Go back to previous topic
Forum nameThe Lesson
Topic subjectCan Eminem top Recovery?
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=2752191
2752191, Can Eminem top Recovery?
Posted by L0WD0WN, Sun Oct-28-12 08:31 PM
With the buzz machine already in motion via the release of Detroit Tigers themed Eminem hats displaying "Champion" and each year of his album releases including 2013, I'm wondering which direction Em will go this time around.

Now, I know OKP hated Recovery but by all accounts, it was a smash hit that was definitely regarded as his "comeback" that Relapse was supposed to be. Packed full of mainstream radio hits, the obvious intention was to make sure that Eminem was more accessible to the masses and relevant in today's more pop friendly hip hop environment. It also showed a sharp change in direction from his typical pop star bashing, tongue and cheek lyrics to a more mature, older, Eminem.

So with his new album slated to drop in Q1 2013, will he try to follow the same game plan that Recovery followed? If so, can he equal or top the success that it achieved? It's been rumoured that he intends on working mostly with Dre this time around. Being that he had always been the one that pushed him in the Slim Shady direction, will Eminem instead fall back to old tricks?

This could also quite possibly be his last album so that might influence what direction he chooses to go in and dictate what he wants to accomplish before hanging up the mic.

What do ya'll think he'll do this time?
2752200, Was Recovery a classic or something?
Posted by Starks dunked on Bulls, Sun Oct-28-12 09:10 PM
2752203, I hope so, it wasn't anything special
Posted by icecold21, Sun Oct-28-12 09:41 PM
Honestly, I don't care, I won't buy it either way.
2752207, It would be great if he at least equalled Relapse
Posted by Nodima, Sun Oct-28-12 09:58 PM
A lot of people, myself included, didn't realize how good we had it with that album until he shat on our chests with Recovery.


~~~~~~~~~
"This is the streets, and I am the trap." © Jay Bilas
"I don't read pages of rap lyrics, I listen to rap music." © Bombastic
http://www.popmatters.com/pm/archive/contributor/517
Hip Hop Handbook: http://tinyurl.com/ll4kzz
2752227, ^^^^^
Posted by Ketchums, Mon Oct-29-12 03:49 AM
I actually loved Relapse from the jump. Hated Recovery, though.
2752231, subject matter be damned...
Posted by xangeluvr, Mon Oct-29-12 06:08 AM
Em was rapping his ass off on Recovery.
2752221, Can ambiguity top a pile shit?
Posted by csuave03, Sun Oct-28-12 11:36 PM
I guess we can hope
2752228, Is he capable? Sure.
Posted by Ketchums, Mon Oct-29-12 03:57 AM
It's just a matter of seeing what he does. If he's primarily working with Dr. Dre, I'm happy to hear that; I loved Relapse, and that's the only Em album Dre produced from top to bottom. One of the big things that annoyed me about Recovery is that he brought in so many notable names on the production side, but it still didn't *sound* that much differently from his other material. Eminem and Dre is what I like to hear.

Relapse was a dope concept record, so it'd be dope to just see them go back to making a dope rap album. Great rhymes, great beats. I respected him for at least going outside of his usual comfort zone a bit on Recovery and Hell The Sequel, but he didn't really sound comfortable on those at all. I'd like to see him go back to what he's good at. I'd rather him just go back to the lab with Dre and do what the two of them are good at.

Eminem's sales are always going to be crazy, that's never a question. But we'll see if it does better than Recovery.
2752238, What?!
Posted by Brew, Mon Oct-29-12 07:04 AM
>One of the big things that annoyed me about Recovery is that
>he brought in so many notable names on the production side,
>but it still didn't *sound* that much differently from his
>other material.

Recovery sounded nothing like any of his past material IMO, and that was the problem with it. The beats all had heavy rock elements, Eminem was screaming like an asshole, and the emo themes were in full force. Awful album.


>Relapse was a dope concept record, so it'd be dope to just see
>them go back to making a dope rap album. Great rhymes, great
>beats. I respected him for at least going outside of his usual
>comfort zone a bit on Recovery and Hell The Sequel, but he
>didn't really sound comfortable on those at all. I'd like to
>see him go back to what he's good at. I'd rather him just go
>back to the lab with Dre and do what the two of them are good
>at.

Yea I'd like to see him go back to basics, too.
2752256, I think he'll probably make another Recovery.
Posted by dalecooper, Mon Oct-29-12 08:57 AM
Which is too bad, I'm firmly in the "Relapse was far, far better" camp.
2752257, Me too.
Posted by Brew, Mon Oct-29-12 09:00 AM
>Which is too bad, I'm firmly in the "Relapse was far, far
>better" camp.

Relapse wasn't great by any means but it certainly got a little bump in overall grade after Recovery dropped leaving its shit stain on the world. I came to appreciate the overall concept, lyricism and tone of the production way more.
2752258, all i ask is he stops yelling
Posted by Goose, Mon Oct-29-12 09:05 AM
and maybe quit the horrible punchlines.


Like why does the mainstream think that yelling voice is acceptable? its teh most grating thing ive ever heard.
2752259, Yea. Unlistenable.
Posted by Brew, Mon Oct-29-12 09:06 AM
Those beats were awful, too.
2752270, yup, accents>>>>>>>yellling
Posted by Bombastic, Mon Oct-29-12 10:48 AM
2752304, agreed
Posted by Goose, Mon Oct-29-12 11:51 AM
at first i was annoyed by the accents, but now i think they really add to the crazy psychopathic character was playing in Relapse.

There is nothing okay with his yelling.
2752455, Hell yeah. TOtally agree. Fuck a recovery.
Posted by Admbmb, Mon Oct-29-12 07:36 PM
I want the accents and drug using Eminem back. However, I would like an album with no dre or em production. Lets hear him over all alchemist beats.
2752436, lol, he actually said
Posted by Ketchums, Mon Oct-29-12 06:20 PM
"Swing my dick in a circle, so you know I'm not fuckin' around"

smmfh
2752468, yea I can SEE the "Eminem rapped like hell" argument
Posted by Nodima, Mon Oct-29-12 08:39 PM
because at first I felt that way too

but after about a week, Recovery was one of the corniest sets of rhymes I'd ever heard regardless of scheme/meter

and the beats didn't help at ALL

~~~~~~~~~
"This is the streets, and I am the trap." © Jay Bilas
"I don't read pages of rap lyrics, I listen to rap music." © Bombastic
http://www.popmatters.com/pm/archive/contributor/517
Hip Hop Handbook: http://tinyurl.com/ll4kzz
2752357, Everybody talks about relapse vs recovery
Posted by Dr_Gonzo, Mon Oct-29-12 02:05 PM
I'm more on SSLP vs MMLP vs TES
I'll take any of those over his last two.
I'm just hoping that the man studies his own work and what made it good/bad, gets other producers, and just raps well.
2752439, RE: Can Eminem top Recovery?
Posted by StakksAbbot, Mon Oct-29-12 06:28 PM
Commercially, it'd be difficult i think. That shit sold like 5 million in this climate, that's damn near 10 mil+ in the early 2000's, so it'd be difficult for him to surpass that..

However...

Artistically, he could...If he quit with the yelling and the corny one liners and went back to just flowing his ass off ala kill you or criminal he's easily to surpass it. The way he rhymes now, if he had the same flow and content of yesteryear with slight alterations to how he flows, he'll obliterate his recent output...
2752441, He could fart for an hour and surpass Recovery artistically...
Posted by Brew, Mon Oct-29-12 06:32 PM
2752442, RE: He could fart for an hour and surpass Recovery artistically...
Posted by StakksAbbot, Mon Oct-29-12 06:35 PM
No question, but can/will he is the million dollar question
2752463, it will be better than recovery
Posted by makaveli, Mon Oct-29-12 08:19 PM
but it won't do better commercially.
2752464, I for one and hoping for...
Posted by L0WD0WN, Mon Oct-29-12 08:27 PM

1. Beats mostly by Dre, mixed with a little Mr. Porter, 45 King, Salaam Remi and 40.
2. NO YELLING
3. Braggadocios rhymes (it's about time he talks more about how good he is just like rappers with half his talent do)
4. Topics: The state of hip hop or what hip hop means to him, a tribute to Detroit posse cut, reflection on his career, some subliminal disses towards popular MC's (Rick Ross would be a good target), a song aimed at haters in general that don't give him the respect he deservers.
5. Guest Appearances by Royce, Obie Trice, Proof (an old, never before used verse), Xzhibit and Red Man.
6. No song about his mom! (Though I might be interested to hear what's up with Halle these days)
7. A couple freestyles type interludes a la BET cypher where he just blacks out for 2 minutes.
8. Did I mention no yelling?
2752496, RE: I for one and hoping for...
Posted by StakksAbbot, Mon Oct-29-12 10:13 PM
I actually like the idea of the cypher-style interludes...like what wayne did on carter 4, but just eminem going over a beat that builds each time he gets on it, between songs about whatever, that would be 19 different kinds of ill!
2752499, The Hallie thing isn't happening
Posted by Laz aka Black Native, Mon Oct-29-12 10:15 PM
Nas wanted him on a remix for Daughters & Em turned it down b/c he said he'd done enough rapping about her
2752542, I'd buy this album.
Posted by KneelB4Me, Tue Oct-30-12 02:07 AM
And I haven't dropped 1 cent for Em since The Eminem Show.


"I halfway hope people put "btw, rappers lie and shit" on CD covers, like a parental advisory sticker." - OKP Villain

www.twitter.com/lexlamont
2752545, Didn't you hear 'Cindarella Man'
Posted by denny, Tue Oct-30-12 03:21 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQFETJqRctw
2752832, Yeeea but...
Posted by L0WD0WN, Tue Oct-30-12 08:05 PM
I think that song sounds more like his way of saying "I feel good" "I'm a new man" and almost trying to convince himself that he's ready to be back. Like a self help book or something.

I'm talking more like "I'm iller than any MC in the game. You can't fuck with me".
2753461, Eminem blackout tracks would be awesome in any form...
Posted by phenompyrus, Thu Nov-01-12 09:15 PM
Interludes, intro/outro, tracks...
2752543, My answer isn't answering the question....
Posted by denny, Tue Oct-30-12 02:50 AM
but the reason such a question gets asked is because:

At some point in time, Eminem decided to write his way into the archetypical pop artist. And it's seemed contrived to me at parts....but that's his bottom line in his artistry. He's making a story.

And that's why one billion people will buy a completely unaccessible record like 'Relapse' and why one billion people will buy his new record.

They want to see where the story goes. He tells a good yarn and it's easily reducible to the rags to riches, dealing with fame, excess, fall-back, recovery, triumphant return, etc.... It's an ARCHETYPE and he knows his way around it.

I suspect his next album will have some songs that are less personal than Em's normal thing. Basically, I think he's gonna be more like a Springsteen thing or something. Trying to speak to the common people's problems instead of his own.
2752553, Eminem is the greatest pop artist of 00's.
Posted by denny, Tue Oct-30-12 05:10 AM
The following link don't always sound good....but the writing and the variety of content is astounding:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AA-qj_oL_14&feature=related
2752626, He did and it's called ReLapse
Posted by Mgmt, Tue Oct-30-12 11:07 AM
2752860, RECOVERY FUCKING SUCKS
Posted by thesickboi, Tue Oct-30-12 09:50 PM
I still, after all this time, can't believe people like this album.

It's not Eminem.

It's contrived, cookie cutter, huff pop rap.


Fuck this album. It sucks all of the dicks.


Eminem already fucking DID top Recovery, with every other album he released.
2752866, You didn't read my post
Posted by L0WD0WN, Tue Oct-30-12 10:33 PM
2752915, I LAUGHED
Posted by Brew, Wed Oct-31-12 07:19 AM
>It sucks all of the dicks.

Priceless. I'm dying.
2754052, haha. standard catchphrase of mine.
Posted by thesickboi, Mon Nov-05-12 03:57 PM
glad you laughed.
2753983, Doubt it, it's one of the GOAT albums lyrically in the history of hip hop
Posted by Oak27, Mon Nov-05-12 10:53 AM
http://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=2524082&mesg_id=2524082&listing_type=search
2755145, Hilarious post.
Posted by denny, Sat Nov-10-12 04:29 AM
Yet could only be made by someone that really got stuck on something. And they sound like someone who hated hip hop in 1985 to me.
2755153, Does Eminem even realize how much Recovery sucked?
Posted by Admbmb, Sat Nov-10-12 07:07 AM
I can understand if he did a "sell out" album, but does he actually realize how corny this album was to actual fans of hip hop? And the YELLING has to stop. Does he have anyone around him that can tap him on the shoulder and say "dude...the fuck are you doing"?
2756643, Nope.
Posted by L0WD0WN, Fri Nov-16-12 10:07 PM
Because outside of OKP and "under ground" websites, the rest of the world loved the album. So I doubt he really cares.