>Metallica's first 5 are very strong, don't really know if
>anything since the Black album has been well received but
>still have a huge fanbase. Since this is strictly about
>discogs, than idk if Wilco has 5 better but definately don't
>have any that made as much noise since most people couldn't
>tell you what Wilco is including me.

Metallica's first two are before the 25 year cutoff. That's a big problem. After the cutoff they have:

Master of Puppets - classic
And Justice for All - classic
Black album - good to great
Load/Reload - not good
St. Anger - the opposite of good
Death Magnetic - good

They need those first two. If this was about the last 30 years instead of the last 25, I think they're big contenders on the basis of the first four or five alone.