Here's my new list:

1 - Phrenology - The Roots
2 - Stankonia - OutKast
3 - Like Water for Chocolate - Common
4 - The Private Press - DJ Shadow
5 - Game Theory - The Roots
6 - Joyful Rebellion - K-Os
7 - Graduation - Kanye West
8 - The Minstrel Show - Little Brother
9 - The Black Album - Jay Z
10 - Rising Down - The Roots
11 - American Gangster - Jay Z
12 - The Ownerz - Gangstarr
13 - Late Registration - Kanye West
14 - Fantastic, Vol 2 - Slum Village
15 - Act I: The Eternal Sunshine (The Pledge) - Jay Electronica
16 - Voodoo - D'Angelo
17 - The Ecstatic - Mos Def
18 - Train of Thought - Reflection Eternal
19 - King - T.I.
20 - Petestrumentals - Pete Rock
21 - Shades of Blue - Madlib
22 - Quality Control - Jurassic 5
23 - Electric Circus - Common
24 - Atlantis: Hymns for Disco - K-Os
25 - God's Son - Nas