both are pretty...both are talented...but, one is severely overrated and one is blatantly underrated.

the overrated one can't open a movie for shit and has never broken 40 mill without a big name male lead. the underrated one has...hmmmmmmm. edge: underrated chick

overrated let herself go and won an oscar. so did underrated. edge: even

overrated one looks every bit her age. underrated one looks younger than the overrated one. edge: underrated.

underrated has broken 100 mill 6 times. overrated one...just did it for the second time. edge: underrated.

underrated one can't keep a man. overrated one cuckolds a third tier actor, because she know he ain't going nowhere. edge: even

catwoman vs. aeon flux? let's go to the numbers....okay. edge: underrated.

debut film...jungle fever vs. children of the corn iii (uncredited at that)...edge: underrated

so, as you can see...halle better and more attractive and make better choices.