Go back to previous topic
Forum nameThe Lesson
Topic subjectI don't get how Late Registration is >> The College Dropout
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=2659210
2659210, I don't get how Late Registration is >> The College Dropout
Posted by BlackandProud, Wed Feb-08-12 04:27 AM
Late Registration is cool and all but I don't get it when a lot of people say it's a better album than The College Dropout. To me, Kanye's best and opus album is The College Dropout. CD is just a dope album from start to finish, great singles and great non singles. While I think some of Late Registration is cool and all, it just doesn't compare. I think when it comes to Late Registration I enjoy the music or beats rather, more so than I do the actual songs and even sequencing of the album. It doesn't flow like The College Dropout does. After about midway through the album it sounds spotty and not like one sound. I think had he just stuck with one sound with the production it would've been better. Like The College Dropout sounds like one complete sound on the production side of things. That album is better because of the songs, sequencing, and one sound. I might be the only one who thinks so but Late Registration just sounds more like a handful of good songs instead of an album while The College Dropout sounds like a complete album.
2659211, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWdd6_ZxX8c
Posted by Nodima, Wed Feb-08-12 04:44 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWdd6_ZxX8c



~~~~~~~~~
"This is the streets, and I am the trap." © Jay Bilas

http://www.last.fm/user/NodimaChee
http://www.popmatters.com/pm/archive/contributor/517
http://rateyourmusic.com/list/Nodima/run_that_shit__nodimas_hip_hop_handbook
2659214, More polish, much improved rapping, more focused stories
Posted by -DJ R-Tistic-, Wed Feb-08-12 05:19 AM
and verses.

It's one of those where that first album was basically like 28 years of work (however old he was then) and the next album was like a year and a half's work, if that....so of course, the first one is great in different ways.
2659218, I agree wholeheartedly
Posted by Szabo, Wed Feb-08-12 06:26 AM
For mine the production on tcd is kinda dated compared to lr which if released today would sound fresh. Fantasy is my fav, late and graduation a close second then tcd
2659306, End post
Posted by ZooTown74, Wed Feb-08-12 11:38 AM
LR expands CD's world view and has a richer sound

I get why people would prefer CD over LR, though... it's a pretty simple hip hop record in comparison to LR, though

_________________________________________________________________________
Baby, I'm your carpenter, please let me lay your tile
2659420, this
Posted by BrooklynWHAT, Wed Feb-08-12 03:14 PM
2659860, ^^^^what he said
Posted by soulsupreme, Thu Feb-09-12 02:31 PM

______________________________________________________________
http://twitter.com/Gedi

"This is your world. Shape it or someone else will." - Gary Lew
2659215, Wait....The College Dropout doesn't have "one complete sound"
Posted by zuma1986, Wed Feb-08-12 06:01 AM
This
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b4SbYnNsTQA
doesn't sound like this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8yoxyIu0s8
which doesn't sound like this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkFOBx6j0l8
which doesn't sound like this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S0IYO1M4OIY
2659223, Typical backlash against what most gravitate to.
Posted by Otis Oliver Ocean, Wed Feb-08-12 07:17 AM
Didn't you read the Off The Wall>>>>>>>>>Thriller post?
The Parade>>>>>>>>>>>Purple Rain post?

Do you know where you postin right now? The better album becomes the
worse album if it's a)loved by more people or b)a bigger seller. You
wanna come in here and flip the OKP LESSON rules on they head? Boy you
better fall in line!!!

And why in the fucking fuck is you named BLACKNPROUD with a damn white
brawd in yo avy? What kind of confused NIGGA bullshit is that? Fuckin disgrace!
2659234, CD has no replay value
Posted by Nick Has a Problem...Seriously, Wed Feb-08-12 08:03 AM
you take the skits off LR and you have damn near a classic. about three or four tracks get burn from CD.
2659247, RE: CD has no replay value
Posted by Thanes1975, Wed Feb-08-12 08:51 AM
Yep, LR has more replay value, less filler, and Kanye had improved as an MC
2659250, LR is worlds better, IMO
Posted by Dstl1, Wed Feb-08-12 08:56 AM
Song for song it wins by a landslide. CD wasn't nearly as focused. The skits make it almost impossible for me to listen to it now. Whereas LR can damn near be played without skipping.
2659255, LR has better beats and rhymes
Posted by Ishwip, Wed Feb-08-12 09:12 AM

__
I don't like the beat anymore because its just a loop. ALC didn't FLIP IT ENOUGH!

Flip it enough? Flip these. Flip off. Go flip some f*cking burgers.(c)Kno

Allied State of the National Electric Beat Treaty Organization (NEBTO)
2659256, College Dropout is a rap album, Late Registration is pop/rap
Posted by spew120, Wed Feb-08-12 09:20 AM
2659698, No.
Posted by Szabo, Thu Feb-09-12 06:41 AM
Both have pop/rap elements, which isn't a bad thing. Graduation is his 'pop'-iest album by far/
2659267, Dropout will always be my favorite Kanye album
Posted by Oak27, Wed Feb-08-12 09:45 AM
For nostalgia alone.

I also love how Kanye isn't taking himself too seriously on this album. A lot more humble, hungry and humorous. Even the wacker skits, the workout song and the obvious punching in Kanye does after like a line and a half of rapping.. I fucking love it all *kanye shrug*
2659672, Yeah, The College Dropout just shines bright to me.
Posted by BlackandProud, Thu Feb-09-12 02:14 AM
I don't mind the skits either, in fact I like them.
2659268, College Dropout has
Posted by cjr2221, Wed Feb-08-12 09:47 AM
no replay value in 2012. I still spin Late Registration now and then, College Dropout sounds dated.

Spaceship, Two Words, and Never Let Me Down are the only tracks on College Dropout that still have value to me.

I don't think College Dropout is as cohesive as Late Registration, I end up having to skip tracks which is why I never listen to it anymore; for me to play an LP it can't have skip-ables.

I almost thought this was a shock post when I first saw the subject b/c I've never heard anyone say Dropout > Late Registration.
2659307, no love for Through the Wire and All Falls Down?
Posted by hardware, Wed Feb-08-12 11:40 AM
2659421, Why yall always bring up this DATED argument?
Posted by Otis Oliver Ocean, Wed Feb-08-12 03:16 PM
As if you caint enjoy music that sounds like it's from another era? If
you caint, ok fine but that don't mean the music ain't good. As much
as the negros talk about Rakim, KRS ONE, Big Daddy Kane and all that,
DATED shouldn't be an issue.
2659522, It sounds stale
Posted by cjr2221, Wed Feb-08-12 06:28 PM
http://images.cheezburger.com/completestore/2011/9/3/4e382e74-a719-4cad-9d27-4496cccfa345.jpg

does stale work better than dated?

Age has nothing to do with it, really; well it kinda does....

hmmmmm KRS-One, Rakim and them their music obviously, sounds dated, but it's not "stale".

No what I'm saying? It's timeless.

College Dropout is not a pleasure to listen to, like Paid in Full/Return of the Boom Bap.

When I was 12 I thought through the wire was an AMAZING song. Now nah I skip that shit heard it way to much on the radio, and it's not even that great of a song. All Falls Down is tight though.

But LR
Drive Slow
Heard Em Say
Roses
Bring Me Down
CRACK MUSIC
We Major
MY WAY HOME
Addiction

C'mon son. Late Registration is classic.

College Dropout... nah?

it's all opinion though so w/e.
2659708, HOLD UP
Posted by hardware, Thu Feb-09-12 07:57 AM
you were 12 when that shit dropped?!

Damn. I feel old.
2659853, lol
Posted by cjr2221, Thu Feb-09-12 01:56 PM
I don't know; I was youngER than I am now.

lemme do the math

Through the wire came out in '03; oh shit I was 10 lmao.

Doesn't seem that long ago, but it was almost a half of my lifetime ago.

=\.
2659304, It isn't to me. I go...
Posted by CaptNish, Wed Feb-08-12 11:35 AM
808s (yeah yeah, I know) > Dropout > MBDTF > LR > Graduation

Mind you, those bottom three trade spots depending on the last time I heard 'em.
2659315, You're pretty much the exact opposite of me...
Posted by Brew, Wed Feb-08-12 11:58 AM
>808s (yeah yeah, I know) > Dropout > MBDTF > LR > Graduation

I go:

Graduation
Late Registration
College Dropout
MBDTF
2659399, 808s FIRST and Graduation LAST? Well I never... lol
Posted by CMcMurtry, Wed Feb-08-12 02:46 PM
Graduation is still his "masterpiece", I think.
2659418, Grad I know I sleep on.
Posted by CaptNish, Wed Feb-08-12 03:13 PM
I fuck with:

"Good Morning"
"Champion"
"Stronger"
"I Wonder"
"Can't Tell Me Nothing"
"Flashing Lights"
"Everything I Am"

But usually skip:

"Drunk and Hot Girls"*
"Barry Bonds"
"Homecoming"
"Big Brother"
"The Glory"
"Good Life"

(* - Actually... I listen to D&HG a lot. But not because I think it's a good song. Just cause the shit makes me laugh)
2659308, The rapping on LR is SO much better than CD that it's not even close
Posted by CMcMurtry, Wed Feb-08-12 11:40 AM
I think CD's best songs (All Falls Down, Spaceship, Never Let Me Down, Jesus Walks) are better than the best songs on LR, however, from start to finish, Late Registration is the stronger project, IMO.

As well, the skits on College Dropout feel less useful than the ones on Late Registration.

Looking back, I'd rank CD a strong @@@@, and LR a @@@@1/2. So not as if the projects are miles apart in terms of quality.
2659318, he delivered beyond expectations with LR
Posted by cbk, Wed Feb-08-12 12:01 PM
better rapping. really good songs too: "roses" "hey mama" undeniable (or unavoidable?) "golddigger"

bigger production. he got jon brion...HUGE wtf??? that actually worked. the music exploded off the speakers: "we major" "gone" "diamonds" the end of "celebration"

as it's always said, he didn't go the easy route and give us CD2. he did some brave shit and worked.

and speaking of brave, he got nas before the jay-z beef was deaded...when jay was his boss! that, and coming out against homophobia when the album dropped really stood out. and the music was really good too.
2659398, Don't let ?uest here you say this...
Posted by CaptNish, Wed Feb-08-12 02:45 PM
>he got jon brion...HUGE wtf???

lol
2659442, haha i know, maybe
Posted by cbk, Wed Feb-08-12 03:52 PM
jay putting out his coldplay song before kanye (and kanye getting all mad at it, haha) was the universe's way of getting kanye back for him swiping jon brion first before the roots.
2659475, what was the story on that?
Posted by Stadiq, Wed Feb-08-12 04:38 PM
2659494, apparently ?uest, i think around the time of the Block Party
Posted by forgivenphoenix, Wed Feb-08-12 05:10 PM
had the idea to work with Jon Brion on what would I guess have been The Tipping Point. However, KanYe got wind of the idea and booked time with Jon Brion before The Roots did, thus negating the novelty of Jon Brion working with hip-hop.

i kinda wish ?uest had went ahead and did it anyway because I think it would have led to some work more musically complex than the more pop leanings on LR.
2659540, Really?! That's fucked up.
Posted by Brew, Wed Feb-08-12 07:28 PM
Never heard that story.

Is ?uest salty about it? He seems to praise Kanye often so I guess not, but if I were him I'd be fired up about that.
2659563, ?uest being the gracious and dignified person he is has mostly
Posted by forgivenphoenix, Wed Feb-08-12 08:33 PM
gotten over it. I think from posts he's made around here that he's more salty that KanYe has never reached out to work with him or Thought and since they kinda share similar fans (although KanYe has more of them) it would be a natural step to let The Roots shine on a KanYe record so that The Roots could get some more exposure.

i think there was some beef between KanYe and Thought because KanYe was a twitter about something he *thinks* he heard Thought say, but i think that eventually got deaded.

but yeah for a while I think ?uest was angry (and rightfully so) about the situation.
2659567, Word word ... I definitely hear all of this.
Posted by Brew, Wed Feb-08-12 08:42 PM
2659579, There's def a GOOD Music beef.
Posted by CaptNish, Wed Feb-08-12 09:18 PM
Find the post ?uest made about how hard it was to be able to do the project with John.
2659671, does this post exist or were you asking me to find it?
Posted by forgivenphoenix, Thu Feb-09-12 02:07 AM
i looked in The Lesson Archives but I didn't find anything related to jon brion.
2659738, Here's the post without detail
Posted by CaptNish, Thu Feb-09-12 09:41 AM
http://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=2627970&mesg_id=2627970&listing_type=search#2629157

I feel like there was another, but I can't find it.
2660074, i hope i don't come off as snide
Posted by forgivenphoenix, Thu Feb-09-12 11:23 PM
but i didn't read anything in that post about Jon Brion. just about Bill Withers and Al Green.
2660079, Nah, I think we crossed streams on the convo
Posted by CaptNish, Thu Feb-09-12 11:32 PM
The link I posted was in regards to the GOOD Music/Roots beef and how hard it was doing the project with John Legend. As for the Brion stuff.... first time I heard about it, ?uest had talked about it back in the old chatroom. And then it fell through. You can see a taste of it here: http://qoolquest.blogspot.com/
2659599, timing-wise, wouldnt it have been Game Theory? Either way
Posted by Stadiq, Wed Feb-08-12 09:46 PM

thanks for the info...

They should still do it.
2659455, lol this means absolutely nothing
Posted by Oak27, Wed Feb-08-12 04:05 PM

>and speaking of brave, he got nas before the jay-z beef was
>deaded...when jay was his boss! that, and coming out against
>homophobia when the album dropped really stood out. and the
>music was really good too.

by this time the beef was essentially dead, and he wasnt even the first person to get both of them on his album since the beef started (see: the fix)
2659516, well...
Posted by cbk, Wed Feb-08-12 06:10 PM
how dead was it in late 04-early 05 when "we major" was recorded? i didn't think they were COOL cool until they did interviews together, and then jay appeared on "black republicans" which officially meant dead to me.

different with scarface. kanye was completely under jay's wing.
2659631, This was around the same time as the album
Posted by zuma1986, Wed Feb-08-12 10:40 PM
http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1512432/jayz-nas-put-beef-sleep.jhtml
2659330, better rapping, less horrible skits, fully actualized concepts, etc.
Posted by Benedict the Moor, Wed Feb-08-12 12:30 PM
2659558, It's his best album to me.
Posted by unohoo, Wed Feb-08-12 08:23 PM
And yes it is better than College Dropout.
The people have already provided valid evidence. (well...opinion)
2659587, Both are really really good
Posted by Playa_Politician, Wed Feb-08-12 09:26 PM
but LR just sounds more musical to me if that makes any sense. LR is IMO his best work, but none of his shit is really wack so it's all debatable.
2659849, LR is great... but the sequencing on the 2nd half isn't great..
Posted by DonWonJusuton, Thu Feb-09-12 01:51 PM
"bring me down" is really bad.. but other than that.. the album is really really good.. i still like Graduation and MBDTF better.... maybe even watch the throne too.. but honestly, kanye is getting to that territory where i don't even like saying which one i like "better"... all of the albums are completely different... the closest are probably CD and LR.. and the latter sounds like a more refined version of CD's style and really, it's like when he "put it all together".. CD was the draft.. Graduation is basically the prototype 00's pop rap album.. MBDTF is the untamed opus