Go back to previous topic
Forum nameThe Lesson
Topic subjectDid Frank Knuckles leave The Roots?
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=2991251
2991251, Did Frank Knuckles leave The Roots?
Posted by stimuland, Sun Jun-04-17 07:37 PM
He hasn't performed on the Tonight Show since March and was absent from The Roots Picnic yesterday. Is everything all right? Is he still in the band?
2991253, Kinda seems like it, but sometimes people take breaks
Posted by seandammit, Sun Jun-04-17 11:54 PM
Kamal was MIA for a few months if I remember correctly.

There have been some clues that Stro Elliot may be joining the band in some capacity beyond the past few festival performances, I have wondered if he is the replacement or not...

2991254, Check his Tiwtter
Posted by handle, Mon Jun-05-17 12:23 AM
https://twitter.com/FrankKnuckles/with_replies?lang=en

Looks like family related stuff.
2991351, He seems like a good dude I hope things get better for him
Posted by makaveli, Tue Jun-06-17 08:21 PM
2991387, I think there is more to the story
Posted by stimuland, Thu Jun-08-17 06:24 AM
He has been very active on social media lately and replies to most of his comments. Seems to be doing okay. However, he won’t mention or acknowledge ANYTHING related to The Roots or the Tonight Show…

I hope there wasn’t a falling out. I enjoyed his stage presence and thought he brought a lot of energy to The Roots' shows. But sadly it is beginning to look as if he is no longer with the band or is at least trying to distance himself from them.

If it's personal then I'll respect that. But it's still pretty newsworthy when someone leaves the band after 15 years...
2991391, this is just a guess
Posted by makaveli, Thu Jun-08-17 11:19 AM
but maybe he had some family issue he was dealing with, and it took him too long to come back? and eventually, they were like "alright dude, time to come back to work." idk. I'd say you are right that there's something else to it.
2991397, Stro Elliott is working The Tonight Show now...
Posted by ChampD1012, Thu Jun-08-17 01:53 PM
2991418, ?uestlove said that Stro Elliot is a member of The Roots now
Posted by ChampD1012, Thu Jun-08-17 08:11 PM
2991420, A band with Ex-roots members possible?
Posted by handle, Thu Jun-08-17 08:36 PM
Ala - "the Heads" without David Byrne?

Hell, maybe 2?

The Roo-Tees?
Malik B (lead voals)
Hub (Bass)
Ben Kenny (Guitar)
Keyboards (Scott Storch)
Rahzel (Beat box)


The Yoots?
Kid Crumbs (lead vocals)
Josh Abrams (bass)
Martin Luther (guitar)
Nikki Yeoh (keyboard)
Scratch (beat box)


And Owen will open for both with Mister Barrington - which will add Dice Raw as lead vocalist.
2991422, RE: They've been a working unit for thirty years now.
Posted by Austin, Thu Jun-08-17 10:02 PM
It's pretty common to have people come and go, especially when they've toured as much as they have and had as many vocalists as they have.


os·ti·na·to
/ˌästəˈnädō/
noun
a continually repeated musical phrase or rhythm

http://austinato.bandcamp.com

https://www.discogs.com/lists/Favorites-of-2017/332378
2992860, Damn, so I guess it’s official now:
Posted by stimuland, Tue Jul-04-17 09:57 PM
https://twitter.com/FrankKnuckles/status/882239386246676480

https://twitter.com/FrankKnuckles/status/882237521983352832

https://twitter.com/questlove/status/878153021041115136
2992861, Damn. Wonder what happened?
Posted by Nick Has a Problem...Seriously, Tue Jul-04-17 10:31 PM
Shit looks like it's about to get ugly
2992867, YIKES...I hope everything works out for both sides...
Posted by ChampD1012, Wed Jul-05-17 06:30 AM
easily could have been a contract dispute or something
2992895, Does seem kinda passive-aggressive from 15
Posted by dustin, Wed Jul-05-17 01:47 PM
But we don't know the full story.

Also Frank is replying to a tweet from june 23 but his screenshot says '12h ago' ... I wonder why the screenshot and his tweet (yesterday) are so far apart
2992900, only if you take the word from the source from which it came
Posted by 15, Wed Jul-05-17 02:32 PM
i have never ever ever ever done anyone shitty on the business side of things.

and if there was a dismissal?

you BEST believe there was a DAMN UNAVOIDABLE reason for it happening.

i wish him well in his endeavors

i wrote an extra paragraph.

but i erased it.

cause it's not worth it.
2992901, RE: only if you take the word from the source from which it came
Posted by dustin, Wed Jul-05-17 02:42 PM
I'm glad I added my "Gotta hear both sides" (c) tokpr disclaimer above lol. I know Frank and you have a deep history so I trust there's more to it. Thanks for shedding a lil light.

(He still lurks, y'all!!!)

2992919, 15 always lurks...he's the reason the boards aren't gone. LOL
Posted by ChampD1012, Thu Jul-06-17 05:38 AM
2992980, Yeah He's Lurking While Laughing
Posted by Dj Joey Joe, Thu Jul-06-17 09:44 PM
How many ex-members of The Roots is it now ten kats and counting, I'm surprised James G. aka Kamal is still around with the other James getting more shine than him these days.

It almost seem like how the whole Bad Boy producer camp is always changing and letting people go, and usually after they have done made a hit for diddy.


3026238, Not according to Jaguar Wright
Posted by stimuland, Thu Aug-06-20 08:18 PM
>i have never ever ever ever done anyone shitty on the
>business side of things.

who alleges Malik B. received a measly $200 per week up to his death and accuses you of cutting off Hub's health insurance when he was battling cancer...
3026240, The Hub issue I heard too
Posted by justin_scott, Thu Aug-06-20 11:22 PM
I don't care what Quest says, I believe they did Hub dirty and probably did Knuckles dirty too. and then there's Jaguar Wright and Flo Brown....hell, even the Jazzies got buried.
2994565, UPDATE: Frank Knuckles is suing The Roots
Posted by stimuland, Sat Aug-19-17 02:44 AM
http://www.nydailynews.com/entertainment/gossip/confidential/roots-sued-longtime-band-member-frank-knuckles-article-1.3420850