Go back to previous topic |
Forum name | Pass The Popcorn |
Topic subject | ok, fun post idea for the movie buffs.... best movie score? |
Topic URL | http://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=6&topic_id=366287 |
366287, ok, fun post idea for the movie buffs.... best movie score? Posted by BarTek, Wed Apr-23-08 09:07 PM
okay, for me, it's a tie between Braveheart and Last of the Mohicans... Can anything really top these beautiful compositions?
@}-,-`-
... everyone wants to be a rebel, but no one wants to be a revolutionary...
|
366293, Bernard Herrman - Psycho Posted by Nukkapedia, Wed Apr-23-08 09:29 PM
considering the score is not technically original, does Sleeping Beauty count?
|
366305, check out The Mission Posted by rdhull, Wed Apr-23-08 10:23 PM
|
366306, not the best, but i LOVED greenwood on There Will Be Blood Posted by bshelly, Wed Apr-23-08 10:33 PM
As in, I thought it was amazing before I knew he did it.
oh, and pulp fiction too ;)
|
366310, I loved the Greenwood score too, but Posted by stravinskian, Wed Apr-23-08 10:53 PM
strangely enough, the best section of it was actually someone else's music. A piece called "Fratres," by the minimalist composer Arvo Pärt, was used (if I remember correctly) shortly after the "gusher" scene. (I think it was when it became clear HW had lost his hearing.)
Of course, there's nothing wrong with using someone else's music. It was fully attributed in the credits. They also used an arrangement of the Brahms Violin concerto in the scene where the well was opened. But that was clearly incidental music, and could be interpreted as a part of the action of the scene. Fratres, on the other hand, was entirely in the background, and it sounded so much like Greenwood's music that someone who hadn't heard Fratres wouldn't have noticed the difference. I guess it was probably an homage, from Greenwood to Pärt, who's probably been a strong influence. Does anyone know if Greenwood has ever been interviewed about the score? I'm curious.
|
366328, That score *was* amazing.... it adds so much to the film.. Posted by BarTek, Wed Apr-23-08 11:50 PM
i honestly thought the film was brilliant.. the music fantastic.
@}-,-`-
... everyone wants to be a rebel, but no one wants to be a revolutionary...
|
366330, then full credit. Posted by bshelly, Wed Apr-23-08 11:57 PM
like i said, i loved it regardless of who did what
|
374210, Shit, no. Posted by McDeezNuts, Tue May-27-08 02:30 PM
It was one of the worst scores in recent memory, IMO. It was so jarring that it totally took me out of the movie.
I honestly turned the sound WAY DOWN on the fucking thing and put on subtitles until the dumb shit would quiet down.
|
366315, Here's a story about movie scores: Posted by stravinskian, Wed Apr-23-08 11:11 PM
Orson Welles and Igor Stravinsky (my namesake) were mutual admirers. At one point, Welles talked Stravinsky into writing a score for one of his movies (I think it would have been Ambersons, but I'm really not sure, I think it was near that timeframe).
Welles went to his producer to get permission to hire him (this was after Kane, so Welles needed permission for these sorts of things). Welles explained the situation, the producer replied "Stravinsky, yes, I think I've heard of him. How much money is he asking for?"
Welles responds "twenty thousand dollars."
The producer, shocked, replies "Twenty thousand?! For just five thousand more we could get Max Steiner!"
So I don't know who they went with.
|
368189, Bernard Herrmann did that one Posted by MothershipConnection, Fri May-02-08 02:37 AM
He did both Citizen Kane and The Magnificent Amberson with Orson as well as all the stuff he did with Hitchcock obviously. Pretty much anything he or Max Steiner did was great though.
|
366320, Ascenseur pour l'échafaud Posted by stravinskian, Wed Apr-23-08 11:23 PM
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0051378/fullcredits
I also have a strong personal affinity for the music in Barry Lyndon. I don't think any of it's original, though, so maybe it doesn't count. But Kubrick and his compatriots had a real talent for going out and finding music that's absolutely perfect, and I think Barry Lyndon is the best example of that (that or maybe 2001 or EWS).
|
366321, Back to the Future, Indiana Jones, Jurassic Park, Remo Williams Posted by Frank Longo, Wed Apr-23-08 11:24 PM
Just to throw some action flick scores in here.
|
366379, shit, didn't see Jurassic Park in your list before I wrote it Posted by MadDagoNH, Thu Apr-24-08 09:24 AM
I still really, really love that main theme. It really fit that first movie so well.
------------------------------------------------------------------ 2006-07 Zeno Memorial Cup winner: Chara SMASH
Dark grin, he can't help when he's happy, looks insane...
|
366336, I really like The Fountains score Posted by calij81, Thu Apr-24-08 12:28 AM
I would also agree with Last of the Mohican's. From what I remember, Master and Commander was good as well but it has been a while since i saw that movie.
|
366341, Me too Posted by jigga, Thu Apr-24-08 12:54 AM
|
366344, Yeah that score is great Posted by calij81, Thu Apr-24-08 01:01 AM
I really like how it goes so well with the ending of the movie. Just a powerful score to go with some great images and colors.
|
366347, The score & effects really carry the movie Posted by jigga, Thu Apr-24-08 01:07 AM
>I really like how it goes so well with the ending of the >movie. Just a powerful score to go with some great images and >colors.
Yeah that crescendo towards the end is tremendous. Especially when the flowers start coming out of his mouth & through his body.
|
366345, 25 Hour,Batman Begins,The Assassanation of Jesse James,Hulk Posted by jigga, Thu Apr-24-08 01:02 AM
Before the Devil Knows You're Dead Fargo Memento The Prestige The Proposition The New World The 3 Burials of Melquiades Estrada A Scanner Darkly Reqiuem for a Dream American Gangster
|
366352, def co-sign The Assassination of Jesse James Posted by LA2Philly, Thu Apr-24-08 01:27 AM
It's the one score in my recent memory that stuck out as amazing.
|
366353, check The Proposition Posted by DrNO, Thu Apr-24-08 01:42 AM
if you haven't already. Also the band The Dirty Three.
|
366375, Nick Cave Posted by Deebot, Thu Apr-24-08 08:47 AM
|
366447, It's hard to pick which score I like better between Prop & JJ Posted by jigga, Thu Apr-24-08 03:35 PM
They both fit the mood of the movies to perfection.
|
366436, I gotta add Inside Man as well. I love Terrance Blanchard. Posted by jigga, Thu Apr-24-08 02:43 PM
I really love those violins in that last scene with Jodie Foster & Christopher Plummer. I dont think I even noticed them the 1st time I saw it but ever since then its been 1 of the moments I really look forwad to in that movie. Subtle but sweet.
I was supposed to see Terrance Blanchard play at the Jazz Alley here in Seattle last summer but I missed out on it. I hope he comes back here again sometime soon.
|
366349, Off the top, Once Upon a Time in the West and Man With the Golden Arm Posted by mrhood75, Thu Apr-24-08 01:17 AM
|
366351, The Thin Red Line (Malick remake) Posted by calij81, Thu Apr-24-08 01:20 AM
Once again it has been about eight months since I last saw this and I remember liking the score and thought it enhanced the movie.
Nothing is better than a good/great score or soundtrack to a movie, especially if the movie isn't very good.
|
366369, I'm not great with these, but Star Wars Posted by MadDagoNH, Thu Apr-24-08 07:48 AM
I don't have any kind of great ear for classical compositions...I'm not sure if John Williams is considered hacky, but I love his big movie scores. The Star Wars movies, Indiana Jones and Jurassic Park especially. When I was like a kinda band geek in junior high, the two songs I loved playing were the Jurassic Park theme, and the Magnificent Seven theme...which is another one I love.
And a big co-sign on 25th Hour as well.
------------------------------------------------------------------ 2006-07 Zeno Memorial Cup winner: Chara SMASH
Dark grin, he can't help when he's happy, looks insane...
|
368702, Star Wars Posted by Liam, Sun May-04-08 12:50 AM
definitely, the Star Wars themes are classic (anything by John Williams for that matter)
|
366370, My favorite...American Beauty Posted by Mageddon, Thu Apr-24-08 07:59 AM
'Arose' being my favorite track.
|
367263, It, like the film, is unjustly shit upon around here Posted by ZooTown74, Mon Apr-28-08 07:45 PM
and I'm about goddamn fuckin sick of it
Er, I mean, cosign ________________________________________________________________________ I'm so happy Doin' the neutron dance I'm just burnin' Doin' the neutron dance Woo hoo
|
368134, Um glad I missed that post... one of my favorite movies, and it Posted by kysersozey, Thu May-01-08 09:05 PM
certainly earned the oscar.
|
368276, The movie sucked, get over it. Posted by Orbit_Established, Fri May-02-08 10:27 AM
The plastic bag scene = the worse scene of the past 15 years, easily
just shush
----------------------------
O_E: Your Super-Ego's Favorite Poster.
"I ORBITs the solar system, listenin..."
(C)Keith Murray, "Cosmic Slop"
|
368587, k Posted by ZooTown74, Sat May-03-08 12:38 PM
________________________________________________________________________ Oh my God She's so hot She's so flippin' hot She's like a curry I wanna tell her how hot she is But she'll think I'm being sexist She's so hot, she's makin' me sexist B*tch
- Bret McKenzie
|
366405, Ghost Dog Posted by guru0509, Thu Apr-24-08 12:32 PM
and thats not the hiphop head in me talking
RZA really laced that movie well..even better than Kill Bill ------------ Prodigy - H.N.I.C. 2 9th Wonder & Buckshot - The Formula
|
366416, Stand and Deliver...lol Posted by El_Pistolero, Thu Apr-24-08 01:22 PM
That cheesy 80's stuff kills me evrytime!
|
366424, RE: ok, fun post idea for the movie buffs.... best movie score? Posted by Starkey Loves Girl, Thu Apr-24-08 01:40 PM
Virgin Suicides......
|
366444, A Beautiful Mind Posted by jomac, Thu Apr-24-08 03:20 PM
|
367066, RE: ok, fun post idea for the movie buffs.... best movie score? Posted by JMD, Sun Apr-27-08 07:59 PM
E.T. I dont care what anyone says, you cant deny the scene when the riding the bikes and they take off in flight. That made my childhood.
|
367125, Batman- Danny Elfman Posted by disco dj, Mon Apr-28-08 07:51 AM
.
|
367174, traffic - cliff martinez Posted by triplebogey, Mon Apr-28-08 11:37 AM
|
367374, actually, his solaris score is far superior Posted by ZioN, Tue Apr-29-08 03:29 AM
i'm writing my thesis on it this year
|
367187, Syriana Posted by jigga, Mon Apr-28-08 12:27 PM
|
367261, North by Northwest, Lawrence of Arabia, Spartacus, Blade Runner Posted by ZooTown74, Mon Apr-28-08 07:44 PM
Magnolia (yeah, I said it, go cry)
E.T. (see Magnolia)
Those are off the top of the head
Also, I'm pretty partial to any film score that has a piece titled, "Overture," meaning the film also has an overture, which is almost always dope ________________________________________________________________________ I'm so happy Doin' the neutron dance I'm just burnin' Doin' the neutron dance Woo hoo
|
367283, Juliet of the Spirits Posted by natural, Mon Apr-28-08 09:11 PM
"Quienes argumentan que el arte no debe propagar doctrinas, se refieren a doctrinas contrarias a las suyas" - Jorge Luis Borges
|
367376, neil young's score for 'dead man' was pretty damn awesome Posted by ZioN, Tue Apr-29-08 03:31 AM
it MADE that movie in such a big way
|
367932, i'm a big enncio morricone fan but Posted by lfresh, Thu May-01-08 06:54 AM
robert rodriguez has been doing a good job ~~~~ When you are born, you cry, and the world rejoices. Live so that when you die, you rejoice, and the world cries. ~~~~
http://unodostres.etsy.com
http://playvicious.com/
|
368206, RE: i'm a big enncio morricone fan but Posted by ZioN, Fri May-02-08 07:33 AM
>robert rodriguez has been doing a good job
hell yeah!
he is so underrated as a composer. his score for planet terror was really great. and his work on sin city and once upon a time in mexico were excellent too.
he's a great example of a director working within a specific genre, and creating music that really references the history of that genre's music while still being innovative and really powerful. the fact the guy writes, shoots, directs, edits and scores his own films means he is nothing but a freak. so impressive
|
368126, Schindler's List Posted by JCass, Thu May-01-08 08:32 PM
Is the first to come to mind
|
368128, K-Pax Posted by xbenzive, Thu May-01-08 08:35 PM
It fits the movie very well, Edward Shearmur did great!
< Buddha's Eight-fold Path by Utagawa Kunisada II
|
368137, Magnolia. Posted by WhiteNotion, Thu May-01-08 09:08 PM
http://shaunbockert.muxtape.com http://www.audioscrobbler.com/user/whitenotion/
|
368185, Who did the score? Posted by BlakGirlSoul, Fri May-02-08 01:03 AM
************************************** <--- I love ya man http://blackgirlsdontdate.blogspot.com Black Girls Don't Date - Coming soon! ***************************************
|
368190, Jon Brion Posted by MothershipConnection, Fri May-02-08 02:38 AM
Of Kanye West fame. Also did I Heart Huckabees, Punch Drunk Love among others.
|
368508, it's funny to hear "of kanye west fame". Posted by WhiteNotion, Fri May-02-08 09:59 PM
it might be true, as kanye is probably his most high-profile project, but as an old-school brion fan, it's still funny to hear it.
http://shaunbockert.muxtape.com http://www.audioscrobbler.com/user/whitenotion/
|
368586, It's what most people on this site would probably remember Posted by MothershipConnection, Sat May-03-08 12:35 PM
But yea, I am a huge fan of everything he's done, from soundtracks to his production of other bands and his solo stuff. Very versatile and gifted musician.
|
368755, i agree with everything you just said. Posted by WhiteNotion, Sun May-04-08 01:37 PM
http://shaunbockert.muxtape.com http://www.audioscrobbler.com/user/whitenotion/
|
368179, Romeo is Bleeding Posted by jigga, Fri May-02-08 12:25 AM
|
368192, The Birds Posted by MothershipConnection, Fri May-02-08 02:44 AM
Okay, maybe not the best, but for nothing but electronic noise, it sure gets the job done.
Also does not help that I personally hate birds.
Out of the classics, I really liked the score to the original King Kong (Max Steiner) and Once Upon a Time in the West (Morricone).
|
368268, Was going to say Psycho Posted by Key, Fri May-02-08 10:16 AM
Bernard Herrmann who also did Taxi Driver
|
368275, Suspiria Posted by Key, Fri May-02-08 10:25 AM
The Goblins aka Dario Argento
I just love all those old keyboards.
|
368670, C'mon Posted by Arch Stanton, Sat May-03-08 09:15 PM
Nobody said Godfather yet? Nights of Cabiria had a good one. Both done by Nino Rota, who apparently did most (all?) of Fellini's stuff.
Also, Terminator: Boom-Boom, Boom, Boom-Boom. So simple, yet so great.
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon and Hero (especially the first fight scene) both had pretty amazing scores too.
Fuck it, Los Lobos did an excellent job on Desperado (and I don't even like that movie).
|
368691, Post Jack: What's your favorite Jon Brion soundtrack? Posted by rorschach, Sat May-03-08 11:33 PM
I can't really decide because they're all good. And there are some gems on each of them. --------------------------------------- The OKP® King of the Late Pass™
http://www.centsports.com/?opcode=33245 ^^^Free Gambling w/Ad Money....It Works :)^^^
"Being the bigger man is overrated." -- Huey (The Boondocks)
|