I thought about Midnight Mass but I wasn't getting a good vibe on its potential from the trailer. Since it's gotten some support here, I might check it out.

We've gone through:
Malignant
Escape Room 2
Quarantine (I'd seen it before but they hadn't, surprisingly good for a few jump scares)

On Deck:
New Candyman
Don't Breathe 2
New Season of Locke and Key on Netflix (10/22)
The Resort
World War Z might get a revisit

Thinking about doing 1-2 of these:
Incarnate
The Vatican Tapes
Deliver us From Evil
The Rite
The Possession
The Possession of Hannah Grace

I told them they couldn't watch Exorcist (GOAT horror film IMO) until next year in High School so this would be an intro for them lol