Magneto's super-powerful, AND super smart
Posted by BigReg, Mon Nov-17-08 11:21 AM
Doom may be go a bit harder in the planning department, but Magneto's no slouch.

Let em both have enough prep time, Doom would cook up some marvelous shit.

But Magneto wouldn't show up half assed either, and at the end of the day he's still one of the most powerful people on the planet AND knows how to push his powers to the limits.

Like, all it takes is someone to have some change in their pocket in a 100 mile radius, and Dooms dead, lol.


414597, RE: Magneto's super-powerful, AND super smart
Posted by Brother_Afron, Mon Nov-17-08 12:33 PM
My first instinct was to give it to Magneto, because like you said, if you ever had a filling he should be able to handle up on you, but then I remembered that Wolverine stays getting shots off on him. If A stupid midget with a hundred pounds worth of metal can do it, then surely Doom has a chance.
414703, ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Posted by isaaaa, Mon Nov-17-08 03:24 PM

http://cockygold.blogspot.com/ (updated daily)

Get 25% off www.karmaloop.com w/ rep code JR9103 at checkout!
414634, The super mutherfuckin villain goddammit!
Posted by Big Chief Rumbletummy, Mon Nov-17-08 01:50 PM

*

DOOM would first demagnetize a dime (like a rhyme) and he'd get jet black head-to-toe & then battle Magneto for bottles of mo' or 'dro! DOOM'S fly flow take practice like Tae Bo with Billy Blanks you guys...there's really no fuckin with him.

I bet Magneto can't even rhyme good.
414766, ^^^ BCS LEVEL HYPOTHETICALS ^^^
Posted by Torez the Judge, Mon Nov-17-08 05:45 PM
why i stopped fooling with comic book super battles...