Go back to previous topic
Forum nameThe Lesson
Topic subjectAre you a completionist of any music artist?
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=2738566
2738566, Are you a completionist of any music artist?
Posted by The DC Sniper, Sat Sep-08-12 12:30 AM
I'm talking about you owning EVERYTHING they've ever produced. All the LPs, EPs, singles, remixes, alternate artwork, foreign editions, etc. I want to do so with a lot of artists but I'm very obsessive so I know that I'll probably end up selling my car if I do. It's very informative, however. For those of you who only buy the main albums in stores or on iTunes, you'd be surprised how much music you haven't heard from a lot of your favorite artists. I tried to be a Bjork completionist but it got to the point where I'd have to file for Chapter 11 just to get all her Japanese releases on eBay. Then there's also the realization that no matter how hard you try, you won't be able to own everything an artist has made because two new things pop up for every one that you buy. It's a very Quixotic or Sisyphean task. I doubt even ?uestlove owns every Prince release.
2738569, ARRUH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by mistermaxxx08, Sat Sep-08-12 12:38 AM
R.Kelly because i got all kinds of songs he did for acts, known, unknown and hood acts.

and he is hard to keep up with on the real, but i'm close to everything he has everything he has ever done though.

got all of his books the good ones
2738570, RE: ARRUH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by The DC Sniper, Sat Sep-08-12 12:43 AM
Do you got that Talent advance CD?
2738629, RE: ARRUH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by mistermaxxx08, Sat Sep-08-12 08:57 AM
yeah i did and it was cool for the rareness of it, though aside from a couple of songs i wasn't blown away or anything,however they could have made a little nose.

i was trying to tracy down Lady.
2738588, Prince & The Lady In MY Ave,,,
Posted by Harlepolis, Sat Sep-08-12 04:02 AM
Somethings I can bring myself to spend my lousy dime on though, like Carmen Electra's album. Thanks, but noooooooo, thank you!
2738593, i used to be. i would get every beat made by certain producers
Posted by GumDrops, Sat Sep-08-12 04:18 AM
even when i knew they werent that great

now im not fussed about that

i dont need every primo beat ever made

i dont even need every prince thing out there

every p-funk thing isnt necessary

but then thats also cos i dont have the time/inclination to rummage through every release in search of gems anymore, which maybe just makes me less of a hardcore music head these days, but im fine with only having the best stuff
2738597, official releases or whatever, but
Posted by Nodima, Sat Sep-08-12 04:44 AM
I don't really bother with bonus tracks, or b-sides/singles, or foreign tracks. Just LPs, EPs and tapes. There are some exceptions, but I'm not a fiend about it for anyone. The closest is probably Lil' Wayne and Gucci Mane, but even then I'm not hunting down albums he has a guest feature on if I have no interest in them. And those two are nowhere near my favorite artists, I just sort of latched onto knowing what they're up to.

~~~~~~~~~
"This is the streets, and I am the trap." © Jay Bilas

http://www.last.fm/user/NodimaChee
http://www.popmatters.com/pm/archive/contributor/517
http://rateyourmusic.com/list/Nodima/run_that_shit__nodimas_hip_hop_handbook
2738611, J-Zone for sure.
Posted by Li Mu Bai, Sat Sep-08-12 07:17 AM
It helps that a lot of the other artists he's worked with(Copywrite, Tame One, Cage, etc) were on Eastern Conference or Fondle Em but he's still got some stuff that's pretty hard to find.
2738616, Have You Copped His Book Yet?
Posted by Dj Joey Joe, Sat Sep-08-12 08:12 AM
"Root For The Villain" http://www.amazon.com/Root-Villain-Bull-Celebration-Failure/dp/0615532276 came out probably 6months ago but I heard it's pretty good with a lot of information on how the rap industry is; plus I heard that it was a limited audio-cassette version of this book, you might want to start tracking that down if you are a die-hard fan of J-Zone.


2738657, that shit is expensive. lol
Posted by Joe Corn Mo, Sat Sep-08-12 12:29 PM
i don't need every 12" single and remix.
i don't need every guest appearance and side project.

my favorite artists are MJ, prince, marvin gaye, and stevie wonder.


3 of those four artists started at motown. which means
they all have a boat load of filler that's not worth hearing once,
nevermind owning.


the fourth is so prolificly inconsistent that makes
efforts to own his entire discography futile and unrewarding.



that being said, there are artists that i own all of the albums
from their golden eras.

but there's no artist that i own ALL of their material.


>I'm talking about you owning EVERYTHING they've ever
>produced. All the LPs, EPs, singles, remixes, alternate
>artwork, foreign editions, etc. I want to do so with a lot of
>artists but I'm very obsessive so I know that I'll probably
>end up selling my car if I do. It's very informative, however.
>For those of you who only buy the main albums in stores or on
>iTunes, you'd be surprised how much music you haven't heard
>from a lot of your favorite artists. I tried to be a Bjork
>completionist but it got to the point where I'd have to file
>for Chapter 11 just to get all her Japanese releases on eBay.
>Then there's also the realization that no matter how hard you
>try, you won't be able to own everything an artist has made
>because two new things pop up for every one that you buy. It's
>a very Quixotic or Sisyphean task. I doubt even ?uestlove owns
>every Prince release.
2738667, Used to be with Meshell, up to about 2004.
Posted by Buck, Sat Sep-08-12 01:21 PM
Getting that way with Joni Mitchell now.
2738677, Amy Winehouse
Posted by Dix, Sat Sep-08-12 01:45 PM
Lots of crazy demos and live shows out there
2738680, i do what i can
Posted by fontgangsta, Sat Sep-08-12 01:55 PM
im pretty anal, so i only put complete discogs on my HD - ive got an "incomplete" folder for the collections im still working on
sometimes if there's like one japanese bonus track i can't scavenge of the of the netz ill let it go, but for the most part im a stickler. so far ive got 345 discogs and counting
2738689, RE: Are you a completionist of any music artist?
Posted by ajiav, Sat Sep-08-12 02:57 PM
I did recently order that bjork disc of remixes from debut, incl. black dog, sabres of paradise, etc. - haven't gotten it yet, but was curious given the 'remixers' involved and I had never heard of it. Two dollars, seemed worth it, but curious on your take, if familiar.
2738696, Completist n/m
Posted by johnbook, Sat Sep-08-12 03:54 PM

THE HOME OF BOOK-NESS:
http://www.thisisbooksmusic.com/
http://twitter.com/thisisjohnbook
http://www.facebook.com/book1


http://i32.tinypic.com/kbewp4.gif
http://i50.tinypic.com/hvqi4w.jpg