Go back to previous topic
Forum nameThe Lesson
Topic subjectWhat's the time signature for the Bryson Tiller - "Exchange" beat?
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=2969473
2969473, What's the time signature for the Bryson Tiller - "Exchange" beat?
Posted by TRENDone, Mon Jul-18-16 08:51 PM
the most exotic rhythm in mainstream R&B since Tweet - "Oops, Oh My"

Bryson: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aj9coPGuFkM
2969475, 4/4
Posted by howardlloyd, Mon Jul-18-16 09:56 PM
n/m
2969479, Lol
Posted by PimpTrickGangstaClik, Mon Jul-18-16 11:46 PM
2969480, What's exotic about this beat?
Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Tue Jul-19-16 12:19 AM
2969591, I was thrown off by the offbeat snare
Posted by TRENDone, Wed Jul-20-16 04:54 PM
As far as I'm concerned every beat on the radio sounds like DJ mustard or drunk in love. I'd love to hear someone try to do it live w/ a female singer, drums, and a moog or bass. Best R&B song in a minute but dude can't sing for shit smh.

Drake was doing these kinda beats like Rtistic said below
2969609, It's not off-beat tho lol... just on odd number counts. Rick Ross BMF
Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Wed Jul-20-16 11:59 PM
has the same snare hits as do hella
songs on the radio in the last few years.
2969666, thanks for the snarky lesson but
Posted by TRENDone, Thu Jul-21-16 09:17 PM
BMF and Exchange are not the same drum pattern. BMF is closer to my other example, Drunk in Love. please give me other examples of songs within the last 5 years with a rhythm/drum pattern close to bryson tiller's exchange...and i'm not just talking about a sped up 90s sample.

check out this cover where this doowop group does a medley of don't and exchange...notice they don't sing the verse of exchange? they had to switch it up...cuz it's different...even the way kevin gates raps on "2 phones" i can't articluate it, but it's exotic to me. i know it's been around, but it's mainstream now. Drake and Beiber using dancehall rhythms on their latest POP ALBUMS is a trip to me as well.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XjSpUQAk7O8
2969671, Wasn't snarking you at all.
Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Thu Jul-21-16 11:19 PM
>BMF and Exchange are not the same drum pattern.


I said the snares hit on the same count in both beats.
That's what you said was throwing you off.
Exchange is just slower.


>check out this cover where this doowop group does a medley of
>don't and exchange...notice they don't sing the verse of
>exchange? they had to switch it up...cuz it's
>different...
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XjSpUQAk7O8


I could tell you why that is, but you'll just
think I'm being snarky again, so nevermind.
Glad you're enjoying the music and finding it
fascinating.




2969893, I'm just being a lil sensitive...
Posted by TRENDone, Mon Jul-25-16 10:08 PM
but do you have any examples of beats in the last 5-7 years similar to the "exchange" beat?
2970007, RE: I'm just being a lil sensitive...
Posted by bearfield, Fri Jul-29-16 02:18 AM
>but do you have any examples of beats in the last 5-7 years
>similar to the "exchange" beat?

pusha t - "intro": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cCQ5wkzORQs

a little faster than "exchange" but around the same tempo

nas and/or dj khaled - "esco album done": http://www.audiomack.com/song/hiphop-lives-here/esco-album-done

i think this tempo (~80-95 bpm) with "trap" drum patterns (meaning one snare per measure hitting on the 3) is a fairly recent development and could be a gateway for older artists to get on more modern-sounding beats since the tempo is closer to what they used to rap over. they don't really have to change up their flow much, save for accounting for the "increased" space due to there being only one snare per measure instead of two. hopefully this leads to more experimentation with patterns by said older artists

not sure about the time signature. most likely 4/4 and littered with 8th and 16th notes that sound "slow" because of the tempo and snare pattern. maybe 8/8 where the snare hits on the 5? but that seems overly complex
2969559, re Tweet - "Oops, Oh My"
Posted by 2Future4U, Wed Jul-20-16 08:45 AM
belongs in that circle of Timbaland's drum and bass influenced production

Ugly
Get Your Freak On
etc

4/4 also
2969563, I think this might be 2/2 (cut time).
Posted by Teknontheou, Wed Jul-20-16 10:00 AM
His melody is very active with alot of notes, but there's still the strong beat on the 1 followed by three other beats. The slow tempo kind of throws that off.

The bass drum is syncopated and kicking on off beats, with an asymmetrical pattern, which is why you might have thought the meter was unconventional.
2969571, It's straight from Drake school of speeding up a sample and then
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Wed Jul-20-16 11:54 AM
cutting the beat in half, or even into a fourth.

"Shorty swing my way" is 140 BPM. "Exchange" is 40 BPM. Dude sped up "Shorty swing my way" up to 160 BPM, and drop drums that were basicaly 1/4th of that to make it 40 BPM.
2969590, Drake definitely the father to that style
Posted by TRENDone, Wed Jul-20-16 04:46 PM
Those snycopated trap beats.
2969592, The beat is 4/4
Posted by Anonymous, Wed Jul-20-16 05:07 PM
The tempo and when the drums hit have nothing to do with the time signature.

This beat simply only has a snare hit on either the 4 or the 8 depending on what tempo the track was created at.