Go back to previous topic |
Forum name | Pass The Popcorn |
Topic subject | am i the only one that thinks 'scarface' is a bad movie? |
Topic URL | http://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=6&topic_id=324949 |
324949, am i the only one that thinks 'scarface' is a bad movie? Posted by al_sharp, Tue Oct-23-07 01:37 PM
i mean really bad.
like bad b-movie bad.
the shit is like a steven seagal movie starring al pacino.
some shit you'd see at like 2 in the afternoon on channel 9 on a saturday.
ugh.
www.theyesyesyalls.com www.myspace.com/shamelessplug www.myspace.com/theyesyesyalls www.myspace.com/dumhi www.myspace.com/phamelessslug
|
324953, everyone knows that it is a HORRIBLE movie Posted by Iltigo, Tue Oct-23-07 01:39 PM
it is universally accepted as a bad movie, and it tanked in the theaters.
it is a cult classic,
|
324997, that's the thing though... everyone doesn't Posted by Mynoriti, Tue Oct-23-07 02:54 PM
to the point that they'll drop $2500 on this:
http://us.st11.yimg.com/us.st.yimg.com/I/abasleathers_1971_44381641
http://www.abasleatherjackets.com/sclalejawirh.html
|
325078, tell the truth, u've seen at least one of those jackets at a Raider game Posted by Bombastic, Tue Oct-23-07 05:45 PM
>to the point that they'll drop $2500 on this: > >http://us.st11.yimg.com/us.st.yimg.com/I/abasleathers_1971_44381641 > >http://www.abasleatherjackets.com/sclalejawirh.html
|
325081, lol Posted by Mynoriti, Tue Oct-23-07 05:51 PM
|
324969, yeah it's bad Posted by BigWorm, Tue Oct-23-07 02:09 PM
The original wasn't that good either.
I don't know, if I had known more about it beforehand, I would have just watched it for the intentional or unintentional camp value.
I took it seriously, which made it godawful.
But I mean, an Italian guy from New York playing a Puerto Rican drug lord in Florida...that's kinda funny.
|
324972, He was Cuban actually Posted by Starbaby Jones, Tue Oct-23-07 02:12 PM
and I still get looks of surprise when people find out I'm Cuban because I don't talk like that.
|
325010, Wudda'ju talggin'bout main? Posted by MANHOODLUM, Tue Oct-23-07 03:17 PM
Ju don'talg like thah?
|
325025, i'm more disturbed by the sight of Robert Loggia in brownface. Posted by Orfeo_Negro, Tue Oct-23-07 03:39 PM
|
325038, Exactly! Posted by WarriorPoet415, Tue Oct-23-07 03:55 PM
______________________________________________________________________________
http://cscpov.blogspot.com/
"There's a fine line between persistence and foolishness..." -unknown
"To Each His Reach" -George Clinton
|
324975, the movies a cult classic Posted by walihorse, Tue Oct-23-07 02:21 PM
i enjoy it every time i see it
|
324976, i liked it Posted by budz4zo, Tue Oct-23-07 02:22 PM
nm
|
324981, It's SO over-the-top and a lot of folks think it's a so realistic... Posted by bigkarma, Tue Oct-23-07 02:29 PM
that frustrates me.
<-------littlekarma http://www.imagestation.com/album/pictures.html?id=2102430494 A hare, meeting a lioness one day, said, "I always have a great number of children while you have only one." The lioness replied, "That is true, but my one child is a lion.
|
324982, RE: am i the only one that thinks 'scarface' is a bad movie? Posted by John Sparks, Tue Oct-23-07 02:33 PM
Wow, I just had this converstaion today. We were talking about classic films and a bunch of people said SCARFACE. I had to set them straight and tell them that when it came out it was panned by the critics and considered a flop. The acting is horrible and Pacino's accent is ridiculous!!! One person had the nerve to say it was an epic story in the same mold as the GODFATHER . . . WTF?????
www.myspace.com/sublimenoize
|
324987, it's not that bad.... Posted by The Rapture7, Tue Oct-23-07 02:37 PM
it's schlocky, it's over the top, it's laughably unbelieveable, but it's fairly entertaining....I'm nowhere near as much of a Scarface fan as most of the rest of our generation, but the excellence of it's excesses make it at least understandable as a cult classic...and I say this with it being easily one of my least favorite Pacino flicks...
|
324992, ^^^This is it Posted by Marauder21, Tue Oct-23-07 02:48 PM
|
324988, i like a some B movies though. but it *is* over-rated. Posted by DawgEatah, Tue Oct-23-07 02:40 PM
http://fuck-your.blogspot.com http://www.myspace.com/insightclopediabrown http://www.myspace.com/dumhi http://www.youtube.com/group/okayplayer http://www.last.fm/user/DawgEatah R.I.P. 3rd i
|
324991, So what that make you? Good? Posted by 40thStreetBlack, Tue Oct-23-07 02:47 PM
You're not good.
|
325167, So say goodnight to the bad guy! Posted by Smetana, Tue Oct-23-07 09:41 PM
nm
|
325169, Here pelican pelican pelican... Posted by Smetana, Tue Oct-23-07 09:48 PM
nm
|
325363, that pelican shit always cracks me up Posted by 40thStreetBlack, Wed Oct-24-07 12:23 PM
|
325425, fly pelican fly Posted by ThaAnthology, Wed Oct-24-07 02:39 PM
fuck all that "b movie" shit. When it comes on, people watch...isn't that a classic? I mean who watches Gone With The Wind on a reg? Exactly.
For art quality and craft, sure it's no Godfather. But for the pure esthetic of drugs, violence and a bad guy we love to root for... A+
|
324995, it's a great movie if you don't take it seriously Posted by Mynoriti, Tue Oct-23-07 02:49 PM
and just sit back and enjoy over the top 80s excess of guns, coke, violence, cash, and cheesy music..... good times.
but people who compare it to the godfather (and there are alot of them out there) are beyone retarded.
|
325108, pretty much Posted by sosa, Tue Oct-23-07 06:42 PM
and 2nd half is not as good. I remember playing the 1st half tape way more than the 2nd.
>and just sit back and enjoy over the top 80s excess of guns, >coke, violence, cash, and cheesy music..... good times. > >but people who compare it to the godfather (and there are alot >of them out there) are beyone retarded. > >
|
324996, i kept falling asleep on it Posted by SammyJankis, Tue Oct-23-07 02:50 PM
|
325009, yeah, it's a bad movie, but it's a trashy bad movie that many Posted by Nukkapedia, Tue Oct-23-07 03:15 PM
(not me) find entertaining
|
325012, Bad performance..looks like Pacino mocking Vinnie Barbarino Posted by MANHOODLUM, Tue Oct-23-07 03:18 PM
like in a funny way, like he was at a house party, and everyone's drunk, and Al is like "Watch me do Travolta in that Kotter show!"
|
325226, lol Posted by al_sharp, Wed Oct-24-07 01:04 AM
www.theyesyesyalls.com www.myspace.com/shamelessplug www.myspace.com/theyesyesyalls www.myspace.com/dumhi www.myspace.com/phamelessslug
|
325013, I thought a couple scenes were classic, IMO Posted by MANHOODLUM, Tue Oct-23-07 03:20 PM
The assiassination scene was dope "LiberTAAAAAAAAAAAAAD", and when they went to the hotel. That Columbian chick with the gun under the pillow was tough as hell. Your boy coming up behind him on the stairs and grabbing his hair was the shit.
|
325033, but 'Push It To The Limit' is a great song!!! Posted by Orfeo_Negro, Tue Oct-23-07 03:50 PM
i never get tired of hearing it!!!!!!!
|
325045, limiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit Posted by Mynoriti, Tue Oct-23-07 04:04 PM
i think south park used it in a montage once. that and the karate kid's "you're the best around".
|
325092, LMAO Posted by Orfeo_Negro, Tue Oct-23-07 06:09 PM
>that and the >karate kid's "you're the best around".
|
325227, that's the best movie montage song ever. Posted by al_sharp, Wed Oct-24-07 01:05 AM
ever.
www.theyesyesyalls.com www.myspace.com/shamelessplug www.myspace.com/theyesyesyalls www.myspace.com/dumhi www.myspace.com/phamelessslug
|
325274, i dunno. "You're The Best" from Karate Kid might win by a hair. Posted by DawgEatah, Wed Oct-24-07 08:22 AM
|
325357, wrongo on both counts Posted by buckshot defunct, Wed Oct-24-07 12:15 PM
I submit to you: The Rocky IV Training Montage
http://youtube.com/watch?v=Ns6p_8wGPXY
|
325649, my list... Posted by tappenzee, Thu Oct-25-07 06:10 AM
1. Rocky ("Getting strong nowwwwww... won't be long nowwwwww") 2. Karate Kid ("You're the best...around") 3. Rocky II (Survivor - Eye of the Tiger) 4. Rocky IV ("There's no easy way out/There's no shortcut hooooome") 5. Over the Top ("Winner takes it all, loser takes a fall, fight to make it over the top") 6. Revenge of the Nerds (when they're cleaning up the Frat house) 7. Team America: World Police (this movie kinda sucked, but this part was funny) 8. Naked Gun ("Something tells me I'm in for something good") 9. Scarface ("Take it to the limit... LIMIIIIIIIT!")
|
325634, that's the one i was talkin about. Posted by al_sharp, Thu Oct-25-07 02:28 AM
www.theyesyesyalls.com www.myspace.com/shamelessplug www.myspace.com/theyesyesyalls www.myspace.com/dumhi www.myspace.com/phamelessslug
|
325784, you KNOW i agree Posted by Mynoriti, Thu Oct-25-07 02:31 PM
kid takes out half of Cobra Kai in one song! http://youtube.com/watch?v=n5TSCwMbsPY
|
325047, For what it is, it's great. But not great by conventional standards. Posted by Frank Longo, Tue Oct-23-07 04:10 PM
It's an exercise in excess, excessive violence, big flashy cinematography, larger-than-life character acting.
I doubt that would have been as good a movie if they'd tried to make it conventionally great. Playing to the excessive style is what has made it last.
|
325063, SAY GOO-NIGH TO MY LILLL FRIEN... CHOOT THAT PIECE OF CHIT* Posted by ZooTown74, Tue Oct-23-07 05:12 PM
That's all I got
*yes, those lines were misquoted intentionally ______________________________________________________________________ I have no remorse So check me out in The Source
|
325064, Miami WAS popping off like that in the 80's tho. Posted by Madvillain 626, Tue Oct-23-07 05:15 PM
Dudes WAS gettin clapped in the streets.
|
325553, Cocaine Cowboys Posted by Mynoriti, Wed Oct-24-07 08:58 PM
makes you think maybe Scarface didn't have ENOUGH violence.
|
325556, *adds to Netflix que* Posted by ZooTown74, Wed Oct-24-07 09:24 PM
______________________________________________________________________ I have no remorse So check me out in The Source
|
325109, "people like scarface because...it's heartfelt." (c) Snoop. Posted by now or never, Tue Oct-23-07 06:45 PM
lmao @ how he says that on the dvd like he's talkin about "the fox and the hound" or some shit.
i'm just gon start slappin motherfuckers on sight.
|
325228, hahaha...word. Posted by al_sharp, Wed Oct-24-07 01:05 AM
www.theyesyesyalls.com www.myspace.com/shamelessplug www.myspace.com/theyesyesyalls www.myspace.com/dumhi www.myspace.com/phamelessslug
|
325349, RE: "people like scarface because...it's heartfelt." (c) Snoop. Posted by Calico, Wed Oct-24-07 11:54 AM
hah!
|
325110, Scarface is a bad movie, everyone who knows movies knows that Posted by Hitokiri, Tue Oct-23-07 06:50 PM
But it's great in it's horribleness. It's what Snakes on a Plane should've been. It's ridiculous, full of one-liners and bad accents.
It will say though, it's not as excessive as people here seem to think. I urge you all to go watch Cocaine Cowboys. Scarface seems over the top, but in a lot of ways, that's how Miami was in the 80s.
|
325112, its the reason for the phrase "awesomely bad" Posted by DubSpt, Tue Oct-23-07 06:57 PM
and if you ask me, that is still some kind of greatness.
and no matter what any of you say....... it is a mark of its generation. like it or not, its not going anywhere, and as we get further and further away from its original release more and more people will forget that it was a flop.
if you ask me, thats a great thing.
i mean, really, ask yourself how many so called great movies that you love also bombed at the box office and were critically trashed? does that mean any of those movies were actually that awful then and we've been brainwashed, or does it mean that it was a good movie that just didnt fare well?
basically, its all personal, and frankly, i am a little tired of the redundancy of the whole "well its great but its bad talk". if you think its great, just admit it, flaws and all. nothing's perfect.
but yeah, all the accents are awful and loggia gives one of the worst performances in cinema history. but maybe thats me.
|
325117, Less-beeyang (c) Manolo after being slapped by broad @ the pool Posted by The Rapture7, Tue Oct-23-07 07:37 PM
shitty Cuban accent translation: lesbian.
|
325144, 1983 version >>>>>>> 1932 version Posted by genius.switch, Tue Oct-23-07 09:08 PM
About two months ago, I did a complete 180 on my stance of that movie, and Pacino's performance within even.
While it might be unfair to hold Hawkes's work to modern standards, because of pressures from censors and the limitation of movies back then, Paul Muni and company themselves come of as one-dimensional and over-the-top and prove generally grating to watch. Sure, the on-screen depiction of violence still sparks--and must have been revolutionary at the time--but the story is told in a rather flimsy and uncompelling if not laughable manner that is simply not worthwhile for the audience. Maybe it was a true originator once and everyone simply copied for decades following, thus limiting its initial power, but it really seems now more of a parody of gangsters and gangster films. (However, something like Public Enemy still holds up relatively well today, so I'm not gonna give Hawkes that much of a pass.)
On the other hand, while De Palma's version--his most satisfying film--may also be dated in some areas, by its early 80's soundtrack and montages, and though the grip on its ending is not so air tight, its ever-quotable dialogue, appropriately operatic lead performance, horrifying violence, consistent suspense, and well-researched story hardly waste a minute of film.
I know it's rather easy to blame Tony for his influence, especially with as uninspiring and myopic as those copy-cats have been, but I say without hesitation that 1983's Scarface is the infinitely more entertaining and better made film.
Now I just have to see Sternberg's Underworld somehow.
|
325173, bad, bad, really really bad (c) MJ Posted by jambone, Tue Oct-23-07 09:55 PM
no run-dmc-o
however, its one of the best unintentional comedies in cinema.
the tragedy is that n*ggas actually value the so-called "lessons" from that movie. they actually "study" that movie and see it as an inspiration.
i will say this though, Oliver Stone wrote some great dialogue for the movie.
|
325229, that's what pisses me off the most... Posted by al_sharp, Wed Oct-24-07 01:07 AM
all these fuckin thugs thinkin the shit is like the holy grail.
i know way too many dumb muhfuckas like that.
www.theyesyesyalls.com www.myspace.com/shamelessplug www.myspace.com/theyesyesyalls www.myspace.com/dumhi www.myspace.com/phamelessslug
|
325174, One of the better movies made in the 80s imho Posted by Smetana, Tue Oct-23-07 09:58 PM
nm
|
325362, did u think it was bad as a kid tho??? Posted by My_SP1200_Broken_Again, Wed Oct-24-07 12:23 PM
...that was the SHIT when we were in like 9th grade
|
325635, i did tho...and everyone i hung out with LOVED it... Posted by al_sharp, Thu Oct-25-07 02:29 AM
i've ALWAYS thought that shit was bad.
www.theyesyesyalls.com www.myspace.com/shamelessplug www.myspace.com/theyesyesyalls www.myspace.com/dumhi www.myspace.com/phamelessslug
|
325386, So bad it's good in that over the top 80s sort of way Posted by JWBIII, Wed Oct-24-07 01:11 PM
I mean, the movie is absolutely ridiculous. But it is ridiculous enough to become a cult classic and work itself into pop culture.
The problem is that so many think of it a seriously incredible movie and seem to take life lessons and base their decision making skills on it. They actually take the movie seriously, and don't actually view it as campy and over the top. "Scarface" is maybe as campy as "The Warriors."
I blame "Scarface" for morons like TI.
|
325636, ha... Posted by al_sharp, Thu Oct-25-07 02:29 AM
>I blame "Scarface" for morons like TI.
word.
www.theyesyesyalls.com www.myspace.com/shamelessplug www.myspace.com/theyesyesyalls www.myspace.com/dumhi www.myspace.com/phamelessslug
|
325388, fantastic re-imagining of Shakespeare's Macbeth Posted by The Damaja, Wed Oct-24-07 01:12 PM
i really enjoyed it. i think a lot of the complaints about it being shallow/cheesy/overthetop are misdirected cause there's a strong sense of that superficiality being a major theme in the film. but watching it all the way through with Macbeth in mind, it made a lot of sense to me
|
325391, i have never heard this reasoning b4 Posted by Calico, Wed Oct-24-07 01:14 PM
but ok
|
325401, it does follow MacBeth, I'll give it that Posted by JWBIII, Wed Oct-24-07 01:42 PM
I actually thought about this before. "Scarface" does follow the general story and character progression as "MacBeth."
"MacBeth" is the action movie of Shakespeare's work.
|
325426, wait....... what? Posted by DubSpt, Wed Oct-24-07 02:47 PM
because he rises to power and then is killed in the end? i dont know man.
|
325438, well it's more than just that Posted by The Damaja, Wed Oct-24-07 03:18 PM
they both gain initial elevation through battlefield deeds then they get overambitious and bump off their superiors then get paranoid and fail to enjoy their status off their best friends think they're invincible before finally getting served by some other dudes from the old gang
i wouldn't say it's a 'rewriting' of macbeth, but a 'reimagining'. lots of stuff was changed by i could see WHY it was changed. like perhaps the most famous quality of Lady Macbeth was her childlessness, and that infertility theme is picked up by Scarface's girlfriend quite noticably. it used Macbeth as a base to go on and make new points about modern psychology (afterall Macbeth is celebrated for it's psychological accuracy... like Lady MacB getting obsessive compulsive disorder and stuff). while the shakespeare play had a veil of superstition over the whole thing, Macbeth has got a veil of liek... cocaine-driven numbness/superficiality
|
325637, hmmm. Posted by al_sharp, Thu Oct-25-07 02:30 AM
www.theyesyesyalls.com www.myspace.com/shamelessplug www.myspace.com/theyesyesyalls www.myspace.com/dumhi www.myspace.com/phamelessslug
|
325420, But its an 80's classic...... Posted by BlakGirlSoul, Wed Oct-24-07 02:31 PM
I didn't say it was good, but it is classic Reminds me when cable boxes had knobs you had to turn and Cinemax really showed porn HA! ************************************** <--- Master of Metrosexuality http://blackgirlsdontdate.blogspot.com Black Girls Don't Date - Coming soon! ***************************************
|
325585, its Valley Of The Dolls of crime flicks Posted by rdhull, Wed Oct-24-07 11:31 PM
but also is the movie nerds favorite punching bag... "now"
|
325631, Prepare to have this discussion on Belly in 15 years.. Posted by Coatesvillain, Thu Oct-25-07 02:11 AM
With the way I hear people talking about that movie, I have no doubt it'll be more revered the further we're away from it.
Regarding Scarface I liked the movie. I never took anything from it, and can't sit through the whole thing again.. But I liked it when I watched it.
|
325638, ha...word. Posted by al_sharp, Thu Oct-25-07 02:31 AM
www.theyesyesyalls.com www.myspace.com/shamelessplug www.myspace.com/theyesyesyalls www.myspace.com/dumhi www.myspace.com/phamelessslug
|
325701, I still hate Belly Posted by BlakGirlSoul, Thu Oct-25-07 10:29 AM
Hate that I lost $7.50 Hate that my b/f spent $7.00 for it at Walmart ************************************** <--- Master of Metrosexuality http://blackgirlsdontdate.blogspot.com Black Girls Don't Date - Coming soon! ***************************************
|
325743, can never sit through the dvd Posted by rjc27, Thu Oct-25-07 12:32 PM
if its on tv i end up watching it... but would never just throw it on, too long and waaay to overrated
|