Because people saw the movie at so many different times (when it first came out to when it got released on DVD all the way to the Oscars), dicsussion has been rather fractured. At the same time, it did become a definitive Reviews / PTP films so I think it needs *something*. I'd go with the first one because it actually came first, and then also 'cause it got the most replies. Discussion throughout may not be exactly sterling, but it's the clear favorite IMO.