Go back to previous topic |
Forum name | General Discussion |
Topic subject | Ryan Coogler's Sinners. |
Topic URL | http://board.okayplayer.com/okp.php?az=show_topic&forum=4&topic_id=13510371 |
13510371, Ryan Coogler's Sinners. Posted by bwood, Tue Sep-24-24 08:16 AM
Starring Michael B. Jordan of course.
Shot on 70mm and IMAX film.
Trailer: https://youtu.be/bKGxHflevuk?si=NUYYZvH2bpNGU6m0
|
13510377, Wasn't dying for a horror movie but Looks good. Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Tue Sep-24-24 09:30 AM
********** "Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson
"what's a leader if he isn't reluctant"
|
13510944, Another racism move. These dudes need to stop making movies. Posted by 81 DUN, Fri Oct-04-24 11:13 PM
Black Trauma and popcorn. Racism and an ice cold coke. Slavery and some JujyFruits
|
13511209, How'd you land on that from the 2:00min trailer? Posted by FLUIDJ, Fri Oct-11-24 08:29 AM
"Get ready....for your blessing....." "Bury me by my Grand-Grand and when you can come follow me"
|
13511221, I'm honestly confused as to how you reached this... Posted by bwood, Fri Oct-11-24 12:04 PM
...conclusion.
|
13511293, That's the new stupidcool thing to say. Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Sat Oct-12-24 10:03 AM
Because this trailer doesn't say that, but even if it did, our people's stories still deserve to be told and they deserve our attention.
|
13511553, Thank you Posted by bwood, Wed Oct-16-24 11:35 AM
Between this and the Aaron Pierre as Green Lantern colorism, Ho-teps are taking it to levels that don't need to be taken to.
Just making it weird for no reason.
|
13511884, We rank last when it comes to film making. Unimaginative. Posted by 81 DUN, Tue Oct-22-24 07:45 PM
We get one of two every now and then. I liked the movie Us I can't think of much else. I'm not one of the people that like things just because.
|
13511892, What did you like about ‘Us’? Posted by 3CardMolly, Tue Oct-22-24 08:03 PM
There was so much background missing from it for me.
|
13511970, Literally what are you saying? Posted by bwood, Thu Oct-24-24 09:19 AM
All there is a vague two-minute trailer that gives away very little outside of mood, tone, and feel.
I seriously don't know how you connect your previous comments or Us to this.
|
13511982, Us was kinda wack.. lol Posted by legsdiamond, Fri Oct-25-24 07:17 AM
this doesn’t look like a story about “racism”
that’s like saying Life was about racism because of the pie scene down south or the time period being before Jim Crow.
|
13512043, Or the white warden Posted by 3CardMolly, Sat Oct-26-24 08:16 AM
Or his white daughter w/black baby Or all the inmates being black Or how unjust and racist the justice system is. Granted we didnt get stuck on the racism, the films backdrop (w/some foreground appearances) is racism.
|
13510955, After seeing 81 Dun’s response, I’m good Posted by 3CardMolly, Sat Oct-05-24 01:10 PM
But you know what would be nice, a film on Christopher J. Scarver Sr. Perhaps written from the perspective of a conversation with his son.
Now that I’d pay top dollar for.
|
13511018, 13 years a Slave is getting a Netflix series. Posted by 81 DUN, Mon Oct-07-24 01:58 AM
Maybe your prison movie idea will see the light of day.
|
13511893, Naw cause he killed their beloved dahmer Posted by 3CardMolly, Tue Oct-22-24 08:13 PM
A racist and some two bit hick (also white) that stiffed him a days pay.
|
13511292, You should probably not listen to 81Dun and look for yourself. Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Sat Oct-12-24 10:01 AM
|
13511889, don't forget the new Kendrick Lamar slavery movie by the South park creators Posted by 81 DUN, Tue Oct-22-24 07:53 PM
I can't make this B's up.
|
13512057, True or not, that ain't got shit to do with a damn thing. Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Sat Oct-26-24 03:17 PM
|
13512164, When a person is defending something so flawed this hard Posted by 81 DUN, Mon Oct-28-24 05:03 PM
Coogs and B Jordan get participation points but they're not good in their field of work. The system is dirty.
|
13511133, Horrible accents. Should've gotten somebody from the South for real. Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Tue Oct-08-24 06:03 PM
I might still see it tho. Can't glean much from the trailer.
|
13511154, I am kinda on that these days. Just saw the Piano Lesson. Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Wed Oct-09-24 11:00 AM
And I think it makes a difference to have real Southerners play these roles instead of Brits.
********** "Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson
"what's a leader if he isn't reluctant"
|
13511204, It really makes a difference. Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Fri Oct-11-24 03:57 AM
Even with Black Americans from different places. For some reason, a lot of Black people who aren't from the south tend to talk like white southerners in these roles instead of Black southerners. It irritates my southern ears so bad that I can't really take the story seriously.
|
13511266, Man, go see Piano Lesson when it drops on Netflix next month. Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Fri Oct-11-24 06:30 PM
You are exactly right about folks doing White Southerners instead of Black Southerners. Piano Lesson has legit Southerners and it shows.
********** "Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson
"what's a leader if he isn't reluctant"
|
13511284, Aight, bet. Apparently it's in select theaters Nov. 8th. Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Sat Oct-12-24 12:52 AM
I'll check it out then if it's playing somewhere near.
|
13518787, I saw this btw. Loved it! Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Mon May-05-25 09:28 PM
|
13511885, It's called acting for a reason. Let the best actor get the role. Posted by 81 DUN, Tue Oct-22-24 07:49 PM
Now we hating on Black British actors. I don't see no one hating on Colin Farrell for playing an American.
|
13511924, He's not hating on Black British Actors, he's hating on bad accents Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Wed Oct-23-24 12:59 PM
And what might be passable to a non-Black Southerners can sound terrible for people from there.
And I don't give a shit about Colin Farrell playing an American but I do care about the authenticity of the portrayals of Southern Black people.
Ain't that hard.
>Now we hating on Black British actors. I don't see no one >hating on Colin Farrell for playing an American.
********** "Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson
"what's a leader if he isn't reluctant"
|
13511978, Michael B. Jordan is from Oakland. Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Thu Oct-24-24 07:23 PM
I like how you automatically associated bad southern accents with British actors tho. Sounds like we're "hating" together.
|
13512166, Michael B. Jordan is not from Oakland. Posted by 81 DUN, Mon Oct-28-24 05:11 PM
|
13512177, Close enough to prove my point Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Mon Oct-28-24 09:21 PM
|
13512305, Born in SoCal, raised in NJ. nm Posted by Original Juice, Wed Oct-30-24 11:43 PM
|
13512379, Ok. Again, point is he ain't British. He's American. Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Fri Nov-01-24 06:49 PM
|
13512380, Ok. Again, point is he ain't British. He's American. Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Fri Nov-01-24 06:50 PM
|
13511984, the goal is to entertain and make money Posted by legsdiamond, Fri Oct-25-24 07:25 AM
I didn’t notice or care about accents when I watched the trailer
and yes, I’m from Pittsburgh but I have lived down south long enough to finally understand the thickest of southern accents.. lol.
|
13511983, This was a fantastic trailer Posted by legsdiamond, Fri Oct-25-24 07:22 AM
no idea wtf this is about.. vampires? the devil?
|
13518654, alladat interwoven with cultural appropriation Posted by legsdiamond, Tue Apr-29-25 08:44 AM
and all of it happened because of a gotdamn Karen ass white woman
|
13518670, All he had to do was tongue her cooze like she asked. Posted by JFrost1117, Tue Apr-29-25 11:29 PM
|
13518680, PRESSED!!! Posted by legsdiamond, Wed Apr-30-25 09:25 AM
|
13518682, my favorite piece of cultural appropriation was "Pick Poor Robin Clean" Posted by PROMO, Wed Apr-30-25 09:42 AM
i was sort of fascinated by it as they were singing it in the movie because it seemed like something that might be like, some irish jig or whatever.
then, as we sat thru the credits for the end scenes, i noticed it was a song by someone named Geeshie Wiley. i turned to my wife and said, "that song was by someone named Geeshie so you know they are black...so the white vampires appropriated it, made it white, and were using it to lure or make the black people comfortable".
THEN, if you actually look into the deeper meaning of "Pick Poor Robin Clean"??? absolute fire as far as the thought that went into this:
https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTjkWs1PJ/
|
13518686, I'm hoping the blu-ray release of the moive Posted by Numba_33, Wed Apr-30-25 10:44 AM
will delve into the research that went into stuff like what you mentioned above.
I have to imagine some level of research and attention to detail went into the Irish jig portion of the movie, along with showing the Asian-American shop keepers.
It was nice for a movie rooted deep in a Southern black aesthetic took the level of care and respect to authentically display other cultures as well.
For a mainstream blockbuster movie, it certainly has layers and depth to it.
|
13518688, yeah, i'm deep down the historical rabbit hole of Sinners on Tik Tok Posted by PROMO, Wed Apr-30-25 10:56 AM
there's some great clips floating around about the histories of asian people in the mississippi delta.
the movie has so many layers and messages, and probably a ton more that may not have even been intentional but are easy to see once you look past the surface.
my favorite detail that i didn't understand when i first watched was the reason why Smoke and Stack are dressed how they are dressed, and how, that ultimately plays into the greater story.
|
13518641, Brilliant movie. For everybody, by us, and about us. Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Mon Apr-28-25 11:27 PM
I'm seeing it again.
|
13518657, Seen it 3 times. Posted by PROMO, Tue Apr-29-25 09:52 AM
Immediate cop when it's for sale and then to watch 5 more times.
Really interested to see how awards season treats this when it's that time, because it SHOULD win A LOT.
|
13518671, I thought it was pretty good Posted by csuave03, Tue Apr-29-25 11:45 PM
I’m not a big movie goer and pretty much saw it on the strength of it being an unapologetically Black film.
It was cool. I think this is the first Ryan Coogler film that I’ve seen; I may have to check some of his other work. Although this may be to only movie that has what I’m looking for
|
13518689, did you see Black Panther or Creed 3? Posted by Hot_Damali, Wed Apr-30-25 10:59 AM
|
13518692, No, from what I understand they were good Posted by csuave03, Wed Apr-30-25 12:20 PM
They didn't catch my attention like Sinners did before seeing it
|
13518685, Great movie Posted by Lurkmode, Wed Apr-30-25 10:39 AM
Coogler putting in work.
Michael Harriot did a deep dive on the ContraBand Camp
Ryan Coogler's 'Sinners'
A deep dive into the Black history embedded in Ryan Coogler's magnum opus.
https://www.contrabandcamp.com/p/primary-sources-the-black-history
|
13518690, Thanks for the link Posted by luminous, Wed Apr-30-25 11:13 AM
|
13518691, Welcome Posted by Lurkmode, Wed Apr-30-25 11:28 AM
|
13518728, Thanks, this was a good read Posted by csuave03, Thu May-01-25 04:06 PM
Crazy that Rick Ross, Ike Turner, and Nate Dogg are from Clarksdale
|
13518733, Welcome Posted by Lurkmode, Thu May-01-25 06:53 PM
Yeah that was crazy.
|
13518767, Solid read. Posted by 3CardMolly, Sun May-04-25 04:20 AM
I was watching reviews via yt on Sinners and a few kept pushing sympathy for Remlick, noting how his country was once enslaved and he just wanted to get back to his roots in Ireland. So glad this article didnt go that route but further exposed or reminded us of the devils being exactly who them devils are.
Haven’t seen a reviewer speak on it but I feel Sinners also touched on the “cookout pass” that too many of us were willing to welcome in whites for the appropriation of our style or for giving a word in how anti-racist they are and pointing out the obvious evils of their people that we already know.
Oddly I couldn't help but think of Drake and Eminem. Drake’s always appeared as a hollow shell, consuming as many Black styles/spirits etc as possible to create his look/sound etc.
Eminem just showed how thirsty Black boys and men were for a white connection, even If it stemmed from hatred of women. Em was much like Remlick in the jig song scene, telling about his hard times to those that had it just as hard and made worse by him, in order to receive their worship of him.
Both received an abundance of n-word passes, never giving recognition to the Black communities they leeched from. In both cases most Black women weren’t fooled by them but for the Black women that did welcome them they were either belittled, ran through or existence dismissed. That last not being so bad at all.
One final thing, my grand would always say ‘when people show you who they are, believe them’. It was interesting that despite Smoke holding his brother’s dead body, seeing and hearing him change into something else, he was willing to step through the doorway. Even the asian lady was going to go when her husband’s image arrived yet couldnt understand why he stood calmly as big dude tore through the drunk guys body. It was kind of a ‘not us, but them’ moment. Once she realized there was nothing left for her that meant everyone else had to feel her pain too. Very much a white adjacent thing to do when you want the agency of Black folks. Also very white-ish of her to not recognize that the vamps getting Sammie was the goal and reason none of the them left.
|
13518773, I agree with your post Posted by Lurkmode, Mon May-05-25 08:02 AM
Those yt reviews that you mentioned, "sympathy for Remlick" crazy.
Yep way too many passes for those who don't deserve it.
>I was watching reviews via yt on Sinners and a few kept >pushing sympathy for Remlick, noting how his country was once >enslaved and he just wanted to get back to his roots in >Ireland. So glad this article didnt go that route but further >exposed or reminded us of the devils being exactly who them >devils are. > >Haven’t seen a reviewer speak on it but I feel Sinners also >touched on the “cookout pass” that too many of us were >willing to welcome in whites for the appropriation of our >style or for giving a word in how anti-racist they are and >pointing out the obvious evils of their people that we already >know. > >Oddly I couldn't help but think of Drake and Eminem. Drake’s >always appeared as a hollow shell, consuming as many Black >styles/spirits etc as possible to create his look/sound etc. > >Eminem just showed how thirsty Black boys and men were for a >white connection, even If it stemmed from hatred of women. Em >was much like Remlick in the jig song scene, telling about his >hard times to those that had it just as hard and made worse by >him, in order to receive their worship of him. > >Both received an abundance of n-word passes, never giving >recognition to the Black communities they leeched from. In >both cases most Black women weren’t fooled by them but for >the Black women that did welcome them they were either >belittled, ran through or existence dismissed. That last not >being so bad at all. > >One final thing, my grand would always say ‘when people show >you who they are, believe them’. It was interesting that >despite Smoke holding his brother’s dead body, seeing and >hearing him change into something else, he was willing to step >through the doorway. Even the asian lady was going to go when >her husband’s image arrived yet couldnt understand why he >stood calmly as big dude tore through the drunk guys body. It >was kind of a ‘not us, but them’ moment. Once she realized >there was nothing left for her that meant everyone else had to >feel her pain too. Very much a white adjacent thing to do when >you want the agency of Black folks. Also very white-ish of her >to not recognize that the vamps getting Sammie was the goal >and reason none of the them left. >
|
13518696, One of the best Hollywood blockbusters in years. Posted by Frank Longo, Wed Apr-30-25 01:40 PM
It's everything so many bigger budget movies these days aren't. It has vision. It has meaning. It has personality. It has a lived-in world. The sets are real, the relationships are real, the fear is real. It's funny, it's sexy, it's scary, it's sad-- it's got everything.
Coogler's the real deal. One of the best big-budget filmmakers working today. And I'm overjoyed he's using the clout he's built up over the years to make a movie that is very clearly personal and, from a $90 mil budget movie standpoint, quite audacious. How many other filmmakers today are doing something like that music sequence in the middle? On this budget?
Just really fantastic work. Thrilled he got a chance to make this, and beyond thrilled it's been a big success at the box office. We need more movies like this.
|
13518758, Just left the theater, an outstanding film experience Posted by Adwhizz, Fri May-02-25 06:58 PM
Great hybrid of Period piece, Drama, horror, musical and action.
They did such a good job establishing the universe and character that halfway through you forget it's a horror movie until a jump scare occurs
|
13518769, I liked it Posted by kwez, Sun May-04-25 02:40 PM
But I'm assuming it's actually meant to be seen on IMAX because I wasn't as blown away as most reviewers were.
|
13518770, i saw it in Imax i felt like i was IN the movie Posted by BrooklynWHAT, Sun May-04-25 05:22 PM
|
13518771, saw it in IMAX and Dolby. Posted by PROMO, Mon May-05-25 12:31 AM
didn't matter the format.
FIRE, either way.
Also, while the IMAX was good, I don't think it was THAT much better than Dolby to the point where you should feel like it was the format that wasn't doing it for you.
sounds like you just didn't like it as much as most.
|
13518772, It was shot with iMAX cameras Posted by Numba_33, Mon May-05-25 07:57 AM
|
13518775, Super Dope. Coogler's relationship with his audience is inspiring. Posted by Buddy_Gilapagos, Mon May-05-25 11:27 AM
Like Hollywood is scratching it's head at the success of an original Rated R vampire movie but from the first trailer I knew that everyone I know was going to want to see it in the theater and that turned out to be the case. Even my sister-n-laws who hate Horror movies were there because they knew Coogler and MBJ was going to serve themsomething satisfying and no one else is really delivering. Reminds me of Early Spike but more commercial.
I really enjoyed the film....but whish Jonathan Majors played one of the brothers rather than the VFX twinning.
********** "Everyone has a plan until you punch them in the face. Then they don't have a plan anymore." (c) Mike Tyson
"what's a leader if he isn't reluctant"
|
13518788, 81 DUN's response is even dumber after you see the movie Posted by Boogie Stimuli, Mon May-05-25 10:42 PM
|
13518791, Definitrly a jumping of the gun Posted by 3CardMolly, Tue May-06-25 06:13 AM
I wish to see it in IMAX yet the one IMAX theater in Chicago was closed last year.
|