Go back to previous topic
Forum nameThe Lesson
Topic subjectyep. and they're just gettin' all bent outta shape.
Topic URLhttp://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=5&topic_id=2537278&mesg_id=2537616
2537616, yep. and they're just gettin' all bent outta shape.
Posted by disco dj, Wed Apr-13-11 09:23 PM

>(not necessarily that you DON'T, but rather that you CAN'T. It
>requires an entirely new notation to itself, one that still
>hasn't been completely successfully developed; that can't be
>said about most other musical systems which use different
>notations in their indigenous settings but can still be
>represented by/transliterated to Western notation if
>necessary.)

right. that's ALLLLLLLL I'm trying to say.


>
>that hip hop did not represent a natural progression in
>musical evolution, but rather a break from musical continuity;
>ground zero of an entirely different evolutionary tree.
>
>Which was mostly disagreed with.

and rather than address it, they're just circling their wagons and flying the "Hip-Hop *IS* real music, you just have to know how to break it down" banners. Nobody is admitting that the shit CANNOT, in it's most elemental form, be written on sheet music as ONE ENTIRE COMPOSITION. All they keep talking about is polyrhythms, and cadences and wordplay and all that other shit.

The minute somebody shows me the Sheet Music for "Welcome To The Terrordome" I'll shut up.