Go back to previous topic
Forum namePass The Popcorn
Topic subjectIt's all a matter of preference. I can understand both sides.
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=6&topic_id=435060&mesg_id=435144
435144, It's all a matter of preference. I can understand both sides.
Posted by jigga, Thu Feb-19-09 06:54 PM
But I usually go this route. I've decided to read A Long Way Down & The Road before the movies just to test things out though.

>>Wouldn't the "oh shit" moments in the movie also be lost
>for
>>those that have already read the comic? I mean if you read
>the
>>book first then see the movie you know all the spoilers. And
>>vice versa right?
>
>I guess I'm saying, if you were to lose the drama of either
>version, I'd rather pick the movie.
>
>but seeing as you're pretty set on watching the movie, I'd
>recommend just waiting to read the comic. watch the movie
>first, possibly enjoy it, then be impressed when the comic is
>tons better. opposed to my predicament: be blown away by the
>comic, then go into the movie already waiting for it to fail
>me.

I mean I remember all the Watchmen talk before the movie was even announced & how it would never happen because it just wasn't possible to trim it down to a decent running time. But I was sold from the first trailer. I'm almost positive I'm better off seeing what the big screen has to offer first and then having the rest opened up to me in the novel. I'm pretty sure I'll get the same enjoyment when I get around to reading Let the Right One in as well. I liked the movie but had a ton of questions afterwards. It's good to know I can go to the book (or PTP) after the fact to get the answers.